• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Young People Really Are Stupid

India is much less industrialized than the US so being 4th in the world is a horrible record. They aren't really doing much about it. Most all of the plastic in the ocean also comes from Asia and Africa but the environmentalists don't even talk about that.

Factoid --
China, Indonesia, Philippines, Thailand, and Vietnam are dumping more plastic into oceans than the rest of the world combined , according to a 2017 report by Ocean Conservancy.
 
It only matters who pollutes most to the extent that they foul the environment not to the extent that they will bring on some climate calamity. So, people here illegally should get free healthcare which law abiding citizens pay for. Really? That's a position you want to run on? I hate to tell you but that's DOA. The GND estimates are between 30 and 90 trillion dollars. The total current budget is $4 trillion. Do the math. That aside, the idea that we should destroy the fossil fuel industry, probably the biggest wealth generator we have, is total insanity. It's also impossible as we have nothing to replace it with.


No, illegals shouldn't get anything free from the taxpayers other than a bus ticket home. Then, the magnet that draws illegals here has to be ended. We do that by enforcing the law against hiring them.

Your math is equal to your science it seems. Throw out a few impossibly big numbers, and you have an argument. What are those figures based on, though? How is the GND going to cost 90 trillion? Why not just say 90 gazillion, since the number is based on thin air anyway?

As for the fossil fuel industry, that can't be suddenly ended of course, but it will end sooner or later. The Earth is not creating any new fossils, after all, and petroleum will eventually have to go the way of whale oil.
 
Factoid --
China, Indonesia, Philippines, Thailand, and Vietnam are dumping more plastic into oceans than the rest of the world combined , according to a 2017 report by Ocean Conservancy.

True, and expecting something different from areas where there is no real water treatment systems would be idiocy. If the world works together to provide clean water in these areas, those plastic figures would drop immediately.
 
They'd cost as much as $90 TRILLION dollars and utterly destroy the economy. Only leftist children can't figure this out.

That is your idea of the cost (source please), what is your estimate of the revenue produced?
 
The greatest wealth generating system in history is the exact system that has resulted in creating the climate crisis we are involved in. Your description of making the poor richer would require growing the pie, and that requires continuing to grow the system we haven't been able to control.

LOL. The Earth warms and cools. It has done so many times, even before man was on the planet. Get over it.
 
1 It that's the case, then:
2. it doesn't matter who is polluting the most, as it has no effect anyway.
3. Giving free health care to, say, 10 million illegals will cost trillions, or hundreds of thousands per illegal. Wow, that' some health care.
4. Fewer trillions than we're spending now on the current health care system,
5. The Green New Deal is a non binding resolution to try to curb greenhouse gasses, which you don't believe have any effect on climate anyway. Why would it cost "20 times the federal budget?" Those figures appear to have been picked out of the air.

Is it a requirement of all conservatives that they reject modern science and basic mathematics?

You know darn well that the Green New Deal would cost trillions of dollars. They want to redo every building in the US from shanties to skyscrapers. EVERY building. Then they want to build massive clean trains everywhere so that they can get rid of airplanes. The left believe that money grows on trees.
 
All of your claims require something more than your opinion. Here is an example, China does pollute more than the US, but India doesn't. You can say it, but it doesn't make it true.

The left need to prove that rising temps are actually due to man and not just one of the normal cycles the planet has gone through many times. It may very well just be a coincidence that today's rising temps just happen to be happening during the same time as the industrial revolution. You can't prove that that is not the case.
 
Most of those green energy and climate proposals would boost the economy and create more jobs, just like FDR's new deal. They would not end capitalism, despite your chicken little claims.

There are not enough workers to do the jobs open now.
 
Young people are nowhere near as stupid as Trump supporters. History is proving that in realtime.
 
Well that's not what you said in your earlier comment is it? Environmentalists are talking about it, and where do you suppose the majority of that plastic is produced?

Who cares where it's produced? What matters is the countries that are irresponsible in disposing of it.
 
