I heard some columnist say that if Roger Ailes were still alive, he would have restrained Fox News from becoming the Trumpischer Boerbachter.
Fox IMO is just the worst of the bunch for their editorial content. All of the News Channels are IMO for crap. My opinions of the big three as follows.
Fox:
Generally decent News Coverage when they do news coverage. Most glaring failing, covering man bites dog stories when they simply do not want to cover a real news story AT ALL. But then you get to their evening broadcasting and they are more off the rails than anybody else. Utter trash broadcasting even for editorializing and they make me wonder if their "decent" news coverage is a means to an end, providing a lead in to their nighttime whack job stuff.
CNN:
Cropping actual video and editing actual news audio in such a way as to bias it is not beyond them AT ALL. Their nighttime editorial stuff is not as strident and whacked out as Fox but it is only IMO marginally better. I would actually prefer the Fox standard as to news in simply not covering a story that they don't want to cover as opposed to cropping and editing actual news.
MSNBC:
Pretty even handed for news though I should have mentioned at the top that none of these channels engage in much news gathering. They depend on WAPO, NYT, the Trib, LAT and the wires for their news and they editorialize off of it. Sometimes they will take "news" from their networks but the channels are not news gathering. Anyway, they are not bad for news and when they screw up a news piece an actual news piece, they tend to admit it. That is more than I can say for CNN.
It is worth paying attention to how each of the big three lines up its evening hosts. I will use MSNBC as an example.
Mathews is OK sort of. He has lost his fastball and it shows. Makes sense he gets the 7PM slot or no slot at all.
Chris Hays is next and he is decent if not a bit lacking in an actual knowledge base to work from. He is typical of the younger News Channel host. He is topical, attractive, urban, not too bright. Must have missed some college classes.
Maddow though much maligned in these pages is pretty sharp. She is an excellent Columnist able to cut a through-line through the dots AND do it such that it is understandable to her audience. She is a nighttime News Channel gem. She does sometimes go off on something she should not go off on and that is where she deserves criticism. Its rare though. She is a logical thinker which is what allows her to take a bunch of dots gathered by reporters, throw them on her desk and find the through-line. Very impressed with the way her mind works.
Lawrence O'Donnell to me is a disaster. The Left's and MSNBC's version of Hannity. That is all I got on O'Donnell. If it were my decision to make I would either move or fire O'Donnell.
Brian Williams deserves a better slot unless MSNBC thinks it vitally important that they have a steady hand to close out the news cycle going from 11 to 12 midnight. If that is what they were shooting for in Williams that is what they have.