• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

— So Police Take Away All His Guns and License to Carry

The M240 is one of the best weapons I've had the pleasure to fire and is a staple weapon throughout the military. SpecOps use SCARS, which are 7.62mm, with a full-auto option. Most miniguns mounted on helicopters are 7.62mm.

And the British don't use single action only firearms.

Please only post true statements.

Please read what I post and I was in the British Army for 15 years (1986-2001).

In 1982 (the year of the Falkland Conflict) the standard rifle - the SLR - was single action ONLY (though I was told a strategically placed matchstick turned it into full auto but that involved illegal stripping of the weapon).

Though as discussed with the GPMG, it did have automatic weapons.
Alongside the GPMG we also has the SMG (sub-machine gun).
Special forces did have access to all kinds of weapons

The SLR was replaced in the late 80's with the hated L85 SA-80 which was selective fire.


What statements were not true ?
 
...you need a good dog to flush them into the air so they can be shot, and then to find them once they drop into the snow after being shot...

In the UK, it's tradional for grouse to be directed toward the gun butts by locally hired seasonal "beaters". The Queen's son Prince Edward once famously shot a beater and was forced to sell his (expensive) guns


...baiting game is illegal in Alaska. Spruce grouse have a very distinctive call, and they tend to be very vocal...

What does that mean, the tree chair is illegal ?
You might not believe this but I've seen an add for a remotely aimed gun in the tree chair...there's companies that will collect your shot game, butcher it and deliver the choice cuts to your door. All that remains is to make the remotely aimed gun totally automatic and the "hunter" will not have to worry about a thing until his doorbell rings with the meat.

...before I was allowed to go deer hunting myself, my father made me clean and prepare his deer first. I was 12 years old at the time....

At that age the only "gun" I ever shot was a .22 air rifle at empty tin cans



...we were broken down into three four-man teams per squad (12 people + 1 Squad Leader). There was usually one heavy-weapons squad per platoon....

When I transferred out the infantry was adopting a "lesson" from the 1982 Falklands Conflict. An 8 man section/squad was to field two machine guns...in those days the expected enemy was the Red Horde coming West. In later years we learned the Russians were utterly convinced the West was hell bent on invading them!


...Steve McQueen was a former Marine. He joined the Corps in 1947 when he was 17. He ended up serving as part of the Honor Guard protecting President Truman’s yacht....

I didn't know that
He always looked the part in uniform.


...other than the Beretta (which has a factory in the US, so it really doesn't count as "foreign" even though it is an Italian designed firearm), the only foreign firearm that I have fired was the MG42. Even that was just for a few short bursts...

I got to shoot a genuine Soviet built AK47 (actually an AK-74)

We were shocked when the US military dropped the .45 caliber for its pitols. After I left, the British army retired the 9mm Browning "Hi-Power" for 9mm Glocks.


...there is a private heavy-weapons club here in Alaska that gets together during the Summer that puts on public live fire demonstrations of heavy weapons. They even allow the public to fire their weapons, for a price. They have a wide variety of machine guns, including a WW I Lewis gun from your neck of the woods. They also have a number of mortars, but their biggest weapon is the 105mm Howitzer. The last time I attended they wanted $400 to fire one of those 105mm rounds, and you didn't get to keep the brass.

Wow a WWI Lewis gun.

I have a CCW but my interest in guns is just for classics from the two world wars.

I'd love to shoot a BREN gun and a STEN (my father's weapon in WWII).
 
What does that mean, the tree chair is illegal ?
You might not believe this but I've seen an add for a remotely aimed gun in the tree chair...there's companies that will collect your shot game, butcher it and deliver the choice cuts to your door. All that remains is to make the remotely aimed gun totally automatic and the "hunter" will not have to worry about a thing until his doorbell rings with the meat.
You cannot feed the wildlife in Alaska. Not only is it illegal, it will also get you instantly fired from most jobs if you are caught feeding the wildlife. The last thing these businesses want is for the wildlife to start associating them with food.

I'm not sure what you mean by your "tree chair" reference. Deer and bear hunters will regularly hang out in trees waiting for their game to come by. It is a good strategy, because you need to disturb your surroundings as little as possible. While I don't climb into trees, I do sit silently for between 30 and 45 minutes when I first begin my hunt, just listening and observing. You can't just go crashing through the brush and expect to get a decent shot. Everything within a mile of you will disappear. You have to be patient and trick the game into believing that you aren't really there.

At that age the only "gun" I ever shot was a .22 air rifle at empty tin cans
I had been hunting with my father by age 8 using his firearms under his supervision. I received my first firearm from him (a Winchester Model 1912) on my 10th birthday.

