- Joined
- May 22, 2017
- Messages
- 4,098
- Reaction score
- 1,991
- Location
- Henderson, TX
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Centrist
I saw HOSTILES.
It was pretty good except in certain parts where they threw logic out the window and went with how modern people would react instead of how they would have reacted in the 1890's. As an example;
SPOILER ALERT:
1. In the beginning a farmer is in his house and 5 "injuns" appear on a hill only about 150 yards directly in front of his house, overlooking his house.
A. no farmer would have built his house on a downward slope like that. He would have built it up on the hill so he could have a view of anyone approaching, kept the water drainage out, kept any snow slides out, and been much drier.
2. The "injuns" attack on horseback and Hollywood has him run out of his house shooting a Winchester 73 in the standing position. Very unstable and he is outnumbered five to one. Dumb, dumb, dumb.
A. Any farmer of the day would have told his wife, " Hey, Babe, we are gonna get five new ponies in just a few seconds when these inexperienced injuns come riding down on me in an open field". Why? The farmer would have steadied his aim against the window and wall frame and gotten good steady shots on each one as they came on. Wifey would have had the shotgun they all had and dealt with any that might have gotten too close. A Winchester 73 holds something like 10 or 14 rounds of 44-40 ammo. Having a steady hold he would have made short work of all of them, and with quick follow up shots.
A Not too detailed spoiler alert:
They also seemed to pick some bad guys out of the air and introduce them purely for the intent of killing off some of the principles.
They did that twice.
It was pretty good except in certain parts where they threw logic out the window and went with how modern people would react instead of how they would have reacted in the 1890's. As an example;
SPOILER ALERT:
1. In the beginning a farmer is in his house and 5 "injuns" appear on a hill only about 150 yards directly in front of his house, overlooking his house.
A. no farmer would have built his house on a downward slope like that. He would have built it up on the hill so he could have a view of anyone approaching, kept the water drainage out, kept any snow slides out, and been much drier.
2. The "injuns" attack on horseback and Hollywood has him run out of his house shooting a Winchester 73 in the standing position. Very unstable and he is outnumbered five to one. Dumb, dumb, dumb.
A. Any farmer of the day would have told his wife, " Hey, Babe, we are gonna get five new ponies in just a few seconds when these inexperienced injuns come riding down on me in an open field". Why? The farmer would have steadied his aim against the window and wall frame and gotten good steady shots on each one as they came on. Wifey would have had the shotgun they all had and dealt with any that might have gotten too close. A Winchester 73 holds something like 10 or 14 rounds of 44-40 ammo. Having a steady hold he would have made short work of all of them, and with quick follow up shots.
A Not too detailed spoiler alert:
They also seemed to pick some bad guys out of the air and introduce them purely for the intent of killing off some of the principles.
They did that twice.