2016 didn't feature any beauties, that was for sure. I don't think it was greatness seen in Trump neither. It may have been folks being dissatisfied by the business as usual routine. Our elected officials kowtowing to corporations, wall street firms, lobbyists, special interests, mega money donors, doing and taking care of those who provided them most of the money for campaigns. Regardless of party. With Trump, as a friend of mine said, we opted for the devil we didn't know, Trump being a businessman, a reality TV show host, not a career politician, we didn't know how he would govern or if he would kowtow and be business as usual. He was politically, a totally unknown. We opted for the devil we didn't know over the devil we did. Everyone knew exactly how Hillary Clinton would govern, exactly what to expect from her. She even promised to be a third Obama term. You couldn't get anymore business as usual than that. With all the name calling and negative personal attacks, I didn't see much substance at all in 2016.
Perhaps the question now becomes, are the people happy with their choice? To find that answer, I'd throw Republicans and Democrats out of the equation. Concentrate on independents, the more or less non-partisan group that make up roughly 45% of the electorate. At least according to Gallup and Pew Research. We know what most independents think about Trump's character, his personality, his shall I say, uncouth persona. I think Trump has lost quite a lot of them. Remember Trump won the independent vote 46-42 over Clinton with 12% voting third party.
Back at the end of January 2017 independents gave Trump a 36% approval vs. 28% disapproval with most independents, non-partisan sitting on the sidelines waiting to see how he would govern. Question 34 shows 35% of independents not sure on his job approval.
http://d25d2506sfb94s.cloudfront.net/cumulus_uploads/document/pyonz5d0lq/econTabReport.pdf
Today or as 5 June 2018, Trump job approval among independents is 33% approve, 51% disapprove, Question 67.
https://d25d2506sfb94s.cloudfront.net/cumulus_uploads/document/dtt00zl5up/econTabReport.pdf
The vast majority of independents accounting for the 23 point rise in disapproval of Trump came from those who were originally sitting on the sidelines waiting to make up their minds. Not sure now have dropped to 16% down from 35% at the end of January 2017. If independents are split on the issues or closely split, then what is it. Why so many now disapproving of Trump?
63% of independents think Trump is arrogant, only 17% of indies think Trump is sincere, 17% think Trump is honest and 21% think his use of twitter appropriate. Then take a look at questions 78 and 79 from the link above and you'll see why independents have moved from the not sure into the disapproval column.
Are you optimistic or pessimistic about the next few years with Donald Trump as President? Independents only, 32% optimistic, 41% Pessimistic.
Do you want Donald Trump to run for re-election in 2020? Independents only, 26% yes, 52% no.
I kind of think independents have moved from being tired of business as usual to being or becoming tired of Trump and his obnoxious personality. substance or no substance, perhaps that doesn't matter.