My analogy is fine and here's why: Hitler did not begin the Holocaust with cattle cars. He started it with a campaign promise to fight birth defects.
I did not challenge your earlier analogy based on what you now say was or is me claiming Hitler began the holocaust with cattle cars.
Here is what I stated in challenge to your analogy:
"First of all capitalize the J in Jew. Secondly your analogy is a crock of shit. When Jewish people and others were forced onto cattle cars to their deaths most did not know the fate that awaited them. For you to use planned extermination of people jammed into train cars as the same scenario of ignorance as to Americans now faced with tariffs is odious. People have full access to the policy of tariffs, the use of tariffs, the pros and cons of tariffs, and most importantly this policy is not being used to target the death of a specific type of American."
You tried to make some ridiculous analogy as to the ignorance of Jews as to their knowledge of the full extent of the holocaust with American citizens now being ignorant and I explained why using the word Jew with a small J and the analogy made no sense and in fact trivialize the victims of the holocaust as being in the same position as current Americans are in regards to Trump policies.
Americans have access on public domain to all the negative consequences of what Trump is doing whether it be with his Trump tariff, his Epstein cover up, his other comments and policies-Jews did not have the legal or political rights Americans to do today to challenge and hold their leader accountable not to mention a free press.
You clearly did not understand that and now go off trying to argue with me as to the origins of the holocaust which has nothing to do with your half assed attempt to create an analogy between Jewish victims of the holocaust and people who question Trump.
Next you now express even more ignorance. The T4 program and the holocaust are two distinct phenomena. They are not one and the same and in history when we study them we take care to make sure when we discucss the T4 policy we explain not just its parallel them of defining targeted persons as not worthy of life but the different manners and reasons for how they were created and then implemented. The holocaust or shoah as it is called in Hebrew refers to the system slaughter of all Jews. In regards to the systemic slaughter of the mentally disabled or other targeted groups such as the Jehova's Witnesses,7th Day Adventists, Roma people. gays, political prisoners (soclalists. communists, Christian Democrats) their killings are all studied as having happened during the holocaust but they are all referred to distinctly as a sign of respect so as not to have them compete in significance or consequence. Each one for its own unique reasons is studied and honoured and while similar demonization thought processes are studied far different traits, consequences are also studied so as not to trivialize any of them.
Christopher R. Browning. The Origins of the Final Solution: The Evolution of Nazi Jewish Policy, September 1939-March 1942. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2004. 640 pp. $39.95 (cloth), ISBN 978-0-8032-1327-2. Reviewed by Hilary Earl (Department of History, Nipissing University) Published...
networks.h-net.org
T4 Program, Nazi German effort—framed as a euthanasia program—to kill incurably ill, physically or mentally disabled, emotionally distraught, and elderly people. Adolf Hitler initiated the program in 1939. It was officially discontinued in 1941, but killings continued covertly until the defeat...
www.britannica.com
Do me a favour stop referring to both the T4 program and holocaust. They have nothing to do with this thread.