I got to shoot a genuine Soviet built AK47 (actually an AK-74)
I forgot. I still own a Romanian-made SKS. I haven't fired it in years. It looked like it had been used extensively, based upon the condition of the wooden stock. I replaced the wooden stock with a synthetic version, but I found the firearm to be terribly inaccurate. At 100 meters I was shooting 6" groups, which is ridiculous. I can shoot 1.5" groups with my Springfield .3006.

We were shocked when the US military dropped the .45 caliber for its pitols. After I left, the British army retired the 9mm Browning "Hi-Power" for 9mm Glocks.
The Marine Corps brought the M1911 back, but they also use of the Glock 19M if they are members of MARSOC.

Marines Allow Operators to Choose Glocks over MARSOC .45s | Military.com

Wow a WWI Lewis gun.

I have a CCW but my interest in guns is just for classics from the two world wars.

I'd love to shoot a BREN gun and a STEN (my father's weapon in WWII).

My interest in firearms is strictly utilitarian. I consider firearms no different than a pair of pliers or a hand drill. It is just a tool.
 
You cannot feed the wildlife in Alaska. Not only is it illegal, it will also get you instantly fired from most jobs if you are caught feeding the wildlife. The last thing these businesses want is for the wildlife to start associating them with food....

Really, I didn't know that.

Even if wildlife comes into your yard ?

Does that include bird seed in bird houses ?

I was told by a family member in Minnesota (where there a huge mosquito problem) that some people keep bats by building a bat house. Apparently a bat can eat up to 1,000 mosquitoes a night.


...I'm not sure what you mean by your "tree chair" reference. Deer and bear hunters will regularly hang out in trees waiting for their game to come by....

A tree chair is literally a chair for "hunters" to fasten half way up a tree trunk and shoot any game that takes the bait.


Rivers Edge Lounger Tree Seat | DICK'S Sporting Goods


You can even get radio controlled rifles so you don't even have to be there and there are companies that collect your kills, butcher it and bring the cut meat to your door.


...I forgot. I still own a Romanian-made SKS. I haven't fired it in years. It looked like it had been used extensively, based upon the condition of the wooden stock. I replaced the wooden stock with a synthetic version, but I found the firearm to be terribly inaccurate. At 100 meters I was shooting 6" groups, which is ridiculous. I can shoot 1.5" groups with my Springfield .3006....

Many Russian / Soviet guns were copied throughout the Eastern bloc...the AK series in particular.
IIRC the Romanian version had a wooden forward pistol grip.


...the Marine Corps brought the M1911 back, but they also use of the Glock 19M if they are members of MARSOC....

And the SIG P226 or is that just the US Army ?


...my interest in firearms is strictly utilitarian. I consider firearms no different than a pair of pliers or a hand drill. It is just a tool.

I view classic guns as similar to my golf clubs.
 
Really, I didn't know that.

Even if wildlife comes into your yard ?
Especially if the wildlife comes into your yard.

Does that include bird seed in bird houses ?
Since the law does not exempt bird-feeders, yes. However, I am not aware of any place that enforces the law in regard to bird-feeders. Bears already come onto people properties to search through their trash, if it isn't secured properly. Why would anyone want to encourage that behavior?

Oh, and if you plant any kind of fruit tree in Alaska, you had better erect a 10 foot wall around it or it won't be there following year. Moose absolutely love fruit trees, and will eat them until only the stumps remain.

In Alaska whenever there is a problem with the wildlife, we relocate the tourist causing the problem. ;)

I was told by a family member in Minnesota (where there a huge mosquito problem) that some people keep bats by building a bat house. Apparently a bat can eat up to 1,000 mosquitoes a night.
If it was a 4.25" wide English Cricket bat, I could believe that. We have a few mosquitoes in Alaska as well. Our mosquitoes, however, are incapable of transmitting diseases. You can't get malaria, West Nile virus, or even heart-worms in pets, from the Alaskan Snow Mosquito. It has glycol in its circulatory system instead of water. It prevents the mosquito from freezing when temperatures drop below freezing, but it also prevents them from carrying any diseases.

A tree chair is literally a chair for "hunters" to fasten half way up a tree trunk and shoot any game that takes the bait.


Rivers Edge Lounger Tree Seat | DICK'S Sporting Goods
Okay, that is what I thought but I wasn't sure. Since it is illegal to bait or feed the wildlife in Alaska I have no problem with anyone sitting in a tree waiting for game to come by. It shows they have enough knowledge to know where and approximately when the game will be arriving. It is really no different than me sitting on a log or rock waiting for the forest to return to normal after I disturbed it.

You can even get radio controlled rifles so you don't even have to be there and there are companies that collect your kills, butcher it and bring the cut meat to your door.
In August when caribou season begins, I call the Park Rangers stationed at Paxson and ask them how far away the herd is from the highway. When they are close enough, I drive the ~3 hours to where the caribou are located. Hike approximately a kilometer from the highway and wait. I'm usually afforded my choice of between 20 or 30 caribou, sometimes more.

Taking the shot is the easy part. After the critter drops the real work begins. I have cleaned game in other states, but in Alaska there is a real sense of urgency. You have at most one hour to clean your kill and get it out of the field before the other predators start showing up. Alaska law prohibits hunters from defending their kill. A dressed caribou will yield about 150 pounds of meat, and unless you are Arnold Schwarzenegger, you are not hauling that out in one trip. Which means you have to leave part of your game by itself, unprotected. That is when the other predators move in.

It is also why I only hunt moose with a partner. A dressed moose will yield 900+ pounds of meat.

And the SIG P226 or is that just the US Army ?
I honestly don't know what the Army uses.
 
Especially if the wildlife comes into your yard....

I would never make it there as I'm a natural animal lover and am always feeding stray dogs and cats
Drives my American wife mad...Must be the English in me


...since the law does not exempt bird-feeders, yes. However, I am not aware of any place that enforces the law in regard to bird-feeders. Bears already come onto people properties to search through their trash, if it isn't secured properly. Why would anyone want to encourage that behavior?

Oh s**t, yes I guess that would focus my mind

I wouldn't want any animal in my back yard that viewed me as lunch
Are you allowed to shoot a bear in your back yard ?


...oh, and if you plant any kind of fruit tree in Alaska, you had better erect a 10 foot wall around it or it won't be there following year. Moose absolutely love fruit trees, and will eat them until only the stumps remain....

And you need to shovel off snow from your roof
Are you from there ?

I wanted to replace a dead tree with an orange tree but we're just too far North for it to survive


...if it was a 4.25" wide English Cricket bat, I could believe that....

You've heard of cricket ?


...we have a few mosquitoes in Alaska as well. Our mosquitoes, however, are incapable of transmitting diseases. You can't get malaria, West Nile virus, or even heart-worms in pets, from the Alaskan Snow Mosquito....

Mosquitoes both here and in Minnesota eat the crap out of you and you're covered in angry red blotches that itch like crazy.


They say it's the state bird in Minnesota


...I have no problem with anyone sitting in a tree waiting for game to come by. It shows they have enough knowledge to know where and approximately when the game will be arriving. It is really no different than me sitting on a log or rock waiting for the forest to return to normal after I disturbed it....

I only have disdain for those so-called "hunters"

...taking the shot is the easy part. After the critter drops the real work begins. I have cleaned game in other states, but in Alaska there is a real sense of urgency. You have at most one hour to clean your kill and get it out of the field before the other predators start showing up. Alaska law prohibits hunters from defending their kill. A dressed caribou will yield about 150 pounds of meat, and unless you are Arnold Schwarzenegger, you are not hauling that out in one trip. Which means you have to leave part of your game by itself, unprotected. That is when the other predators move in....


Isn't refusing to defend your kill not feeding wildlife?


Can you not also "hunt" the wolf that comes by to feed ?
 
I would never make it there as I'm a natural animal lover and am always feeding stray dogs and cats
Drives my American wife mad...Must be the English in me




Oh s**t, yes I guess that would focus my mind

I wouldn't want any animal in my back yard that viewed me as lunch
Are you allowed to shoot a bear in your back yard ?
Only in self-defense or to protect your property. I have moose and bears wandering through my property all the time, but I don't live in town. 99% of the time they are just passing by and don't stop. Once in a while (especially in August when I'm smoking my salmon) I will get a number of curious visitors. I also need to be armed when walking my dogs during the Winter. Wolves love taking pets because they are such easy prey. Fortunately, they only tend to do that when the Winters are particularly bad.

And you need to shovel off snow from your roof
Not where I live. We only average 76" of snow annually. In places like Valdez, AK, their entire homes are completely covered. Valdez averages 305.8" (7.77 m) of snow annually. Driving through the town during the Summer is a rather interesting experience. All of their snow machines are parked on the roofs of their homes. Which looks a bit odd, until you realize that the snow gets to be that deep.

Are you from there ?
I was born in southern California. Lived in Minnesota and Nebraska for awhile, then back to California. I moved to Alaska in 1991 and have never left.

I wanted to replace a dead tree with an orange tree but we're just too far North for it to survive
Apple, cherry, peach, apricot and other fruit-bearing trees will do nicely in your climate.

You've heard of cricket ?
Of course I've heard of it. I've seen the game played, but I couldn't tell you anything about the game. I also played soccer as a kid. But by age 8 I had already dropped it for the Mighty Mites (American) Football League. Soccer was a sport for very young children and girls. I also got into baseball and basketball later in high school.

