• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

New Pro-Obamacare Ad Features Trump Voter

Cigar

Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
Sep 20, 2012
Messages
5,368
Reaction score
2,117
Location
In The Crosshairs
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Very Conservative



A campaign encouraging lawmakers not to repeal the Affordable Care Act will launch two new television ads, with one featuring a man who voted for President Donald Trump.

The ads are part of a “six figure” ad buy from the “Save My Care” campaign that will run in Ohio and Tennessee, according to an advance copy of the press release announcing the ads. Tennessee is home to Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Chairman Lamar Alexander, a key player in the Obamacare debate.

I’m a Republican. I voted for Trump,” says a man identified as Dennis, who is featured in the Tennessee ad. He was diagnosed with esophageal cancer and says in the ad, “The Affordable Care Act saved my life."

The ad running in Ohio features a woman named Paula, who was diagnosed with breast cancer, which spread to her brain and liver. According to the press release, the Medicaid expansion in Ohio under the Affordable Care Act helps her afford her cancer treatment.



New Pro-Obamacare Ad Features Trump Voter


Should I feel sorry for this American ..... ?
 
Should I feel sorry for this American ..... ?

IMO, yes we should as an empathetic society. However, what he shouldn't be is surprised that this is happening. Trump ran on repealing Obamacare so when it is starting to happen this guy shouldn't be surprised.

You get what you vote for, but if the GOP does repeal and doesn't replace the ACA with something viable I predict that many angry voters will return in the midterms to hold their reps accountable and eventually hold Trump accountable in 2020.
 
So does the makers of that ad realize that emotional appeals are not valid arguments? Probably not.
 
So does the makers of that ad realize that emotional appeals are not valid arguments? Probably not.

Life and Death can be Emotional ... we'll all get there someday.
 
Life and Death can be Emotional ... we'll all get there someday.

The issue is that they are purposely trying to manipulate people's emotions to get what they want. Shaping an entire ad campaign around hand picked cases designed to maximize emotional reaction is dishonest and invalid.
 
8 People Who Owe Their Lives to Obamacare


Here are their heartbreaking stories.


President Donald Trump has vowed to dismantle the Affordable Care Act (ACA) — a move that could leave some 30 million Americans without health insurance. ACA literally sustains millions of lives . Without the health insurance it provides, many people wouldn't have access to medicine and procedures that they need to survive. When we asked people on Twitter and through healthcare advocacy organizations to share their stories of how ACA keeps them alive, we were overwhelmed with responses. We heard from people waiting for organ transplants, from cancer survivors, from people with debilitating mental illness, and more. They told us about the toll that disease has taken on their lives: Before the ACA, some were forced to skip treatments because of the price; others couldn't get insurance at all because they were already sick. Here are a few of their stories.



Claudette Williams, 58, Orlando, Florida: I lost my job in 2005. After that I decided to purchase a policy. I found them online. They had a gentleman come to my house, and we talked about my blood pressure medications. The insurance was almost twice what they had quoted me because of the medication, and also because of my condition. I eventually couldn't afford it any more. I was uninsured, except for one year when I qualified for Medicaid. I ended up in the emergency room on a few occasions for heart trouble. I also developed diabetes. I couldn't afford to have regular mammograms. In 2014 I signed up for Obamacare. I was diagnosed with breast cancer in September of last year. The lumpectomy alone was billed at $40,000. I have four more chemo sessions to go, and after that, I have to do radiation. Luckily my cancer is only a stage one, so my prognosis is pretty good. But it is really scary thinking about my insurance being taken away. This is a fight for my life.



Charis Hill, 30, California: When I was 25, in 2012, I had a series of unexplained and undiagnosable respiratory challenges that felt like the flu or bronchitis or pneumonia. Doctors just couldn't figure out what was wrong with me. My condition got worse and worse. I visited urgent care a few times. I thought I was having a heart attack once. They tried to blame it on anxiety.

Eventually reached out to my dad, who was estranged from me. I knew that he had a severe health condition. The first words out of his mouth were, it sounds like you have what I have, which is ankylosing spondylitis (AS). I knew that I would need health insurance to be treated. But if I were to get a diagnosis before getting health insurance, I would have the preexisting condition working against me. So I got the cheapest plan that existed. I wasn't getting all the tests done or getting all the treatments. Then, ten months later, the ACA was implemented, and because of my income, I was eligible for a subsidy to purchase health insurance on the exchange in California. I got a better plan for less than I was paying before, which meant that I could access more treatment and not skip medication.

See the faces of real Americans ... not just a Political Party.
8 People Who Owe Their Lives to Obamacare | Mother Jones
 
8 People Who Owe Their Lives to Obamacare


Here are their heartbreaking stories.


