• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

National Identity Card?

Rexedgar

Yo-Semite!
Supporting Member
DP Veteran
Monthly Donator
Joined
Apr 6, 2017
Messages
63,129
Reaction score
52,787
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
There is a major story in the news concerning voter fraud. DJT seems to have a problem that he was not credited with winning the popular vote. DJT has created a commission to look into his claim of millions of bogus ballots cast.
Before you go off half cocked, please bear with me. I don't know if there is a major problem here (voter fraud). When I vote I have to show my picture ID. Not that long ago, I just had to say I was me. 11SEP01 changed many thing regarding identification/security. In this day and age, what is the arguement against some form of voter identification? I know there are some non-drivers in the country, so DMV permits are not 100%. Before anyone goes on a rant about a "national identity card", let me share what happened a few years back. My grandparents are buried at the USMA, West Point, NY. I had a trip planned to visit an elderly relative in NH. West Point was not that far off the route. I had been there before to pay respects (before 9/11), and there was little or no check to get on post and move freely. This trip there was an MP or civilian officer, and I was stopped and ID checked and asked what my business was. I furnished my VA drivers permit. The officer looked at the front and then he swiped the card through his hand held computer. This is NY state and my permit is issued from VA. The officer evidently got the information he needed from the magnetic stripe. Yours has one too. So my position is that there does already exist some form of national I'd card. Since all people don't drive, DMV permits are not the whole answer. My question is, since drivers surrender personal information, what is the arguement for non drivers to surrender the same along with a photo? At the citizen swearing in ceremony, there could be ID issued as part of the procedure. TBH, something about the way the DJT Administration is going about this, give me pause, but what are some of the arguements for/against? Alternate solutions?
 
There is a major story in the news concerning voter fraud. DJT seems to have a problem that he was not credited with winning the popular vote. DJT has created a commission to look into his claim of millions of bogus ballots cast.
Before you go off half cocked, please bear with me. I don't know if there is a major problem here (voter fraud). When I vote I have to show my picture ID. Not that long ago, I just had to say I was me. 11SEP01 changed many thing regarding identification/security. In this day and age, what is the arguement against some form of voter identification? I know there are some non-drivers in the country, so DMV permits are not 100%. Before anyone goes on a rant about a "national identity card", let me share what happened a few years back. My grandparents are buried at the USMA, West Point, NY. I had a trip planned to visit an elderly relative in NH. West Point was not that far off the route. I had been there before to pay respects (before 9/11), and there was little or no check to get on post and move freely. This trip there was an MP or civilian officer, and I was stopped and ID checked and asked what my business was. I furnished my VA drivers permit. The officer looked at the front and then he swiped the card through his hand held computer. This is NY state and my permit is issued from VA. The officer evidently got the information he needed from the magnetic stripe. Yours has one too. So my position is that there does already exist some form of national I'd card. Since all people don't drive, DMV permits are not the whole answer. My question is, since drivers surrender personal information, what is the arguement for non drivers to surrender the same along with a photo? At the citizen swearing in ceremony, there could be ID issued as part of the procedure. TBH, something about the way the DJT Administration is going about this, give me pause, but what are some of the arguements for/against? Alternate solutions?

Funny that anyone would have a problem with their winning without the popular vote majority. Losing in spite of having the majority of the popular vote. Now that is embarrassing. Means you didn't realize how it works. ;)
 
Funny that anyone would have a problem with their winning without the popular vote majority. Losing in spite of having the majority of the popular vote. Now that is embarrassing. Means you didn't realize how it works. ;)

It's happened 5 of 49 POTUS elections, all in favor of republics .
 
There is a major story in the news concerning voter fraud. DJT seems to have a problem that he was not credited with winning the popular vote. DJT has created a commission to look into his claim of millions of bogus ballots cast.
Before you go off half cocked, please bear with me. I don't know if there is a major problem here (voter fraud). When I vote I have to show my picture ID. Not that long ago, I just had to say I was me. 11SEP01 changed many thing regarding identification/security. In this day and age, what is the arguement against some form of voter identification? I know there are some non-drivers in the country, so DMV permits are not 100%. Before anyone goes on a rant about a "national identity card", let me share what happened a few years back. My grandparents are buried at the USMA, West Point, NY. I had a trip planned to visit an elderly relative in NH. West Point was not that far off the route. I had been there before to pay respects (before 9/11), and there was little or no check to get on post and move freely. This trip there was an MP or civilian officer, and I was stopped and ID checked and asked what my business was. I furnished my VA drivers permit. The officer looked at the front and then he swiped the card through his hand held computer. This is NY state and my permit is issued from VA. The officer evidently got the information he needed from the magnetic stripe. Yours has one too. So my position is that there does already exist some form of national I'd card. Since all people don't drive, DMV permits are not the whole answer. My question is, since drivers surrender personal information, what is the arguement for non drivers to surrender the same along with a photo? At the citizen swearing in ceremony, there could be ID issued as part of the procedure. TBH, something about the way the DJT Administration is going about this, give me pause, but what are some of the arguements for/against? Alternate solutions?

They will say differently, but the real motivation of the voter ID crowd is to suppress Democratic turnout. That's fairly apparent from the laws that are crafted for this purpose.

The problem becomes that this proposed national ID would soon be written into these state laws as not acceptable.
 
They will say differently, but the real motivation of the voter ID crowd is to suppress Democratic turnout. That's fairly apparent from the laws that are crafted for this purpose.

The problem becomes that this proposed national ID would soon be written into these state laws as not acceptable.

Exactly.

There is no voter fraud, there is however election fraud.
 
Funny that anyone would have a problem with their winning without the popular vote majority. Losing in spite of having the majority of the popular vote. Now that is embarrassing. Means you didn't realize how it works. ;)

Odd, then that the 'winner' is the only one crying about it!
 
It's happened 5 of 49 POTUS elections, all in favor of republics .

Are you implying the Democrats have difficulties learning stuff?
 
Odd, then that the 'winner' is the only one crying about it!

I guess he might be embarrassed to have been challenged by such a lughead. No glory in winning then. ;)
 
There is a major story in the news concerning voter fraud. DJT seems to have a problem that he was not credited with winning the popular vote. DJT has created a commission to look into his claim of millions of bogus ballots cast.
Before you go off half cocked, please bear with me. I don't know if there is a major problem here (voter fraud). When I vote I have to show my picture ID. Not that long ago, I just had to say I was me. 11SEP01 changed many thing regarding identification/security. In this day and age, what is the arguement against some form of voter identification? I know there are some non-drivers in the country, so DMV permits are not 100%. Before anyone goes on a rant about a "national identity card", let me share what happened a few years back. My grandparents are buried at the USMA, West Point, NY. I had a trip planned to visit an elderly relative in NH. West Point was not that far off the route. I had been there before to pay respects (before 9/11), and there was little or no check to get on post and move freely. This trip there was an MP or civilian officer, and I was stopped and ID checked and asked what my business was. I furnished my VA drivers permit. The officer looked at the front and then he swiped the card through his hand held computer. This is NY state and my permit is issued from VA. The officer evidently got the information he needed from the magnetic stripe. Yours has one too. So my position is that there does already exist some form of national I'd card. Since all people don't drive, DMV permits are not the whole answer. My question is, since drivers surrender personal information, what is the arguement for non drivers to surrender the same along with a photo? At the citizen swearing in ceremony, there could be ID issued as part of the procedure. TBH, something about the way the DJT Administration is going about this, give me pause, but what are some of the arguements for/against? Alternate solutions?

To stay on topic, I think it's a valid solution. The DMV issues non driving IDs as well.
The argument against is that Democrats would be suppressed. Why? If Republicans are "uneducated rural" and the majority of Dems live in urban areas, where DMV offices are more plentiful(as well as public transportation) it wold stand to reason that they have a better opportunity to get an ID.

You can't have it both ways.
 
Back
Top Bottom