- Joined
- Aug 8, 2005
- Messages
- 69,427
- Reaction score
- 53,834
- Location
- Los Angeles
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Undisclosed
Originally Posted by RobertU:
My own suspicion is that California is not vigorously enforcing its vehicle smog rules because most of the violators are poor people or undocumented immigrants (although they now are allowed a driver’s license as a document).
The progressives running California would rather inhale bad air than put a burden on “oppressed” people.
Unpaid traffic fines and mushrooming fees have left 4.2 million Californians with suspended driver’s licenses — more than one-sixth of the licenses issued statewide — with poor people the hardest-hit
4.2 million have lost driver’s licenses because of unpaid fees - SFGate
If many if not most of those 4.2 million poor people are defying the law and still driving, I doubt they are going to pay for smog checks on their mostly older cars and will allow their non-compliant vehicles to pollute the air.
This last post leaves me wondering if you even own a car.
California's smog check system is well enforced. The equipment sends smog test result data directly to the DMV office in Sacramento.
If your vehicle passes, you get a certificate. If it fails, you don't, and if you don't, you can't renew your registration. If your vehicle is out of reg for a long enough period, it gets towed when you either have contact with law enforcement or if they notice it on the street. Then, to get it back, you have to pay the tow and impound fees, get a passing smog check and pay the penalties on your old reg and get your new sticker, and THEN they let you drive it again.
Otherwise it stays in impound and is either auctioned off or crushed by the junk man depending on the value.
Auction buyers have to bring it into compliance to drive or sell it. Or they can part it out.
As for the "mostly older cars", the smog laws in California address that as well. If your vehicle is more than twenty-five years old, it becomes mostly exempt. That's because most vehicles older than that are either relatively low mile creampuffs or cherished classics.
There simply aren't very many 1981 Buick LeSabres with 230 thousand miles on them still in operating condition anymore in 2019. It is simple mathematical attrition.
Last but not least, those "older cars" have relatively primitive and relatively simple smog control systems. A catalyst on anything built after 1975 or 1976, an EGR valve, maybe an "air injection reactor" pump, and maybe a warm air intake control valve. Any car that was designed with a carburetor isn't going to have a complex or expensive smog system for the simple reason that it can't. Carburetors don't make complex computer controlled air pollution controls possible.
That is why for the most part, carburetors no longer exist on vehicles built after the mid-1990's.
So, you can choose to "believe whatever you want to believe" but you're talking to a person who not only actually has a fair bit of knowledge of this stuff, but I also have close friends who (A) helped DESIGN some of the air quality/smog control systems, like for Chrysler and Mitsubishi just as one example, and (B) who also have worked FOR the California Air Resources Board.
In fact, I just lost one of my best friends, Paul Donnelly, who did work at the C.A.R.B. up until 2011, when he got sick and retired.
I don't know your age, but if you're younger than forty, you were an infant back when it was impossible to see more than a block because of how bad the smog was out here, so you don't remember how bad it was.
If there's one thing that the State of California has taken more seriously than any other state in the country, it's air quality issues. The other thing we take more seriously than anyone else is earthquake construction and safety regulations and standards.
I moved here in 1982, at the age of twenty-five, so I do remember how bad it was back then.