President Donald Trump has vowed to dismantle the Affordable Care Act (ACA) — a move that could leave some 30 million Americans without health insurance. ACA literally sustains millions of lives . Without the health insurance it provides, many people wouldn't have access to medicine and procedures that they need to survive. When we asked people on Twitter and through healthcare advocacy organizations to share their stories of how ACA keeps them alive, we were overwhelmed with responses. We heard from people waiting for organ transplants, from cancer survivors, from people with debilitating mental illness, and more. They told us about the toll that disease has taken on their lives: Before the ACA, some were forced to skip treatments because of the price; others couldn't get insurance at all because they were already sick. Here are a few of their stories.



Claudette Williams, 58, Orlando, Florida: I lost my job in 2005. After that I decided to purchase a policy. I found them online. They had a gentleman come to my house, and we talked about my blood pressure medications. The insurance was almost twice what they had quoted me because of the medication, and also because of my condition. I eventually couldn't afford it any more. I was uninsured, except for one year when I qualified for Medicaid. I ended up in the emergency room on a few occasions for heart trouble. I also developed diabetes. I couldn't afford to have regular mammograms. In 2014 I signed up for Obamacare. I was diagnosed with breast cancer in September of last year. The lumpectomy alone was billed at $40,000. I have four more chemo sessions to go, and after that, I have to do radiation. Luckily my cancer is only a stage one, so my prognosis is pretty good. But it is really scary thinking about my insurance being taken away. This is a fight for my life.



Charis Hill, 30, California: When I was 25, in 2012, I had a series of unexplained and undiagnosable respiratory challenges that felt like the flu or bronchitis or pneumonia. Doctors just couldn't figure out what was wrong with me. My condition got worse and worse. I visited urgent care a few times. I thought I was having a heart attack once. They tried to blame it on anxiety.

Eventually reached out to my dad, who was estranged from me. I knew that he had a severe health condition. The first words out of his mouth were, it sounds like you have what I have, which is ankylosing spondylitis (AS). I knew that I would need health insurance to be treated. But if I were to get a diagnosis before getting health insurance, I would have the preexisting condition working against me. So I got the cheapest plan that existed. I wasn't getting all the tests done or getting all the treatments. Then, ten months later, the ACA was implemented, and because of my income, I was eligible for a subsidy to purchase health insurance on the exchange in California. I got a better plan for less than I was paying before, which meant that I could access more treatment and not skip medication.

See the faces of real Americans ... not just a Political Party.
8 People Who Owe Their Lives to Obamacare | Mother Jones

Which is also an emotional appeal and thus an invalid argument. Is that all the left has to support their law?
 
You think the Un-Affordable Healthcare Act is great? Fine. You can pay my $400/a month premium from the insurance i use only twice a year.

No matter how much Pro-ACA people try to sell it, this thing is the biggest domestic policy disaster since LBJs War on Poverty.
 



A campaign encouraging lawmakers not to repeal the Affordable Care Act will launch two new television ads, with one featuring a man who voted for President Donald Trump.

The ads are part of a “six figure” ad buy from the “Save My Care” campaign that will run in Ohio and Tennessee, according to an advance copy of the press release announcing the ads. Tennessee is home to Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Chairman Lamar Alexander, a key player in the Obamacare debate.

I’m a Republican. I voted for Trump,” says a man identified as Dennis, who is featured in the Tennessee ad. He was diagnosed with esophageal cancer and says in the ad, “The Affordable Care Act saved my life."

The ad running in Ohio features a woman named Paula, who was diagnosed with breast cancer, which spread to her brain and liver. According to the press release, the Medicaid expansion in Ohio under the Affordable Care Act helps her afford her cancer treatment.



New Pro-Obamacare Ad Features Trump Voter


Should I feel sorry for this American ..... ?


Dennis is the only one with a story? I've got a story too and it is one reason why I didn't vote for Hillary.
 
So does the makers of that ad realize that emotional appeals are not valid arguments? Probably not.

The issue is that they are purposely trying to manipulate people's emotions to get what they want. Shaping an entire ad campaign around hand picked cases designed to maximize emotional reaction is dishonest and invalid.

You really should have checked with conservative HQ before going with that narrative. Manipulating people's emotions is really all there is to conservatism because facts don't help. And I wouldn't even call the add an appeal to emotion. I would call it trying to educate conservatives. a lot of you guys don't think Obamacare has helped anybody. But I think the part that upsets you the most is that its true. What was every conservative narrative about Obamacare if not a lying appeal to emotion? be it death panels or hundreds of thousands of doctors would retire or 50-100 million will lose insurance. Or this liar.

 
Dennis is the only one with a story? I've got a story too and it is one reason why I didn't vote for Hillary.

what's your story MR? surely you wont cut and run from that question.
 
what's your story MR? surely you wont cut and run from that question.

