• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

A Second American Civil War Is Nothing To Look Forward To

Doc91478

Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
Jan 29, 2015
Messages
2,778
Reaction score
790
Location
North East
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Undisclosed
A Second American Civil War Is Nothing To Look Forward To​



https://www.americanthinker.com/blo..._civil_war_is_nothing_to_look_forward_to.html
13 Oct 19 ~ By William Marbury
Similarly, today, it is surprising to hear with what composure, and how glibly, members of the public, and even politicians, talk of a second American civil war. Some conservatives assume that they, having more arms and more training and practice in using them, would quickly prevail over the soy-boy Left.
Proficiency with firearms will be no match for nuclear bombs, which Democrat Eric Swalwell has already suggested deploying domestically.
Suppose that foreign powers intervene. In the situation of the world today, a dominant world power such as the United States cannot have a purely civil war, confined to a struggle between domestic forces. What happens in Washington has so much effect on the wider world that the wider world will try to influence what happens in Washington. Foreign interference in our elections would become foreign intervention in any armed conflict in the United States. Russia, China, Iran, North Korea — in fact, nearly all of America's enemies would likely support the Left and the Democrats. A second American civil war might devolve into a conflict between American patriots and the entire rest of the world, perhaps excluding Israel. In a country like Britain, disputes over which side to support could lead to their own civil war. The best strategy to avoid the danger of a second American civil war is the thorough defeat of the Democratic Party at the ballot box. It must be such a resounding defeat as to permanently discredit and destroy the Democratic Party. (The two-party system would be preserved by the splitting of the Republican party into its two wings.) Else, the Democratic Party is likely to destroy the United States.


Comment:
A civil war is the worst thing that can happen to this nation. There will be no winners and the patrimony of its forebears is squandered and destroyed in the process.
This is true, let's win peacefully next year by the re-election of Trump and hope a second civil war never happens in our great country. But as Trotsky once said, "you may not be interested in war, but war is interested in you," which means that you don't have to choose your enemy because it's enough for him to choose you. That is, war may force itself on us as has often happened in history, and we must be prepared to confront our country's enemies if we must.
Having studied the American, Spanish and English and Russian civil wars, our revolution was closer to a civil war than our civil war. It will NOT be the case this time if it happens.
A shooting civil war must be avoided and should be the absolute last resort. The idea that one can even properly identify an UN-UNIFORMED enemy absent obvious actions is dangerously naïve. Who are you going to shoot? This will NOT be the Blue and the Gray of the first civil war, nor Klingons vs Humans! Every neighborhood in every city and town likely consists of people with varying political beliefs that cannot be discerned by their physical appearance, clothing (except for masked Antifa) or skin color. Exactly WHO is your enemy? How do you determine whether they are sufficiently leftist enough to be considered the enemy? Where do you draw the line? Do you wait for them to shoot at you first? Maybe you need to shoot everyone just to be safe? But seriously, every state in the Union is populated with human beings on the Right, Left and down the Middle, each to varying degrees. You can’t seriously draw battle lines based on the dominant political party of a given city or state. Even the bluest state (like California) contains many conservatives who are on your side. By the way, the Swalwells' of the world advocating nuking conservative gun owners should be straitjacketed and confined to mental institutions.
 
What a “civil” post!
 
This is the Right juicing-up their base, making bogeymen out of Dems.

"Socialists are going to start a (nuclear!) civil war!"
 
This is the Right juicing-up their base, making bogeymen out of Dems.

"Socialists are going to start a (nuclear!) civil war!"

It's amazing how this fantasy excites rightists.

Quote Originally Posted by marke View Post
If traitors in the US amass a large following and corral the military to back them then patriotic Americans might have to take up arms against the traitors just like was done against England.
 
It's amazing how this fantasy excites rightists.

Quote Originally Posted by marke View Post
If traitors in the US amass a large following and corral the military to back them then patriotic Americans might have to take up arms against the traitors just like was done against England.

They do get awful excited about killing their fellow Americans :(
 
"A Second American Civil War Is Nothing To Look Forward To"

Yet the only ones talking about it are Trumpsters...
 
