• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Quarantine the infectious

Would you be okay with getting locked up for 14 days if it stopped the virus in two week's time?

  • Need more info

    Votes: 7 16.3%
  • Yes, quarantine me

    Votes: 31 72.1%
  • No, don't quarantine me

    Votes: 5 11.6%

  • Total voters
    43
  • Poll closed .
Yes, they learned their lesson from SARS and MERS and were able to get government out of the way of progress. Question is, will the people you blindly vote for allow us to do the same in this country?

Do they have wet markets, and are therefor anticipating possible outbreaks, or are they observing China and brace themselves?
 
Other than possibly North Korea, what government on earth would manufacture their own tests? Governments always contract with private manufacturers for the production of tests and vaccines (though the development of them is often publicly funded).

How South Korea Scaled Coronavirus Testing While the U.S. Fell Dangerously Behind — ProPublica

BTW, Trump could have approved the use of the WHO tests back in January with an executive order. He could have then used the Defense Production Act to compel suppliers to produce them.
You seem unaware that we initially had to rely on CDC-developed tests that had to be sent back to the CDC in Atlanta to be analyzed.
 
Only if I volunteered. But that kind of defeats the purpose... we already have self-quarantine.

The question is "Would you be willing … " so, in effect, would you agree to self isolate? That seems to me to fulfil, not defeat, the purpose.

(I'm 26 days into self quarantine. My m0tivation is, perhaps, 90% self preservation and 10% altruistic.)
 
Do they have wet markets, and are therefor anticipating possible outbreaks, or are they observing China and brace themselves?
They were originally predicted to have the largest outbreak outside of China... trying to avoid a repeat of past failures, they kicked things into high gear.
 
The question is "Would you be willing … " so, in effect, would you agree to self isolate? That seems to me to fulfil, not defeat, the purpose.

(I'm 26 days into self quarantine. My m0tivation is, perhaps, 90% self preservation and 10% altruistic.)
It also says "getting locked up" which doesn't sound like self-quarantine.
 
Yes, they learned their lesson from SARS and MERS and were able to get government out of the way of progress. Question is, will the people you blindly vote for allow us to do the same in this country?

So just doubled down on not understanding things beyond the bumper sticker eh?
 
It also says "getting locked up" which doesn't sound like self-quarantine.

I took that to mean 'getting locked into one's home'.
 
I took that to mean 'getting locked into one's home'.
I'm in that category more or less. I spend a lot of time outdoors in the yard, but have only been in the car once the past 2-3 weeks to pick up a pizza.
 
So just doubled down on not understanding things beyond the bumper sticker eh?
I can't help you much beyond suggesting that you try to read up on the topic and educate yourself.
 
More info needed, er, the quarantine won't stop the virus in 2 weeks, rather, the virus will be stopped when a vaccine is found.
 
So in Korea, Taiwan and Singapore, if you were found to have a fever, the government would quarantine you for 14 days. No physical contact with another human.

This combined with self distancing like we do in America effectively stopped the virus in its tracks. Korea, Taiwan and Singapore are virus free.

Would you be okay with getting locked up for 14 days if it stopped the virus in two week's time? If you were infected?

People have to be tested first to ID infection.
The idiot Trump administration and the FED can’t get testing to all who need it.
In addition, labs are way behind in reading results of given tests.
You can’t lock up those you can’t identify.
 
So in Korea, Taiwan and Singapore, if you were found to have a fever, the government would quarantine you for 14 days. No physical contact with another human.

This combined with self distancing like we do in America effectively stopped the virus in its tracks. Korea, Taiwan and Singapore are virus free.

Would you be okay with getting locked up for 14 days if it stopped the virus in two week's time? If you were infected?

They are not locking people up. They are confining them to their homes though and using electronic monitoring to do it. We may need to do the same when we get the number of infected down with SD. But first we need the testing capability to identify those who are contagious.
 
You seem unaware that we initially had to rely on CDC-developed tests that had to be sent back to the CDC in Atlanta to be analyzed.
The initial batch of tests did not work and were recalled.
 
False OP poll - not even considering the practical questions of is it even possible, which it would not be by an measure. "Lock them up" where? Would you work at such a location with you given nothing but an N95 mask and nitrile or latex gloves once a day?

