• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

[W:22]NHS 'over-diagnosing' children having transgender treatment, former staff warn

Give me evidence. Please.

0.6%
A different survey in 2016, from the Williams Institute, estimated that 0.6% of U.S. adults identify as transgender. Studies from several nations, including the U.S., conducted at varying time periods, have produced a statistical range of 1.2 to 6.8 percent of the adult population identifying as LGBT.

You're welcome.
 
I disagree. America is one of the most tolerant countries in the world for LGBT folks. The idea that trans people attempt to self harm because they're not accepted enough is a red herring. It's also destructive because it gives the false hope that trans people will be happy, if people just were more accepting of them- no one's wellbeing is determined by whether they're liked by a majority of people. That's a silly idea. You would never tell straight children that their well being in life in determined upon whether they're accepted and supported by everyone, I hope.

And yet we have people who write transphobic articles such at one linked in the OP.
 
You are dangerous. You represent a threat. Because you are a transgender person, and you know through personal experience what it's like to be transgender.

White knights need a victim to White night for. If you take away their victim they will have to find another. And I have a prediction of where it's going to go. What the next victimized identity is going to be. And it's really sad but I think this is going to be in the next 10 years once transgenderism is passe. It's going to be mental illness. that is the way people are going to identify their uniqueness and that's what the white knights will go for.

Another thing about it is the people that help them they are going to be the next version of whatever transphobic is.

We already see it. People are proud of their mental disorders. and I'm not talking like gender dysphoria I'm talking like OCD or anxiety, or the front runner in the favorites depression.

Just wait you will see.

OwmP.gif
 
I disagree. America is one of the most tolerant countries in the world for LGBT folks. The idea that trans people attempt to self-harm because they're not accepted enough is a red herring. It's also destructive because it gives the false hope that trans people will be happy, if people just were more accepting of them- no one's wellbeing is determined by whether they're liked by a majority of people. That's a silly idea. You would never tell straight children that their well being in life in determined upon whether they're accepted and supported by everyone, I hope.

Transgendered people lack basic rights in the US. They can be fired for being trans, thrown out of an apartment and refused to use the restroom of their identity. The GOP is trying to allow medical people and merchants tor refuse them service for being trans. Many of them basic necessarey medical care because of these situations. Almost 40% of homeless youths are LGBT. Many are abused in their homes and schools and are afraid to speak up because they fear it will only get worse when they are more public.
Is this your idea of a safe and healthy place to live?

Trans women have some of the highest rates of crimes committed against them.

HRC Releases Report on Epidemic of Anti-Transgender Violence | Human Rights Campaign
 
So no evidence? That's what I thought. ;)

Every time I add another conservative to my ignore list this forum gains 5 IQ points. Their ignorance is just not worth the stress and effort to reply to.
 
0.6%
A different survey in 2016, from the Williams Institute, estimated that 0.6% of U.S. adults identify as transgender. Studies from several nations, including the U.S., conducted at varying time periods, have produced a statistical range of 1.2 to 6.8 percent of the adult population identifying as LGBT.

You're welcome.

You're profoundly confused.

But that's okay!

:)
 
Every time I add another conservative to my ignore list this forum gains 5 IQ points. Their ignorance is just not worth the stress and effort to reply to.

Coming to a forum with divergent views only to re-establish one's echo chamber = Bizarre, tragic, pathetic
 
No doubt, kids are being messed up because of this...



Dr. Michael Laidlaw an Endocrinologist from California explains the devastating effects that puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and surgical modifications can have on children's developing bodies.
 
Transgendered people lack basic rights in the US. They can be fired for being trans..

That doesn't make it legal.

"Federal courts have shown consistent support for the inclusion of transgender people under existing employment law for decades,” said Gillian Branstette, a spokesperson for the NCTE. That means: Even if you lose your job in a state without protections, you can sue based on federal law. "

Can You Get Fired for Being Trans? - VICE


, thrown out of an apartment

Why would a landlord rent to a trans person, only to end up evicting them? Perhaps they are being evicted for violating the rules that renters must abide by, not for being trans.

and refused to use the restroom of their identity

I don't believe that biological males belong in women's public bathrooms, and we've already seen cases of perverts using women's restrooms to engage in abnormal behavior.