A Second American Civil War Is Nothing To Look Forward To​



https://www.americanthinker.com/blo..._civil_war_is_nothing_to_look_forward_to.html
13 Oct 19 ~ By William Marbury
Similarly, today, it is surprising to hear with what composure, and how glibly, members of the public, and even politicians, talk of a second American civil war. Some conservatives assume that they, having more arms and more training and practice in using them, would quickly prevail over the soy-boy Left.
Proficiency with firearms will be no match for nuclear bombs, which Democrat Eric Swalwell has already suggested deploying domestically.
Suppose that foreign powers intervene. In the situation of the world today, a dominant world power such as the United States cannot have a purely civil war, confined to a struggle between domestic forces. What happens in Washington has so much effect on the wider world that the wider world will try to influence what happens in Washington. Foreign interference in our elections would become foreign intervention in any armed conflict in the United States. Russia, China, Iran, North Korea — in fact, nearly all of America's enemies would likely support the Left and the Democrats. A second American civil war might devolve into a conflict between American patriots and the entire rest of the world, perhaps excluding Israel. In a country like Britain, disputes over which side to support could lead to their own civil war. The best strategy to avoid the danger of a second American civil war is the thorough defeat of the Democratic Party at the ballot box. It must be such a resounding defeat as to permanently discredit and destroy the Democratic Party. (The two-party system would be preserved by the splitting of the Republican party into its two wings.) Else, the Democratic Party is likely to destroy the United States.


Comment:
A civil war is the worst thing that can happen to this nation. There will be no winners and the patrimony of its forebears is squandered and destroyed in the process.
This is true, let's win peacefully next year by the re-election of Trump and hope a second civil war never happens in our great country. But as Trotsky once said, "you may not be interested in war, but war is interested in you," which means that you don't have to choose your enemy because it's enough for him to choose you. That is, war may force itself on us as has often happened in history, and we must be prepared to confront our country's enemies if we must.
Having studied the American, Spanish and English and Russian civil wars, our revolution was closer to a civil war than our civil war. It will NOT be the case this time if it happens.
A shooting civil war must be avoided and should be the absolute last resort. The idea that one can even properly identify an UN-UNIFORMED enemy absent obvious actions is dangerously naïve. Who are you going to shoot? This will NOT be the Blue and the Gray of the first civil war, nor Klingons vs Humans! Every neighborhood in every city and town likely consists of people with varying political beliefs that cannot be discerned by their physical appearance, clothing (except for masked Antifa) or skin color. Exactly WHO is your enemy? How do you determine whether they are sufficiently leftist enough to be considered the enemy? Where do you draw the line? Do you wait for them to shoot at you first? Maybe you need to shoot everyone just to be safe? But seriously, every state in the Union is populated with human beings on the Right, Left and down the Middle, each to varying degrees. You can’t seriously draw battle lines based on the dominant political party of a given city or state. Even the bluest state (like California) contains many conservatives who are on your side. By the way, the Swalwells' of the world advocating nuking conservative gun owners should be straitjacketed and confined to mental institutions.

yea old bitter white guys going into battle wearing their MAGA hats waving their walkers and canes in anger
 
yea old bitter white guys going into battle wearing their MAGA hats waving their walkers and canes in anger

wSp2T49.jpg
 
It's amazing how this fantasy excites rightists.

Quote Originally Posted by marke View Post
If traitors in the US amass a large following and corral the military to back them then patriotic Americans might have to take up arms against the traitors just like was done against England.
Yep. I think some may have never gotten over their defeat in 1865, and are not happy with the social changes that have taken place since then. The GOP love to stoke those fears. So does Trump.
 
Oh, for goodness' sake.

There will be NO "Civil War."


Yes, the liberals/leftists will eventually have complete control over the United States of America.

But that is just how the cookie crumbles.

People who do not want to live in this country in, let's say, the year 2100 will either keep their heads down and do the best that they can under the circumstances, or some (many?) of them will emigrate.(To where? I have no idea.)

We are witnessing one of the biggest changes in the history of the world. One thing for sure: Our great-grandchildren will read with incredulity about what America was like back in 2019.
 
I have said for years that the next civil war will be between the stupid people and the smart people.

It may come to pass sooner than I thought...
 
.....“You know what solves it? When the economy crashes, when the country goes to total hell and everything is a disaster, then you’ll have a, you know, you’ll have riots to go back to where we used to be when we were great,” Trump argued......