I've already told my story many times on here. The succinct version is my wife had to quit being a stay at home mom and go out and find a job to get employer based health insurance because Obamacare sucked so bad for us that we couldn't afford it. It was over $23,000 per year counting premiums and out of pocket costs, and that was over two years ago. Rates have risen substantially since then.
 
I've already told my story many times on here. The succinct version is my wife had to quit being a stay at home mom and go out and find a job to get employer based health insurance because Obamacare sucked so bad for us that we couldn't afford it. It was over $23,000 per year counting premiums and out of pocket costs, and that was over two years ago. Rates have risen substantially since then.

I don’t mean to be a bother but you left out the part that you were not only able to buy insurance before Obamacare but that it was only 500 dollars a year and covered everything. Just curious, these previous “many times” did you post age and dependent data and your location so someone could check out your claims?
 



A campaign encouraging lawmakers not to repeal the Affordable Care Act will launch two new television ads, with one featuring a man who voted for President Donald Trump.

The ads are part of a “six figure” ad buy from the “Save My Care” campaign that will run in Ohio and Tennessee, according to an advance copy of the press release announcing the ads. Tennessee is home to Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Chairman Lamar Alexander, a key player in the Obamacare debate.

I’m a Republican. I voted for Trump,” says a man identified as Dennis, who is featured in the Tennessee ad. He was diagnosed with esophageal cancer and says in the ad, “The Affordable Care Act saved my life."

The ad running in Ohio features a woman named Paula, who was diagnosed with breast cancer, which spread to her brain and liver. According to the press release, the Medicaid expansion in Ohio under the Affordable Care Act helps her afford her cancer treatment.



New Pro-Obamacare Ad Features Trump Voter


Should I feel sorry for this American ..... ?


Anti-Obamacare people don't care about sick people unless they become sick. Then, suddenly, they realize, "Oh ****! I need that Obamacare thingie-ma-jigger."
 
Anti-Obamacare people don't care about sick people unless they become sick. Then, suddenly, they realize, "Oh ****! I need that Obamacare thingie-ma-jigger."

Just like they only care about Fetuses, and not the actual Child once they are born.

Then ... it's the hell with them
 
I don’t mean to be a bother but you left out the part that you were not only able to buy insurance before Obamacare but that it was only 500 dollars a year and covered everything. Just curious, these previous “many times” did you post age and dependent data and your location so someone could check out your claims?

You've got a swiss cheese liberal memory. I never once said that I had insurance before Obamacare for 500 dollars a year. It was around $16,000 per year for family coverage (premiums and out of pocket expenses) but rose to about $22,000 - $23,000 after Obamacare and that was two years ago. And, by the way, my coverage before Obamacare was a far superior policy with bigger networks and formularies than my coverage after Obamacare.
 
You've got a swiss cheese liberal memory. I never once said that I had insurance before Obamacare for 500 dollars a year. It was around $16,000 per year for family coverage (premiums and out of pocket expenses) but rose to about $22,000 - $23,000 after Obamacare and that was two years ago. And, by the way, my coverage before Obamacare was a far superior policy with bigger networks and formularies than my coverage after Obamacare.

no memory involved MR. I've never seen your claims. But my guess was close: cheaper and better before Obamacare. But again I ask, these previous “many times” did you post age and dependent data and your location so someone could check out your claims? just need a county for location.

on a side note, I hope you put that 16000 a year you save in the stock market.
 
wait. he voted for Trump? what did he think was going to happen to the ACA with a Republican congress (which has voted to repeal the ACA 50+ times) and a president who ran around the country screaming about repealing the ACA? FFS. this has to be an actor reading a script, right?
 
8 People Who Owe Their Lives to Obamacare


Here are their heartbreaking stories.


President Donald Trump has vowed to dismantle the Affordable Care Act (ACA) — a move that could leave some 30 million Americans without health insurance. ACA literally sustains millions of lives . Without the health insurance it provides, many people wouldn't have access to medicine and procedures that they need to survive. When we asked people on Twitter and through healthcare advocacy organizations to share their stories of how ACA keeps them alive, we were overwhelmed with responses. We heard from people waiting for organ transplants, from cancer survivors, from people with debilitating mental illness, and more. They told us about the toll that disease has taken on their lives: Before the ACA, some were forced to skip treatments because of the price; others couldn't get insurance at all because they were already sick. Here are a few of their stories.



Claudette Williams, 58, Orlando, Florida: I lost my job in 2005. After that I decided to purchase a policy. I found them online. They had a gentleman come to my house, and we talked about my blood pressure medications. The insurance was almost twice what they had quoted me because of the medication, and also because of my condition. I eventually couldn't afford it any more. I was uninsured, except for one year when I qualified for Medicaid. I ended up in the emergency room on a few occasions for heart trouble. I also developed diabetes. I couldn't afford to have regular mammograms. In 2014 I signed up for Obamacare. I was diagnosed with breast cancer in September of last year. The lumpectomy alone was billed at $40,000. I have four more chemo sessions to go, and after that, I have to do radiation. Luckily my cancer is only a stage one, so my prognosis is pretty good. But it is really scary thinking about my insurance being taken away. This is a fight for my life.



