- Joined
- Feb 15, 2014
- Messages
- 19,599
- Reaction score
- 11,565
- Location
- South Texas
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Conservative
In this passing era lots of QBs are now putting up stats, so how will we rate them beyond SB wins as far as to get into the HOF?
Heres a list of QB stats some active some retired that arent in the hall, which ones would yall put in?
1. 34k yards, 274/93 TD/INT, 103.6 pass rating
2. 34k yards, 247/117 TD/INT, 97.1 pass rating
3. 43k yards, 286/142 TD/INT, 95.4 pass rating
4. 44k yards, 288/153 TD/INT, 94.2 pass rating
5. 35k yards, 221/111 TD/INT, 92.3 pass rating
6. 42k yards, 269/162 TD/INT, 88.1 pass rating
7. 37k yards, 234/117 TD/INT, 85.6 pass rating
8. 46k yards, 302/205 TD/INT, 83.6 pass rating
9. 38k yards, 261/199 TD/INT, 81.5 pass rating
10. 38k yards, 247/184 TD/INT, 81.1 pass rating
11. 35k yards, 203/175 TD/INT, 78.6 pass rating
12. 44k yards, 251/206 TD/INT, 77.1 pass rating
So just based on stats who would you put in(assuming they never played another down)? Then look at the names and see if that changes your opinion
I would say that it certainly changed my opinion knowing the names but how will it play out? like basketball where all the top names get in, or baseball when you hit certain milestones? Its going to be hard to make a case against #2 and #3 but Im not sure either should be in.
Heres a list of QB stats some active some retired that arent in the hall, which ones would yall put in?
1. 34k yards, 274/93 TD/INT, 103.6 pass rating
2. 34k yards, 247/117 TD/INT, 97.1 pass rating
3. 43k yards, 286/142 TD/INT, 95.4 pass rating
4. 44k yards, 288/153 TD/INT, 94.2 pass rating
5. 35k yards, 221/111 TD/INT, 92.3 pass rating
6. 42k yards, 269/162 TD/INT, 88.1 pass rating
7. 37k yards, 234/117 TD/INT, 85.6 pass rating
8. 46k yards, 302/205 TD/INT, 83.6 pass rating
9. 38k yards, 261/199 TD/INT, 81.5 pass rating
10. 38k yards, 247/184 TD/INT, 81.1 pass rating
11. 35k yards, 203/175 TD/INT, 78.6 pass rating
12. 44k yards, 251/206 TD/INT, 77.1 pass rating
So just based on stats who would you put in(assuming they never played another down)? Then look at the names and see if that changes your opinion
1. Aaron Rodgers
2. Tony Romo
3. Phillip Rivers
4. Ben Rothlisberger
5. Matt Ryan
6. Carson Plamer
7. Donovan McNabb
8. Eli Manning
9. Dave Krieg
10. Boomer Esiason
11. Jim Everett
12. Drew Bledsoe
2. Tony Romo
3. Phillip Rivers
4. Ben Rothlisberger
5. Matt Ryan
6. Carson Plamer
7. Donovan McNabb
8. Eli Manning
9. Dave Krieg
10. Boomer Esiason
11. Jim Everett
12. Drew Bledsoe
I would say that it certainly changed my opinion knowing the names but how will it play out? like basketball where all the top names get in, or baseball when you hit certain milestones? Its going to be hard to make a case against #2 and #3 but Im not sure either should be in.