‘When the country goes to hell’: 2014 video shows Trump bragging he would ‘crash the economy’ to get his way – Raw Story

President Trump says his impeachment would 'crash' the economy

Donald Trump: Impeachment would 'crash' the economy

Trump: People will ‘revolt’ if he’s impeached

Trump: People will ‘revolt’ if he’s impeached - POLITICO

:elephantf:usflag2:

donald-trump-tweets-2012-1478856552.jpg


 
Yep. I think some may have never gotten over their defeat in 1865, and are not happy with the social changes that have taken place since then. The GOP love to stoke those fears. So does Trump.

~~~~~~
You're right only part way. It was Southern Democrats who were not happy with the Social changes that took place after the Civil War, that's why they created their first "Antifa" called the Ku Klux Klan, segregation and lynching of Blacks, Catholics and Jews.
 
A Second American Civil War Is Nothing To Look Forward To

no kidding. a bunch of old out of shape Trumpsters are bound to shoot their toes off with their machine guns before keeling over from a heart attack. better that they stay home and doze off in front of Hannity and then wake up to post internet tough guy stuff on the intertubes.
 
This is the Right juicing-up their base, making bogeymen out of Dems.

"Socialists are going to start a (nuclear!) civil war!"
Yeah, it's not like the left embraces violence or confrontation at all. :roll:
 
A Second American Civil War Is Nothing To Look Forward To​



https://www.americanthinker.com/blo..._civil_war_is_nothing_to_look_forward_to.html
13 Oct 19 ~ By William Marbury
Similarly, today, it is surprising to hear with what composure, and how glibly, members of the public, and even politicians, talk of a second American civil war. Some conservatives assume that they, having more arms and more training and practice in using them, would quickly prevail over the soy-boy Left.
Proficiency with firearms will be no match for nuclear bombs, which Democrat Eric Swalwell has already suggested deploying domestically.
Suppose that foreign powers intervene. In the situation of the world today, a dominant world power such as the United States cannot have a purely civil war, confined to a struggle between domestic forces. What happens in Washington has so much effect on the wider world that the wider world will try to influence what happens in Washington. Foreign interference in our elections would become foreign intervention in any armed conflict in the United States. Russia, China, Iran, North Korea — in fact, nearly all of America's enemies would likely support the Left and the Democrats. A second American civil war might devolve into a conflict between American patriots and the entire rest of the world, perhaps excluding Israel. In a country like Britain, disputes over which side to support could lead to their own civil war. The best strategy to avoid the danger of a second American civil war is the thorough defeat of the Democratic Party at the ballot box. It must be such a resounding defeat as to permanently discredit and destroy the Democratic Party. (The two-party system would be preserved by the splitting of the Republican party into its two wings.) Else, the Democratic Party is likely to destroy the United States.


Comment:
A civil war is the worst thing that can happen to this nation. There will be no winners and the patrimony of its forebears is squandered and destroyed in the process.
This is true, let's win peacefully next year by the re-election of Trump and hope a second civil war never happens in our great country. But as Trotsky once said, "you may not be interested in war, but war is interested in you," which means that you don't have to choose your enemy because it's enough for him to choose you. That is, war may force itself on us as has often happened in history, and we must be prepared to confront our country's enemies if we must.
Having studied the American, Spanish and English and Russian civil wars, our revolution was closer to a civil war than our civil war. It will NOT be the case this time if it happens.
A shooting civil war must be avoided and should be the absolute last resort. The idea that one can even properly identify an UN-UNIFORMED enemy absent obvious actions is dangerously naïve. Who are you going to shoot? This will NOT be the Blue and the Gray of the first civil war, nor Klingons vs Humans! Every neighborhood in every city and town likely consists of people with varying political beliefs that cannot be discerned by their physical appearance, clothing (except for masked Antifa) or skin color. Exactly WHO is your enemy? How do you determine whether they are sufficiently leftist enough to be considered the enemy? Where do you draw the line? Do you wait for them to shoot at you first? Maybe you need to shoot everyone just to be safe? But seriously, every state in the Union is populated with human beings on the Right, Left and down the Middle, each to varying degrees. You can’t seriously draw battle lines based on the dominant political party of a given city or state. Even the bluest state (like California) contains many conservatives who are on your side. By the way, the Swalwells' of the world advocating nuking conservative gun owners should be straitjacketed and confined to mental institutions.

How about we dump trump and all live together as peacefully as we can?
 
It's gonna be funny when a bunch of Trump's supporters 60yo wives tell them to get home and lock their guns back up.
 
How about we dump trump and all live together as peacefully as we can?


Your TDS overcomes your thoughts. How about you accepting Trump as the duly elected president of these United States of America and wait until November 2020 like all Americans should do....
 
Your TDS overcomes your thoughts. How about you accepting Trump as the duly elected president of these United States of America and wait until November 2020 like all Americans should do....

08JJTps.jpg
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom