• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

DACA For The Wall?

DACA For The Wall?


  • Total voters
    51
DACA as Democrats propose it is essentially an open border. Is the locks on your doors and windows on your house and car door locks "metaphorical?" Eliminate them and just put up a security camera. No one, ever, would go past any security camera. They should only use security cameras for all prisons as walls and fences are totally worthless and a waste of money.

Again, you are not entitled to your own facts.
 
First order of compromise is, the hostage drama ends, the government reopens and STAYS open, employees get PAID, and then we can start talking about walls.
Otherwise no deals of any kind.
I'm not sure it will end that way, but I very much agree. Never reward hostage takers!
 
How will the $5.6 billion will be spent? Steel or concrete? Made by whom? At how much a section? How high/deep/wide? How deep does it go into the ground? Who are the contractors? Has the choice been tested by DHS? Environmental studies? If steel does it rust? Open bidding process? Penalties for worker injuries and behind schedule? Where exactly are the panels going to placed? Any effects on the Rio Grande River or underground aquifers? Is everything USA? What are the QC parameters?

etc. etc. etc.

No one knows anything. Yet Trump wants $5.6 billion and we'll do this on the fly. Typical Trump incompetence.

That's why is looks, sounds and smells exactly like an episode of The Apprentice, which means it is 100 percent

bovine excrement.webp
 
Speaking of Grumpy old men...
View attachment 67248070
Being into Chevy, this was always my guy:


smokey-yunick-engine.jpg
 
House dems do not negotiate ( in good faith) until the govt is reopened. House Dems only negotiate ( in good faith) with their republican counterparts in Congress. Trump is liar, a cheat and a turncoat. One does not make deals with such men. Let McConnell and friends handle the man-child in the oval office. Its their honor and integrity at stake which of course he will trample on, further dividing and isolating two wings of the party as each points fingers. There will be no attainable deal under this administration but bit by bit piece by piece bills will pass that reopen the govt under the radar over the course of the year, until there is little left of this shutdown.


The real problem that the right has not figured out, is that if this wall in whatever form, is built as a win for Trump, and it still has no broad base of support, its coming down very soon after he leaves office. Dems will do to the wall what pubs did to Obamacare. Dems that do not promise to take down that wall, will not win primaries. The base will not tolerate the symbols of appeasement. With his burn bridges tactics he will be so anathema that no part of his legacy will not have to be blown away, such is the hatred he ingenerates.
 
Last edited:
Being into Chevy, this was always my guy:


smokey-yunick-engine.jpg

That was Smokey Yunick...name always made me chuckle and think "eunuch" but he knew his stuff!
I was a fan of Grumpy Jenkins, got to even hang out with him a few times.
 
How long is this wall going to take anyway? Trump could be run out of office in a few months, or voted out in 2020. Projects like this can take forever and the costs keep going up. He can get a few billion to dig a few post holes now but who will continue the job? Does Pence care enough to chase it up? A possible democrat taking office after 2020? Who will keep asking for and chasing up the money to continue the project once the whole MGA thing has blown over?
 
Only if he reopens the government FIRST.
AND KEEPS IT OPEN, not just some three week nonsense.
This nonsense stops now.

Simple solution. Democrats agree in principal to DACA for a physical wall and Trump reopens the government and they negotiate the details. He would do that. Chuck and Nancy are on record as saying no physical wall. Zero, Zip, Notta.
 
By making this offer, he's not only holding the Federal Employees hostage with the shutdown, he's holding the DREAMers hostage for the wall.

If the wall cannot pass on its own merits and you need this many hostages, perhaps you should reconsider the wall.

I vote no on your poll. On a related topic: I do not negotiate with terrorists.
 
Simple solution. Democrats agree in principal to DACA for a physical wall and Trump reopens the government and they negotiate the details. He would do that. Chuck and Nancy are on record as saying no physical wall. Zero, Zip, Notta.

Trump has already ruled out trading DACA for a wall. More than once.
 
False. Enough dems supported that compromise but trump was being an unbalanced wishy washy hack and his GOP senate doesnt move anything to his desk unless trump has approved the bill in advance so they do not look like fools or lose political capital. The same problem exists now. McConnell wont allow the bill that they voted for a month ago get back to the floor becaus trump is signaling he wont support it. In a lot of these situations, look no further than the fail leader trump.

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk

False?

FALSE?

It was voted on on the House and shot down. EVERY Democrat and 41 anti-Trump Republicans voted against it. How the hell is that Trump's fault?

https://www.rollcall.com/news/politics/house-rejects-conservative-immigration-bill
 
Simple solution. Democrats agree in principal to DACA for a physical wall and Trump reopens the government and they negotiate the details. He would do that. Chuck and Nancy are on record as saying no physical wall. Zero, Zip, Notta.

They might have been persuaded had it not been for Trump's hostage drama. I say "might have" because at this point, Trump has disinvited himself from any and all negotiations.
It is fitting that Pelosi has disinvited him from giving his petulant State of the Union speech, as written, of course, by Herr Stephen Miller.

I understand Chuck and Nancy's position as it stands right now, but what you might not understand is, Trump squandered all his political capital with the both of them because of his unhinged antics.
 
Back
Top Bottom