What is gnd? Does less than 9% of our GDP sound like our biggest wealth generator to you? Not me. Time to update your sources...

GND is green new deal. Any idea that we can eliminate fossil fuels is lunacy. It's not happening.
 
There are not enough workers to do the jobs open now.

Many people have dropped out of the workforce and have stopped looking. Many are underemployed and working outside their skillset.
 
Many people have dropped out of the workforce and have stopped looking. Many are underemployed and working outside their skillset.

Every level of employment in the US is looking for workers. There aren't enough now. The only ones who have dropped out of the workforce are those who truly do not want to work. There is no reason for anyone to be working outside their skillset. You need to quit reading the liberal talking points and look at reality.
 
No, illegals shouldn't get anything free from the taxpayers other than a bus ticket home. Then, the magnet that draws illegals here has to be ended. We do that by enforcing the law against hiring them.

Your math is equal to your science it seems. Throw out a few impossibly big numbers, and you have an argument. What are those figures based on, though? How is the GND going to cost 90 trillion? Why not just say 90 gazillion, since the number is based on thin air anyway?

As for the fossil fuel industry, that can't be suddenly ended of course, but it will end sooner or later. The Earth is not creating any new fossils, after all, and petroleum will eventually have to go the way of whale oil.

Anybody with even moderate ability can figure out that all the lunacy called for by the GND will cost many trillions of dollars. (Retrofitting every building in America, for example:shock:) As for fossil fuels, they will run out sometime but the enviro-nuts want to destroy the industry NOW. IOW, set us back 100 years in a matter of months. Who the hell is going to vote for that? Are people really this stupid, or just brainwashed?
 
That is your idea of the cost (source please), what is your estimate of the revenue produced?

It's not going to produce any revenue because it can't possibly be done. It's economically impossible, not to mention insane.
 
Anybody with even moderate ability can figure out that all the lunacy called for by the GND will cost many trillions of dollars. (Retrofitting every building in America, for example:shock:) As for fossil fuels, they will run out sometime but the enviro-nuts want to destroy the industry NOW. IOW, set us back 100 years in a matter of months. Who the hell is going to vote for that? Are people really this stupid, or just brainwashed?

I think what you're concerned about is the Republicans' version of the Democrats' platform.

The GND is a non binding resolution to reduce the use of fossil fuels. It is a statement of a goal.
 
GND is green new deal. Any idea that we can eliminate fossil fuels is lunacy. It's not happening.

Thanks for the info. The idea that we can't eliminate fossil fuels had better be untrue. Fossil fuels are a nonrenewable energy source that will eventually run out. Before that happens the cost of extraction will make its continued use economically unsound (based on current technologies).
 
You know darn well that the Green New Deal would cost trillions of dollars. They want to redo every building in the US from shanties to skyscrapers. EVERY building. Then they want to build massive clean trains everywhere so that they can get rid of airplanes. The left believe that money grows on trees.

Keep jabbering about the cost, but stop ignoring revenue. Everything you complained about will generate revenue as well as having a cost.
 
Who cares where it's produced? What matters is the countries that are irresponsible in disposing of it.

With no production, there would be no disposal issue. Why do we use single-use plastic? It is efficient and cheap. Time to start charging plastic manufacturers the true cost of their products.
 
With no production, there would be no disposal issue. Why do we use single-use plastic? It is efficient and cheap. Time to start charging plastic manufacturers the true cost of their products.

Without electricity, nobody would ever get electrocuted. Without cars, nobody would die in car crashes. Plastic is here to stay and the answer is holding countries accountable that are polluting the oceans with it.
 
Without electricity, nobody would ever get electrocuted. Without cars, nobody would die in car crashes. Plastic is here to stay and the answer is holding countries accountable that are polluting the oceans with it.

Why not charge businesses the actual cost of their product? The time of allowing businesses to profit off of destruction of the environment is coming to an end. You've stated your support of unbridled capitalism, true capitalism would reward companies with the most competitive product, not the one that can sell it cheapest because they are using our 'commons' without our permission.
 
Back
Top Bottom