- Joined
- Feb 16, 2008
- Messages
- 10,443
- Reaction score
- 4,479
- Location
- Western NY and Geneva, CH
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Other
Nope. No more than I would expect a French police officer to determine whether or not I spoke French if I were to be arrested in Paris. If you are coming to this country, or even moreso if you live here, and you don't speak the language, YOU GET WHAT YOU DESERVE!!!!
You might, might have a point if English was designated the official language and everyone was required by law to speak it, but neither is true. Furthermore, one of the things we as a nation pride ourselves on is how people come here from other parts of the world to start a new life for themselves -- it stands to reason, barring the aforementioned legal requirements, that some portion of those people aren't going to speak English (or at least speak it well).
Even if this country didn't proudly describe itself as a nation of immigrants and even if fluency in English was required by law, making sure someone understands what you are telling them is a basic (almost atomic) component of communication. There are plenty of circumstances under which someone would simply be too stunned or shocky or otherwise medically incapable of understanding what they're being told, and folks in those situations have Constitutional rights, too.