. The GOP is trying to allow medical people and merchants tor refuse them service for being trans.

That's a very abbreviated version of what the guidelines say, and it's not about discriminating against people who are trans, but allowing doctors to decide whether or not they want to give hormones to someone. Many people object to the practice, and look what the NHS is doing- medical experimentation and coercion of children, which may cause further damage. We don't want that here.

Many of them basic necessarey medical care because of these situations. Almost 40% of homeless youths are LGBT.

Now you're lumping lesbians, gays, and bi people in with trans, who represent the smallest portion of the LGBT community. Most homeless people aren't LGBT, so let's not ignore them. California has nearly 1/2 homeless people in the entire country, so let's not pretend that Republicans are to blame here. The liberals and progressives in this state talk a great game about caring for homeless people, but don't care enough to do anything for them. Most volunteers who work with the homeless are Christians, guided by their faith.

Many are abused in their homes and schools and are afraid to speak up because they fear it will only get worse when they are more public.
Is this your idea of a safe and healthy place to live?

No one should suffer abuse, however the USA is not like places in the Middle East where LGBT are chucked off rooftops. We have a system in place to deal with physical abuse. Most assaults are treated as misdemeanors and many felony assaults are reduced. That is a problem with the criminal justice system.

Trans women have some of the highest rates of crimes committed against them.

HRC Releases Report on Epidemic of Anti-Transgender Violence | Human Rights Campaign

Maybe this has something to do with the fact that 1 in 5 transgender individuals work in the sex trade during their lives. It's a dangerous business, surrounded by drug addiction and mental illness. One trans woman said she was repeatedly raped and molested as a boy in her native country, before coming to America to work as a trans prostitute. He said that had he not been raped as a boy, he felt he wouldn't have drifted into the trans lifestyle and prostitution. Protecting children is the real issue here, and we're just not that committed to doing so. That's the real tragedy.

Decriminalizing prostitution is central to transgender rights.
 
No doubt, kids are being messed up because of this...



Dr. Michael Laidlaw an Endocrinologist from California explains the devastating effects that puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and surgical modifications can have on children's developing bodies.


I suspect that we'll find out decades later that the pharmaceutical industry was promoting puberty blockers in the same way they promoted Oxycontin and antidepressants as cure-all wonder drugs. The damage inflicted upon society by these people is immense.
 
Why do you think its transphobic?

Where is the proof? Where is the investigation? If those people are serious, they'd be open and reveal themselves and bring attention to it. I mean it's the children after all. It's very important.
 
I suspect that we'll find out decades later that the pharmaceutical industry was promoting puberty blockers in the same way they promoted Oxycontin and antidepressants as cure-all wonder drugs. The damage inflicted upon society by these people is immense.

And then it'll be too late for many...
 
Where is the proof? Where is the investigation? If those people are serious, they'd be open and reveal themselves and bring attention to it. I mean it's the children after all. It's very important.

The NHS is the public collection of nationalized healthcare providers in the UK. They are employed by the government. The government would be responsible for investigating the GIDS arm of NHS. Saying that the allegations aren't true because the government hasn't investigated is preposterous. Do you know how ****ed up the NHS is?
 
The NHS is the public collection of nationalized healthcare providers in the UK. They are employed by the government. The government would be responsible for investigating the GIDS arm of NHS. Saying that the allegations aren't true because the government hasn't investigated is preposterous. Do you know how ****ed up the NHS is?

Do you understand the importance of children's safety? If I was one of those who quit, I wouldn't be hiding behind anonymity. I would get people to protest with me and demand them be investigated. Apparently it isn't that important to them.
 
Do you understand the importance of children's safety? If I was one of those who quit, I wouldn't be hiding behind anonymity. I would get people to protest with me and demand them be investigated. Apparently it isn't that important to them.

Then you would be accused of being transphobic, by the cultists..
 
Back
Top Bottom