• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

'That sounds like ethnic cleansing': CNN questions lead figure in Israel's settler movement

Ethnic cleansing often fallows sectarian violence.

So where is the US?

Our failure to lead stems from our failure to understand Palestine fell long ago, yet it's people remain homeless.

Palestinian can not exist within the borders of greater Israel. Until we understand that we won't really be able to do much to stop Israel from harming Palestinians.

I know it's ethnic cleansing to move them somewhere else and help them establish the State they desire, but it just is what it is, and moving is better than join Israel or die, which is the choices they have now.
 
nvflash said:
Ethnic cleansing often fallows sectarian violence.

So where is the US?

Our failure to lead stems from our failure to understand Palestine fell long ago, yet it's people remain homeless.

Palestinian can not exist within the borders of greater Israel. Until we understand that we won't really be able to do much to stop Israel from harming Palestinians.

I know it's ethnic cleansing to move them somewhere else and help them establish the State they desire, but it just is what it is, and moving is better than join Israel or die, which is the choices they have now.
Click to expand...

Is Madagascar available?
 
nvflash said:
So where is the US?
Click to expand...

This is a conversation the US should have had with itself many years ago.

The settlers know what they want, the IDF protects them and might arrest one or two in a while but the tide when you look at it over the last 20 years is pretty clear and won't stop.
 
Argent said:
For those who thought that Israeli settlement of Gaza was not the plan. The woman leading the movement says "The Arabs of Gaza lost the right to be in Gaza on the seventh of October."

Click to expand...

It wasn't the plan until October 7th... she makes that very clear.
 
Bodi said:
It wasn't the plan until October 7th... she makes that very clear.
Click to expand...
She lacks credibility for that because the video opens by naming 8 illegal Israeli settlements recognized by the Israeli government that the US opposed. Oct. 7 is the excuse used to re-establish settlements in Gaza which was the intent of those Zionist groups mentioned in the video. At the end of the video a man says "Where ever there are Jewish settlements, there is more security." I am skeptical that an Israeli occupation of Gaza will keep Israelis safe from terrorist groups wishing their extinction.
 
Bok Tuklo said:
Settler terrorist pogroms against Palestinians were in East Jerusalem and the West Bank prior to that.
Click to expand...
Israel needs to remove the Gaza threat.
 
Argent said:
She lacks credibility for that because the video opens by naming 8 illegal Israeli settlements recognized by the Israeli government that the US opposed. Oct. 7 is the excuse used to re-establish settlements in Gaza which was the intent of those Zionist groups mentioned in the video. At the end of the video a man says "Where ever there are Jewish settlements, there is more security."
Click to expand...
Who can blame them. 70 years of being invaded and attacked? I can't believe that Israel has been this patient.
Argent said:
I am skeptical that an Israeli occupation of Gaza will keep Israelis safe from terrorist groups wishing their extinction.
Click to expand...
They have to try though...
 
Imagine a gang in The Valley launching rocket attacks into Los Angeles for years... who actually thinks that SWAT teams would not invading the Valley to eliminate that threat, arrest, lock up?
 
Bok Tuklo said:
Is Madagascar available
Click to expand...
Maybe, but who owns it and what leverage do we have?

The Sinai peninsula is closer and we have leverage over it’s owners.
 
nvflash said:
Ethnic cleansing often fallows sectarian violence.

So where is the US?

Our failure to lead stems from our failure to understand Palestine fell long ago, yet it's people remain homeless.

Palestinian can not exist within the borders of greater Israel. Until we understand that we won't really be able to do much to stop Israel from harming Palestinians.

I know it's ethnic cleansing to move them somewhere else and help them establish the State they desire, but it just is what it is, and moving is better than join Israel or die, which is the choices they have now.
Click to expand...

What is greater Israel?
 
The US should offer Texas as a homeland for Israel. Cede the state to Israel. Get the Jews completely out of the Middle East and let the Islamic majority have it all to themselves. Texas will have the choice to be ex-pats, apply for dual citizenship, or move elsewhere.
 
instagramsci said:
"Israel can have just a wittle bitty ethnic cleansing"
Click to expand...
It isn't ethnic cleansing... there are a couple of million Palestinians LIVING IN ISRAEL
 
Bodi said:
It isn't ethnic cleansing... there are a couple of million Palestinians LIVING IN ISRAEL
Click to expand...
Arabs (no exceptions given by the woman in the video) lost the right to live in Gaza after October 7th is what she said. Removing them because of their ethnic character is... what exactly?
 
instagramsci said:
Arabs (no exceptions given by the woman in the video) lost the right to live in Gaza after October 7th is what she said. Removing them because of their ethnic character is... what exactly?
Click to expand...

Irony.
 
Bodi said:
Israel needs to remove the Gaza threat.
Click to expand...
West bank and east jerusalem isnt hamas.
The settler project of Israel seeks to replace palestinians.
 
Bodi said:
Imagine a gang in The Valley launching rocket attacks into Los Angeles for years... who actually thinks that SWAT teams would not invading the Valley to eliminate that threat, arrest, lock up?
Click to expand...
This is a project that has been continuous since before oct 7. They called it “price tag” terrorism.
 
Bodi said:
It isn't ethnic cleansing... there are a couple of million Palestinians LIVING IN ISRAEL
Click to expand...
She is advocating for ethnic cleansing.
 
instagramsci said:
Arabs (no exceptions given by the woman in the video) lost the right to live in Gaza after October 7th is what she said. Removing them because of their ethnic character is... what exactly?
Click to expand...
She can say what she wants... Being Palestinian is of no consequence.

The fact is they are being removed because of terrorists and because Gaza has always been a terrorist safe haven.
 
bomberfox said:
She is advocating for ethnic cleansing.
Click to expand...
They are not relocating the 2 million Palestinians living in Israel. They are just taking over Gaza and emptying it of terrorists and terrorist supporters.

bomberfox said:
She is advocating for ethnic cleansing.
Click to expand...
...and she is just a lady. She is not the Israeli government.
 
Argent said:
For those who thought that Israeli settlement of Gaza was not the plan. The woman leading the movement says "The Arabs of Gaza lost the right to be in Gaza on the seventh of October."

Click to expand...

And let's assume that's what she's saying.
Who cares? She sets any policy? She was elected into office? Who is she besides a local voice for West Bank settlers, one out of many by the way?
You're basically promoting empty propaganda here.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom