• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Mac/MP3/flash drive question

nota bene

Moderator
DP Veteran
Joined
Aug 11, 2011
Messages
72,212
Reaction score
43,994
Gender
Female
Political Leaning
Conservative
I loaded MP3 files onto a flash drive to help a friend with a project. He says that his Mac is “unable to ‘see’ the flash drive" and that he tried to open it on his wife’s PC, and it said, “There are no files.”

What could be going on here? I gave my friend hundreds of tunes, and while I'm more than willing to load them onto another flash drive, I don't understand what's going wrong and whether I need instructions or he does.

TIA.
 
I loaded MP3 files onto a flash drive to help a friend with a project. He says that his Mac is “unable to ‘see’ the flash drive" and that he tried to open it on his wife’s PC, and it said, “There are no files.”

What could be going on here? I gave my friend hundreds of tunes, and while I'm more than willing to load them onto another flash drive, I don't understand what's going wrong and whether I need instructions or he does.

TIA.

I know when I did the same thing I had to format the thumb drive to be read, cannot recall what format was required. That was for my vehicle though. Could be that???? Not sure though
 
I know when I did the same thing I had to format the thumb drive to be read, cannot recall what format was required. That was for my vehicle though. Could be that???? Not sure though

I'm not sure. When I went Googling, I saw a number of articles about problems with playing flash drives in vehicles but am not sure that this has anything to do with this or whether it's about my friend's Mac or what. Here is one article on what I think you're talking about: https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/usb-music-in-car.1578276/
 
I'm not sure. When I went Googling, I saw a number of articles about problems with playing flash drives in vehicles but am not sure that this has anything to do with this or whether it's about my friend's Mac or what. Here is one article on what I think you're talking about: https://forums.macrumors.com/threads/usb-music-in-car.1578276/

The tdrive I purchased was not formatted to be read by Toyota. After I formatted the tdrive, no issues.
Now is that the problem?? Not sure, could it be a bad tdrive??
 
The tdrive I purchased was not formatted to be read by Toyota. After I formatted the tdrive, no issues.
Now is that the problem?? Not sure, could it be a bad tdrive??

I don't think so, but the truth is that I hadn't even thought of that. But I think I checked a few files while loading. :3oops:

Drat! How likely is it that it's the flash drive?

I'm loading another flash drive for him and just checked to see if a file would play, and it did. But I'm playing it on Windows Media Player. Could this be the problem?
 
I don't think so, but the truth is that I hadn't even thought of that. But I think I checked a few files while loading. :3oops:

Drat! How likely is it that it's the flash drive?

I'm loading another flash drive for him and just checked to see if a file would play, and it did. But I'm playing it on Windows Media Player. Could this be the problem?

Not sure. I would google that issue for mac compatible. I have windows, my daughter has an Apple, same as my sister, and I hate Apple. Yet they both call for help
 
I don't think so, but the truth is that I hadn't even thought of that. But I think I checked a few files while loading. :3oops:

Drat! How likely is it that it's the flash drive?

I'm loading another flash drive for him and just checked to see if a file would play, and it did. But I'm playing it on Windows Media Player. Could this be the problem?

I use a Mac and when connecting a flash drive, there is a notation that pops up on the left side of the screen and notes that the computer has detected the drive. When disconnecting the drive there is a symbol that is needing to be clicked on the computer is not happy. Let me know if the problem still exists and I will go to the Mac and describe it better, I’m on a tablet now.....
 
I loaded MP3 files onto a flash drive to help a friend with a project. He says that his Mac is “unable to ‘see’ the flash drive" and that he tried to open it on his wife’s PC, and it said, “There are no files.”

What could be going on here? I gave my friend hundreds of tunes, and while I'm more than willing to load them onto another flash drive, I don't understand what's going wrong and whether I need instructions or he does.

TIA.

Check how the USB drive is formatted. If it is NTFS, the Mac won't see it. It needs to be FAT32.
 
I use a Mac and when connecting a flash drive, there is a notation that pops up on the left side of the screen and notes that the computer has detected the drive. When disconnecting the drive there is a symbol that is needing to be clicked on the computer is not happy. Let me know if the problem still exists and I will go to the Mac and describe it better, I’m on a tablet now.....


I should know more in a day or so, but my desktop PC also alerts me that the flash drive has been detected or whether it's corrupted in some way. Thanks, Rexedgar.
 
Check how the USB drive is formatted. If it is NTFS, the Mac won't see it. It needs to be FAT32.

The flash drive I'm beginning to load is FAT32, but I'll tell my friend to also check this. If it's NTFS, can it be reformatted?

Why would it be NTFS, and is this more/less common than FAT32?
 
That is really strange. I've transferred all sorts of things between MAC and PC, including various sounds formats, w/ flash drives. Never had an issue, never had to check formatting.
 
That is really strange. I've transferred all sorts of things between MAC and PC, including various sounds formats, w/ flash drives. Never had an issue, never had to check formatting.

Most USB drives are pre-formatted in FAT32 for legacy and "Mac" issues.
 

Now that I'm reading up, though, there are incompatibility issues.

I've talked to my BFF's son, who's in IT, because I didn't know (a little knowledge can be a dangerous thing) whether I would have to partition or what. He says no and to get back the flash drive and drag the files over to a second flash drive. The second one is FAT32; now I know to check. He also says that when I do, he can take control of my computer remotely if I run into a problem. I'm going to do it just as an experiment, I think. I do know now that my friend's Mac is FAT32-friendly.

My brain is about to explode from all this. I really appreciate all the helpful posts.
 
That is really strange. I've transferred all sorts of things between MAC and PC, including various sounds formats, w/ flash drives. Never had an issue, never had to check formatting.

This makes me wonder whether I didn't grab the one-out-of-zillions of flash drives that was NTSF. Won't know until I get the drive back. I'm going to transfer files again today and tomorrow onto a FAT32 drive, and I will be mega-pissed if this happens again!
 
You are all unintendedly treading on new ground. MacOS High Sierra introduces APFS (Apple File System) to Mac computers. APFS replaces Mac OS Extended (HFS+) as the default file system for solid-state drives (SSDs) and other all-flash storage devices. Kaboom! APFS is still having issues recognized flash memory units using other legacy formats. Don't get smug if you are using Windows or Linux, both are introducing similar and compatible flash formats this coming year, Apple was first to the punch. These are all part of new formatting techniques, long overdue, far more efficient and offering maximum usage of flash memory which does have a shorter life cycle than mechanical drives. Likely the owner of the Mac, when last performing a system update, didn't examine a choice of formats for his Mac to recognize. This cannot be corrected after the fact, yet.

Merely plugging a USB Flash drive into an APFS formatted system can screw around with the data contained on the drive, making files invisible to all users.

Adding to the problem, is the fact that MP3's placed on a Mac or opened from any auxiliary drive or source on a Mac, alters the MP3 adding an additional data fork, creating havoc, sometimes turning those files invisible.

That was the bad news. Now the good news, and life as we know it isn't over. There are solutions and work arounds that are simple, and more efficient than USB thumb drives.

There are many file storage sites (clouds so to speak) that offer free storage, sometimes of limited size, sometimes for limited periods of time, but all are basically letting users try out services they want to sell the consumer. Do a bit of searching, you can easily find hundreds of these file sharing sites, examine a few to see which would be best for you, upload your files that you want to share and pass the keys (authentication methods for access) to anyone you want to be able to download those files.



DropBox, which started as a file sharing site, is now a full blown collaboration site, with many users able to simultaneously work of the same file. Usage determined by paid subscription plan.

As a very musical family, we consistently pass files in progress between family members and friends, at time with more than a couple of hundred files being in use. Keeping track of which files are to be accessed by who, latest modifications can be a nightmare without an up to date database with everyone doing their best to for updated contributions. We often use Apple's iCloud accounts that come free with 5gb of free space with each device aquisitiaa.
 
Back
Top Bottom