• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Iraqi TV Reports Strike Kills Powerful Iranian Revolutionary Guard Commander

Yes, in that post the poster was advocating for the murders of millions of innocents. I think after being pressed he backed off to Felis' position: just leadership.

But, the original post was clear as a whistle and it was disgusting and hopefully representative of a tiny minority opinion among us Americans. However, the Trump years have shaken my certainty of the size of that minority.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yes, the actual ****ing post I was responding to WAS clear as a whistle and i make no apologies for my response to THAT post.
 
We are in a No Deal reality, buddy. We killed their #3. They're not coming to the table. We need to consider killing Khamenei before he responds.

I mean I'm 32 years old, well beyond the draft age. I've lived a good life, still have a few goals but I guess if those were to be interrupted by a nuclear holocaust it wouldn't bother me too bad.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I mean I'm 32 years old, well beyond the draft age. I've lived a good life, still have a few goals but I guess if those were to be interrupted by a nuclear holocaust it wouldn't bother me too bad.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 
Is the Orange Oaf hellbent on starting an armed conflict with the second strongest armed forces in that region? And then I am not talking about the legality of it, if Iran would do something to that to a US general it would be a certain act of war.

And to put oil on the fire, the response of the Orange Oaf is the US flag.

Look I hate Iran and everything it stands for with their religious extremism, but actively killing their leaders is a surefire way to start a war. Is this a way to divert attention from his US problems with the impeachment and does he think starting a war in an election year would be a smart election plan?

It may have been a good decision in 2004 to not change leadership during a war with George W. Bush but Trump is no Bush. The man has a streak of lack of self control and a habit of making very bad decisions.

This unnecessary escalation will not sit well with Iraq, Syria, Russia and maybe even China who all are either friendly with Iran or who have a vested interest in not starting a war in that region.

All in all, not a smart of sound move IMHO. Hopefully in both countries moderate voices and tactics will prevail.
 
Moderate voices in Iran prevailed during the Iran deal. The GOP proved them to be wrong and proved the hard liners correct. Is that what you like doing with your vote? Proving theocratic hard liners correct?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

You keep talking about these mythical moderates among the Mullah's.

Got a list of names?
 
America will receive zero support from Western Europe ... Iran is entitled to retaliate against America anyway it deems fit .... Iran is not Iraq and now that it's 2020 the sanctions against Iran from buying Jet aircraft are not long from being lifted
 
Those countries did get pretty heavy assistance. Iran doesn’t have that.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Do you actually believe the Russians and Chinese wouldn't flood Iran with hardware and supplies in the event of an armed conflict with the US?
 
First, let's note that Afghanistan has seventy women elected to provincial office and women have run for national office.

And it's still a government that will fall apart within a year of us leaving.
 
The greatest lie that we were led to believe is that there are (1) "moderate" voices in the Iranian government and, even if there were,

There was actually, a very brief moment between September 11, 2001 and January 29, 2002 where we cooperated repeatedly with the Iranians because like us they had a grudge against both the Taliban and Saddam's Iraq. Then Bush labeled them as part of the Axis of Evil and that disappeared.
 
The bad leaders of Iran understand only one language: Force. That's why it doesn't mess with Israel.

(Just imagine if England and France had had the guts to do the same in the 1930s to a very bad man in Germany. The world would have been spared so much misery.)
 
The most surprising aspect is Trump immediately taking personal credit when he might have let suspicions linger and keep the U.S. role officially under wraps for awhile. Could lead you to think this careful, modest guy is really a bit of a showoff. But I guess bragging about it will help calm the waters.
 
Let that be a lesson to people who are plotting to kill Americans. I hope he suffered a bit before biting it...but I'm guessing he didn't even have time to blink.
 
The most surprising aspect is Trump immediately taking personal credit when he might have let suspicions linger and keep the U.S. role officially under wraps for awhile. Could lead you to think this careful, modest guy is really a bit of a showoff. But I guess bragging about it will help calm the waters.

I think the message is clear....plot to kill Americans and you will be hamburger by the morning. I don't thinkTrump is going on any apology tour anytime soon do you?
 
Trump promised to get us out of the ME quagmire... Another Trump lie.

And Trumpsters are of course happy Trump lied to them and there's a possibility of having a war with Iran.. Maybe Trump will make these so called 'Christians' really happy by getting us into a war with North Korea too. HAPPY NEW YEARS people!!!
 
I think the message is clear....plot to kill Americans and you will be hamburger by the morning. I don't thinkTrump is going on any apology tour anytime soon do you?

Yeah, right. Was only saying he couldn't wait to tell the world, "It was ME!". Maybe this time it was actually the right thing to do.
 
How likely is it for Iran to consider this an act of war?

I would say that the Iranian government has been in a low level state of war with us for years, so, that would suggest they would indeed see this act as a continuation of that.

I don’t foresee this situation calming. We are sending in troops to protect the embassy. Why not remove everybody from the embassy? I wouldn’t want to be there

Well, I wouldn't suggest a career in the State or Defense Departments, then :).

Removing our embassy would have been a huge self-inflicted loss for the U.S., a huge win for Iran, and would have taught them that they could remove us at will from our relationship with countries they sought more control over by attacking our embassies there. The primary intent of this action wasnt to be calming, but rather to ensure that they learned a very different lesson regarding our likely future reaction to any other attacks on US facilities and personnel.

Sent from my Moto G (5S) Plus using Tapatalk
 
Trump promised to get us out of the ME quagmire... Another Trump lie.

And Trumpsters are of course happy Trump lied to them and there's a possibility of having a war with Iran.. Maybe Trump will make these so called 'Christians' really happy by getting us into a war with North Korea too. HAPPY NEW YEARS people!!!

Obama promised to end the war in his first year in office and liberals sucked it right up.

 
“Tis all a Chequer-board of nights and days
Where Destiny with men for Pieces plays:
Hither and thither moves, and mates,and slays,
And one by one back in the closet lays.”

The Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam, Edward Fitzgerald.
 
And if we do fight Iran face to face, it's just gonna turn into an utter **** show as their whole game plan is just gonna be to bog us down and cause major causalities in hopes that we peace out due to the public not wanting to be at war.

Personally, when it comes to war with Iran, I'll take "Hard Pass" for $500 Alex.

I dont think its gonna flare up into a hot war. More like low level tit for tat conflict.
 
Assassinations of foreign government officials have been illegal in the United States since President Ford issued Executive Order 11905 in 1976. That EO was reaffirmed by both the Carter and reluctantly by the Reagan Administration EOs. That is why the CIA was charged with conducting deniable clandestine assassinations with drones for the last 20 years or so. But this time the drone strike which killed many Iranian government officials and security personnel was admittedly ordered by the President, carried out by the Pentagon and executed by US military drone operators. The US President and senior US military brass have broken US law and should be legally liable for these killings both criminally and civilly. It is a dark day when the US Military openly operates as assassins instead of the clandestine secret services. So here's another article of impeachment for the House to investigate.

Cheers.
Evilroddy.
 
Regardless of who wins this, the Iraqi people are going to lose.
Iraqi Nationalism isn't fond of Idealism influence, either. Perhaps, to the extent that there is an "Iraqi people", they could come out of this less dominated. It's probably unlikely, though.

Sent from my Moto G (5S) Plus using Tapatalk
 
Technically, the US can do a cheap and quick war with Iran - quickly bomb it into Stone Age and wait for new leadership to emerge. If we don’t like that leadership - repeat.
No need to do nation building. That was Bush’s mistake in Iraq.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Just nation destroying it is then, same as ever. Your nonchalance for something so horrific really is abhorrent to witness imo
 
Back
Top Bottom