"Would it be ok to lock up everyone on earth in solitary confinement - no exceptions - if it stopped the virus in 14 days?" would be closer to accurate, but not really even that would work.

It is amazing that most people are voting yes. Alarming and sickening is more accurate.

It confirms that the power of the super rich thru their MSM, press and internet they totally own and control is now unlimited in the United States But people totally consumed in fear and hate experience lose of all mental capacity. The nation IQ of the peasant of the United States is now below that of the threshold of mental retardation. The USA is now truly an idiocracy.
This post is much more ignorant than your made-up fools.
 
People are stupid. Most now actually believe that a covid-19 test both a vacine and a cure.

Tens of millions of people in the USA are carrying covid-19. Most suffer little to no harmful effects. Some are already past being infected. The valid of the test is if someone is sick, they can determine if it is covid-19 or not.

What a stupid ****ing post.
You have no idea what anyone else thinks.
Your also have no idea of the number of infected people.
You are neither an expert in communicable diseases nor a soothsayer.
What a waste of time this post is, as usual.
 
Like getting locked up by the "Pre-crime Unit" in the movie Minority Report.

Remember the line: "Everybody runs?"
COVID-19 is serious business, and Kills Americans.
It is not a reason for cutsie little movie quotes.
 
The initial batch of tests did not work and were recalled.
That came next. At first, everything was done at the CDC. The next step was to send out kits. Some of the kits worked, most did not. They had to remanufacture the reagants - while that was going on, all testing had to again go through the CDC in Atlanta.
 
People have to be tested first to ID infection.
The idiot Trump administration and the FED can’t get testing to all who need it.
In addition, labs are way behind in reading results of given tests.
You can’t lock up those you can’t identify.

The real waste of tests is attempting to test everyone for coronavirus. That's, at least, 350,000,000 tests.
 
Stay well.:peace

I am working 7 am to about midnight every day and night - none of which I want or need to do because of this - and none if was even my job - and all employees are working overtime - for you because we are the #1 supplier of two considered "critically essential" covid-19 products. For one of those we are the highest volume manufacturer by far. For both, no matter who it is bought from, it very likely actually it came from us wholesale, private labeling for other companies or bulk.

When this first hit we experienced an increase in sales over 2,000% in the first 24 hours. Day 3 as it continued to grow massively - with waves of furious and panic calls - we ended all sales just to catch up, while deciding whether to reopen at all. We don't want this and don't need it. Rather, why not just give the employees a year's pay and shut it all down? Permanently. Throw all it away fast as possible, lock the doors and walk away? We know some other businesses that already have done so. But, then, that is one goal of this anyway - eliminate all brick and mortar businesses other than of the wealthiest corporations.

We went back up out of a sense of some social duty, but actually I have no empathy/sympathy whatsoever for any of you other than children - and then blame their parents and grandparents. So we are again considering just permanently closing. We owe none of you anything, nearly all of you are in this situation for total irresponsibility, recklessness, amoral and immoral reasons, for which I see Americans - nearly all Americans - as slavery profiteers not different than slave owners - and I see nearly all of you as fools and chumps lacking the rationality of chimpazees because they don't destroy themselves and their territory in the jungle.

Simply, I am not being safe to stay welland giving away days of my life I'll never get back for you, no me. I rapidly think doing so is both foolish and wrong. It might even be unethical to help anyone this way. People should bear the consequences of their own actions and inactions. Americans did this to themselves and all reasons are stupid, amoral and immoral reasons - and have no intention of ever stopping either.

Would you voluntarily work double shifts 7 days a week - all for money you absolutely do not need - to protect white slave profiteers who are sitting safely at home among all their non-white slave labor and imported stuff they so treasure as their measure of happiness so much they are willing to die for it? Willing to kill my family and I to have it too?

That is the question I am considering. But, then, I did not grow up to 24/7 TV infomercials of the wealthiest corporations and people on earth - because all that is on TV, all that is on what you call "news" stations. FOX, CNN, MSNBC, ABC, NBC, CBS and the reason are all owned and totally controlled by a dozen or so of the wealthiest people on earth. Their singular interests is profit. Therefore, everything you see on TV - anything, comedy, sit-coms, news, all of it, is infomercials every second - though they will take money selling time so others can buy time for their 15 to 30 commercials. All the rest of time it is their commericals. The 24/7 every day "news" in covid-19 is 24/7 corporate infomercial for their profit.