Charis Hill, 30, California: When I was 25, in 2012, I had a series of unexplained and undiagnosable respiratory challenges that felt like the flu or bronchitis or pneumonia. Doctors just couldn't figure out what was wrong with me. My condition got worse and worse. I visited urgent care a few times. I thought I was having a heart attack once. They tried to blame it on anxiety.

Eventually reached out to my dad, who was estranged from me. I knew that he had a severe health condition. The first words out of his mouth were, it sounds like you have what I have, which is ankylosing spondylitis (AS). I knew that I would need health insurance to be treated. But if I were to get a diagnosis before getting health insurance, I would have the preexisting condition working against me. So I got the cheapest plan that existed. I wasn't getting all the tests done or getting all the treatments. Then, ten months later, the ACA was implemented, and because of my income, I was eligible for a subsidy to purchase health insurance on the exchange in California. I got a better plan for less than I was paying before, which meant that I could access more treatment and not skip medication.

See the faces of real Americans ... not just a Political Party.
8 People Who Owe Their Lives to Obamacare | Mother Jones

Lol...Well, Im sure they voted for Obama twice and HRC.

Problem is the agenda Obama ran on was rejected. Elections have consequences
 
wait. he voted for Trump? what did he think was going to happen to the ACA with a Republican congress (which has voted to repeal the ACA 50+ times) and a president who ran around the country screaming about repealing the ACA? FFS. this has to be an actor reading a script, right?

that is conservatism. Conservatives are simply disconnected from reality. And don't think its just average people.


“California Farmers Backed Trump, but Now Fear Losing Field Workers,” read the headline on a New York Times story last week....

In the case of big farm operators, this seems kind of obvious: Ejecting undocumented workers from the U.S. was one of the main drivers of Trump’s campaign. But this kind of cognitive dissonance doesn’t arise because businesspeople are stupid


More industries are realizing that Trump is bad for their business.

Any editorial that quotes otter from animal house is a worthy read.
 
that is conservatism. Conservatives are simply disconnected from reality. And don't think its just average people.


“California Farmers Backed Trump, but Now Fear Losing Field Workers,” read the headline on a New York Times story last week....

In the case of big farm operators, this seems kind of obvious: Ejecting undocumented workers from the U.S. was one of the main drivers of Trump’s campaign. But this kind of cognitive dissonance doesn’t arise because businesspeople are stupid


More industries are realizing that Trump is bad for their business.

Any editorial that quotes otter from animal house is a worthy read.

the "all conservatives are this" or "all liberals are that" arguments are impossible. the brush is too broad.

in the case of this commercial, though, it's just too ****ing idiotic for me to maintain suspension of disbelief.
 



A campaign encouraging lawmakers not to repeal the Affordable Care Act will launch two new television ads, with one featuring a man who voted for President Donald Trump.

The ads are part of a “six figure” ad buy from the “Save My Care” campaign that will run in Ohio and Tennessee, according to an advance copy of the press release announcing the ads. Tennessee is home to Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Chairman Lamar Alexander, a key player in the Obamacare debate.

I’m a Republican. I voted for Trump,” says a man identified as Dennis, who is featured in the Tennessee ad. He was diagnosed with esophageal cancer and says in the ad, “The Affordable Care Act saved my life."

The ad running in Ohio features a woman named Paula, who was diagnosed with breast cancer, which spread to her brain and liver. According to the press release, the Medicaid expansion in Ohio under the Affordable Care Act helps her afford her cancer treatment.



New Pro-Obamacare Ad Features Trump Voter


Should I feel sorry for this American ..... ?


The argument that government subsidies make anything "more affordable" is silly. SNAP does not make food "more affordable" - it simply makes someone else pay the same price for it.
 



A campaign encouraging lawmakers not to repeal the Affordable Care Act will launch two new television ads, with one featuring a man who supposedly voted for President Donald Trump.
[/I]


Fixed it for ya. But you won't see this post until Monday, amirite? :roll:
 
wait. he voted for Trump? what did he think was going to happen to the ACA with a Republican congress (which has voted to repeal the ACA 50+ times) and a president who ran around the country screaming about repealing the ACA? FFS. this has to be an actor reading a script, right?

Stand by to be told that Trump supporters don't realize the ACA is Obamacare. There was a poll and everything. :rolleyes:
 
The argument that government subsidies make anything "more affordable" is silly. SNAP does not make food "more affordable" - it simply makes someone else pay the same price for it.

With added administrative costs heaped onto the backs of taxpayers. ;)
 
Back
Top Bottom