Re: Christian Abortion Hypocrisy
I am not saying humans are the only life, i am simply saying humans are a type of life (superior because we have souls, but that is not the topic of this thread).
YOU ARE EXHIBITING STUPID PREJUDICE, essentially saying that human life is the only type of life that matters. But since other entities can say a very equivalent thing about themselves, the result of such Stupid Prejudice is
this. LOGICALLY, it is much better to claim that personhood matters most, regardless of the entity that has it (and as I mentioned before, it is provably impossible for unborn humans to have personhood).
I am saying though, that I think it is wrong to classify an unborn child
IT IS WRONG TO CLASSIFY AN UNBORN HUMAN AS A "CHILD".
Here's the proof of that. YOU are more similar to a newborn baby than any unborn human is similar to a newborn baby.
NOT NECESSARY. All that matters is, neither the lobster nor the unborn human qualifies as a person.
WRONG QUESTION. Since humanness is irrelevant and has nothing to do with personhood. Only personhood matters. Therefore, the correct question is, "how are unborn humans not persons?" And The Answer Is: They cannot exhibit any characteristics different from the characteristics exhibited by ordinary animals. Meanwhile, actual persons can exhibit characteristics that ordinary animals cannot match.
Here is a significant amount of information about that.
And your scenario is interesting to me. I believe that what you are referring to as "Me the person" is my conscience, correct?
NOT QUITE. Basically, a person is a mind. The body is irrelevant. That's why True Artificial Intelligences will eventually qualify as persons (because of their minds), and that's why various extraterrestrial aliens can be expected to qualify as persons (because of their minds), and that's why, after decades of research,
various scientists have claimed that dolphins qualify as persons (because of their minds). Meanwhile, unborn humans don't have person-class minds, period. They only have animal-class minds (or no minds at all, such as during the earliest development stages, before the brain begins to exist).
If so, that serves (to me) to prove that I have a conscience, and something more enduring than a body. But I digress.
YOU HAVE A PERSON-CLASS MIND. That's what matters.
We must answer at what point humans are alive, I think, to answer this.
NOT IN THE SLIGHTEST. Life has absolutely nothing to do with personhood. Consider various fantasy stories that include ghosts. Ghosts are disembodied persons, right? Not biologically alive, but still able to interact with others in a person-class way (as described in those fictions, anyway).