:peace
 
Neil Young's got some great lines to that effect, in "On the Beach":






Thanks Chomsky!

Love me some Neil Young. I get a LOT of play from his songs when I'm sitting around the campfire. His signature voice is hard to emulate. And I'm sure my friend's get a good laugh at me trying to. LOL!
 
I am working 7 am to about midnight every day and night - none of which I want or need to do because of this - and none if was even my job - and all employees are working overtime - for you because we are the #1 supplier of two considered "critically essential" covid-19 products. For one of those we are the highest volume manufacturer by far. For both, no matter who it is bought from, it very likely actually it came from us wholesale, private labeling for other companies or bulk.

When this first hit we experienced an increase in sales over 2,000% in the first 24 hours. Day 3 as it continued to grow massively - with waves of furious and panic calls - we ended all sales just to catch up, while deciding whether to reopen at all. We don't want this and don't need it. Rather, why not just give the employees a year's pay and shut it all down? Permanently. Throw all it away fast as possible, lock the doors and walk away? We know some other businesses that already have done so. But, then, that is one goal of this anyway - eliminate all brick and mortar businesses other than of the wealthiest corporations.

We went back up out of a sense of some social duty, but actually I have no empathy/sympathy whatsoever for any of you other than children - and then blame their parents and grandparents. So we are again considering just permanently closing. We owe none of you anything, nearly all of you are in this situation for total irresponsibility, recklessness, amoral and immoral reasons, for which I see Americans - nearly all Americans - as slavery profiteers not different than slave owners - and I see nearly all of you as fools and chumps lacking the rationality of chimpazees because they don't destroy themselves and their territory in the jungle.

Simply, I am not being safe to stay welland giving away days of my life I'll never get back for you, no me. I rapidly think doing so is both foolish and wrong. It might even be unethical to help anyone this way. People should bear the consequences of their own actions and inactions. Americans did this to themselves and all reasons are stupid, amoral and immoral reasons - and have no intention of ever stopping either.

Would you voluntarily work double shifts 7 days a week - all for money you absolutely do not need - to protect white slave profiteers who are sitting safely at home among all their non-white slave labor and imported stuff they so treasure as their measure of happiness so much they are willing to die for it? Willing to kill my family and I to have it too?

That is the question I am considering. But, then, I did not grow up to 24/7 TV infomercials of the wealthiest corporations and people on earth - because all that is on TV, all that is on what you call "news" stations. FOX, CNN, MSNBC, ABC, NBC, CBS and the reason are all owned and totally controlled by a dozen or so of the wealthiest people on earth. Their singular interests is profit. Therefore, everything you see on TV - anything, comedy, sit-coms, news, all of it, is infomercials every second - though they will take money selling time so others can buy time for their 15 to 30 commercials. All the rest of time it is their commericals. The 24/7 every day "news" in covid-19 is 24/7 corporate infomercial for their profit.

:peace
Fascinating.
Yet another painfully unintelligent post devoid of any facts and rife with uneducated opinion.
Fascinating.
Now you are a production telecommunications expert.
How do you find the time?
Obviously your news source is the Teletubbies.

PS - did you also participate in the Underground Railroad?
 
Yes, we have far too many government regulations and hurdles in place. They were able to incorporate the private sector almost immediately. Lesson learned. We need to work on deregulation.

Yeeehaw! Screw them regya-layshuns! Gimme liberty or gimme a horrible, painful death! FREEDUMB!! :elephantf :2usflag: :elephantf
 
You seem unaware that we initially had to rely on CDC-developed tests that had to be sent back to the CDC in Atlanta to be analyzed.

We did not have to rely on CDC tests. They chose to rely on them. They could have just as easily used the WHO tests as a blueprint as other countries opted to do.
 
You need tests to test if someone is infectious but asymptomatic.

Where are 500 million test kits coming from? How is testing to be enforced? How will this work in the Barrios and Ghettos? And of course deal with the anti-vaxers, their lawyers and the constitutionalist who say forced testing is a dictatorial exercise of police powers and their lawyers? How often will everyone be tested?
 
Back
Top Bottom