Mosquitoes both here and in Minnesota eat the crap out of you and you're covered in angry red blotches that itch like crazy.
You learn to ignore them after awhile. If you don't scratch bite they don't become red blotches or itch.

They say it's the state bird in Minnesota
Lower-48 mosquitoes are tiny in comparison to the Alaskan Snow Mosquito. It has been reported that they can drain a caribou of a quart of blood in a week.

Isn't refusing to defend your kill not feeding wildlife?
If you leave part of your kill unattended while you haul parts of it back to your vehicle it could be construed as "baiting." Which I suspect is the reason for why we are prohibited from defending our kill. I never had that problem with caribou or moose. Even my dogs would help carry the meat. However, I did have that problem with regard to salmon. I had a bear come up behind me and steal two of my Silver salmon that I had already caught and cleaned. I didn't become aware of the theft until after the fact. I couldn't even tell you whether it was a brown bear or black bear, because I never saw them. It just meant I had to catch two more Silvers.

Can you not also "hunt" the wolf that comes by to feed ?
No. That would be considered baiting.
 
Only in self-defense or to protect your property....

I guess most people can claim their property was at risk from a bear in the back yard. Are there many incidents of bears attacking people in their back yard ?


...not where I live. We only average 76" of snow annually. In places like Valdez, AK, their entire homes are completely covered. Valdez averages 305.8" (7.77 m) of snow annually. Driving through the town during the Summer is a rather interesting experience. All of their snow machines are parked on the roofs of their homes. Which looks a bit odd, until you realize that the snow gets to be that deep....

Do you have an AWD truck ?

I hate snow, my father made me shovel it every year, I swore I'd never live where I had to shovel that white **** again. In 15 years in the army, I never had to deal with snow

...I was born in southern California. Lived in Minnesota and Nebraska for awhile, then back to California. I moved to Alaska in 1991 and have never left....

Do you pay negative taxes for living there ?

...I also played soccer as a kid....

LOL it's called football (for obvious reasons). My feet are too big to play the game well, I di play rugby


...you learn to ignore them after awhile. If you don't scratch bite they don't become red blotches or itch....

They must like my English blood and I react quite badly to them.
 
Please read what I post and I was in the British Army for 15 years (1986-2001).
So the British have poor training and you think that's somehow relevant to why Ohio lets US veterans use their US discharge papers from the US military when applying for an Ohio concealed carry weapons permit?
 
I guess most people can claim their property was at risk from a bear in the back yard. Are there many incidents of bears attacking people in their back yard ?
Virtually no one has been attacked in their backyard. There are two or three bear maulings every year (typically in May or June) and 90% of the time it is some idiot riding a mountain bike through the forest or the greenbelts in town. The vast majority of the time the idiot survives the mauling.

An even bigger threat than bear, however, are moose. Moose have injured and killed more people in Alaska than bear. Bears are at least rational critters. If you understand dog behavior, then you will have a good understanding of bear behavior. However, moose are simply psychotic. They will attack you for no reason whatsoever. Given that they stand taller than 2 meters at the shoulder and weigh more than 600 kg, they can be a serious threat.

Do you have an AWD truck ?
I own an old four-wheel drive that I use for hauling trash and clearing snow. I don't get many services where I live.

I hate snow, my father made me shovel it every year, I swore I'd never live where I had to shovel that white **** again. In 15 years in the army, I never had to deal with snow
I love Winters in Alaska. It is the only time of the year we get the State to ourselves. During the Spring, Summer, and Autumn there are more than 1.5 million tourists visiting Alaska (more than double its population). Winter is also the second prettiest season, after Autumn. The northern lights reflecting off the snow covered mountains is an awesome sight. The only trick to surviving an Alaskan Winter is to get use to living in the dark.

Do you pay negative taxes for living there ?
Hardly. Technically speaking, Alaskans pay more than any other US citizen in any other State. The cost of State government is more than $17,500 annually for every man, woman, and child living in Alaska. A family of four must pay more than $70,000 annually to the State.

LOL it's called football (for obvious reasons). My feet are too big to play the game well, I di play rugby
It is called soccer in the US, and it is a sport for small children and girls. Rugby is a sport for men, as is American football.

They must like my English blood and I react quite badly to them.
You react badly because you scratch. It is okay to rub the area, or pour cold water on the effected area, or even use anti-itching cream, but never scratch. Scratching always makes it much worse.
 
So the British have poor training...

No, the British Army has the best training in the world


....you think that's somehow relevant to why Ohio lets US veterans use their US discharge papers from the US military when applying for an Ohio concealed carry weapons permit?


No, why would you even think that ?
You didn't mention Ohio, veterans, discharge papers or CCW permits in post #444



You did mention something about only posting true statements, so again:



What statements were not true ?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom