Greatest QB's of All-Time

[ecofarm]

Ken Stabler and Jim Plunkett

Ray Guy

 

[Bodi]

Where will Mahomes wind up?

Mahomes has to do well for another decade and a half... I am wary of these stellar first couple of year players.

 

[Jay59]

Mahomes has to do well for another decade and a half... I am wary of these stellar first couple of year players.

Of course. However, greatness rarely takes long to present.

 

[Peter King]

You're higher than giraffe ***** if you think Drew Brees barely makes the cut when he outpasses literally everyone else on that list.

Did he also "out win" everybody on that list? Didn't think so.

 

[Court Jester]

A great quarterback leads his team to championships...

There can be only one.

I think that is far too simple of a conclusion.

Based on that thinking one of the greatest batters in baseball history was not "great" because his team never won a championship during the many years he played.

Talking about this guy:

For my money I put John Elway at the top of the list. Other QBs have come along to have greater stats, but few were ever as exciting as 'the comeback kid'.

 

[VanceMack]

I think that is far too simple of a conclusion.

Based on that thinking one of the greatest batters in baseball history was not "great" because his team never won a championship during the many years he played.

Talking about this guy:

For my money I put John Elway at the top of the list. Other QBs have come along to have greater stats, but few were ever as exciting as 'the comeback kid'.

The QB position is unique. It is the leadership spot on the team. All the heat...all the glory. And come on...9 Superbowls in 20 years...winning 6 of them.

For the same criteria you gave for Elway...the comeback wins...is readily matched by Brady.

But its all opinion.

 

[Bucky]

The QB position is unique. It is the leadership spot on the team. All the heat...all the glory. And come on...9 Superbowls in 20 years...winning 6 of them.

For the same criteria you gave for Elway...the comeback wins...is readily matched by Brady.

But its all opinion.

But he cheated, that's a fact.

 

[VanceMack]

But he cheated, that's a fact.

He broke your heart.

The rest remains as silly today as it was then.

 

[calamity]

ALL-TIME

1. Joe Montana
2. John Elway
3. Aaron Rogers
4. Peyton Manning
5. Johnny Unitas
6. Tom Brady
7. Steve Young
8. Dan Marino
9. Drew Brees
10. Brett Favre

I have no problem with that list.

 

[calamity]

Ken Stabler and Jim Plunkett

Ray Guy

Bob Griese was my favorite QB as a kid. He didn't make Bodi's list tho

 

[Rexedgar]

Bob Griese was my favorite QB as a kid. He didn't make Bodi's list tho

Billy Kilmer and Sonny Jorgensen; they would bar hop on Saturday night and play Sunday afternoon.......

 

[SenorXm/Sirius]

Can't put Favre on a top 10 list.

Just can't. He threw too many Ints, too many BAD Ints..

 

[Jack Hays]

Can't put Favre on a top 10 list.

Just can't. He threw too many Ints, too many BAD Ints..

Only the third best QB in Packers history.

 

[Dayton3]

ALL-TIME

1. Joe Montana
2. John Elway
3. Aaron Rogers
4. Peyton Manning
5. Johnny Unitas
6. Tom Brady
7. Steve Young
8. Dan Marino
9. Drew Brees
10. Brett Favre

I would say Tom Brady given that of the 19 Super Bowl victories on this list as starting QB, Brady owns 6 of them.

 

[Top Cat]

#9 Jim McMahon

You can't be serious.

 

[Top Cat]

But he cheated, that's a fact.

NOW you say he cheated?

 

[Top Cat]

You're higher than giraffe ***** if you think Drew Brees barely makes the cut when he outpasses literally everyone else on that list.

Higher than giraffe *****?

 

[Top Cat]

Mahomes has to do well for another decade and a half... I am wary of these stellar first couple of year players.

I suspect before all is said and done Russell Wilson will be on it.

 

[Bodi]

I suspect before all is said and done Russell Wilson will be on it.

Could be...

I would say Tom Brady given that of the 19 Super Bowl victories on this list as starting QB, Brady owns 6 of them.

That is like saying Robert Horry is better than Michael Jordan...

 

[Higgins86]

Could be...



That is like saying Robert Horry is better than Michael Jordan...

Only if you are comparing Robert Horrys and Brady's contribution to their perspective teams.

 

[Top Cat]

It was between Otto and Favre.

Bart Starr should be in the conversation.

 

[JustHanging]

ALL-TIME

1. Joe Montana
2. John Elway
3. Aaron Rogers
4. Peyton Manning
5. Johnny Unitas
6. Tom Brady
7. Steve Young
8. Dan Marino
9. Drew Brees
10. Brett Favre

Warren Moon definitely deserves consideration. From wikipedia:

Moon was in the top five all-time when he retired for passing yards, passing touchdowns, pass attempts, and pass completions

and that was after losing the first six years of his NFL career, and being limited to the teams he could play for, because he was black.

 

[JustHanging]

I suspect before all is said and done Russell Wilson will be on it.

I think it would be better to say "probably should be on it", but playing for a small market NW team is going to make it real difficult. He's just not going to get as much of the league hype. For example, all the experts were so familiar with Wilson and the Seahawks, most thought Denver would win the SB.

 

[Dayton3]

Could be...



That is like saying Robert Horry is better than Michael Jordan...

Are you suggesting that Tom Brady was carried by the Patriots rather than the other way around? You do realize I would hope that at least a couple of those Super Bowl champion teams Brady played on were the underdogs in the game.

 

[Top Cat]

Warren Moon definitely deserves consideration. From wikipedia:

Moon was in the top five all-time when he retired for passing yards, passing touchdowns, pass attempts, and pass completions

and that was after losing the first six years of his NFL career, and being limited to the teams he could play for, because he was black.

Had he not gone to the CFL out of UW, he would be a lock