• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

horrible nightmare in europe

In fact, I consider that the wealth of European countries and their descendants has nothing to do with the political system they have adopted, but with how well it feels to the economy to base their laws on Germanic law
 
I believe that the Germanic tribes are very important, because Germanic law is the main legal basis of the countries that best develop economically, regardless of the political system they adopt...

What are you talking about. Which countries are you talking about that have "Germanic Law" ?


...Goths, Suevian, Vandals... were descendants of the Celts....

"...the earliest undisputed direct examples of a Celtic language are the Lepontic inscriptions beginning in the 6th century BC..."

Celts - Wikipedia

Celtic culture spread through Ancient Britain before the Romans invaded


Please point out the Celtic connection to the Goths

Goths - Wikipedia - the first mention of who'm is in the 1st century AD - about seven hundred years later



Or the Germanic tribe of Vandals a hundred year later approx:

"The Vandals were a large Germanic tribe or group of tribes that first appear in history inhabiting southern Poland...the traditional view has been that the Vandals migrated from southern Scandinavia during the 2nd century BC ..."


Vandals - Wikipedia



All played a part in developing European culture, but saying those tribes were tribal "descendants" of the Celts is nonsense.
 
What are you talking about. Which countries are you talking about that have "Germanic Law" ?




"...the earliest undisputed direct examples of a Celtic language are the Lepontic inscriptions beginning in the 6th century BC..."

Celts - Wikipedia

Celtic culture spread through Ancient Britain before the Romans invaded


Please point out the Celtic connection to the Goths

Goths - Wikipedia - the first mention of who'm is in the 1st century AD - about seven hundred years later



Or the Germanic tribe of Vandals a hundred year later approx:

"The Vandals were a large Germanic tribe or group of tribes that first appear in history inhabiting southern Poland...the traditional view has been that the Vandals migrated from southern Scandinavia during the 2nd century BC ..."


Vandals - Wikipedia



All played a part in developing European culture, but saying those tribes were tribal "descendants" of the Celts is nonsense.


I believe that Germanic law left a special influence on the countries of the European Union and the Common Welth, and, from my point of view, it is so important for their economies, to the point that I consider it to be the cause of their wealth , because it generates a lot of solidarity within families and even communities, which gives many facilities to people who are starting businesses, when they are not yet profitable.

The Celts are associated with the British Islands, Ireland, northern France and Spain, but they were Indo-European tribes, who ended up emigrating to these areas, and many others.
 
Last edited:
I believe that Germanic law left a special influence on the countries of the European Union and the Common Welth...

Can you give an example of such a law ?

And it's "commonwealth" (one word)


...it is so important for their economies, to the point that I consider it to be the cause of their wealth...


Please explain why your example causes wealth


...the Celts are associated with the British Islands, Ireland, northern France and Spain, but they were Indo-European tribes, who ended up emigrating to these areas, and many others.

So, wouldn't they rank as high as any "Germanic" tribe in terms of influence if not more ?
 
Can you give an example of such a law ?

And it's "commonwealth" (one word)





Please explain why your example causes wealth




So, wouldn't they rank as high as any "Germanic" tribe in terms of influence if not more ?



I've already done it. Countries whose law is heavily influenced by Germanic law, are especially supportive in relationships within families and communities, and that is very positive in the face of business going forward, because it helps people (especially young people)
who are investigating what they can do, when what they investigate still does not give benefits, regardless of the political system. Our wealth is due to our law, not our political system. In my opinion, this is due to the type of society that emerged, in areas where there were many survivors of the last glaciation, necessary to survive it.

The Celts were pre-Romanesque Germanic tribes, who migrated from Indo-European areas to virtually all of Europe, and even areas in Asia or Africa, in my opinion, mainly due to the strong expansion of the Roman Empire.
 
Last edited:
I've already done it. Countries whose law is heavily influenced by Germanic law, are especially supportive in relationships within families and communities....

And which modern day countries are those ?


...our wealth is due to our law, not our political system....


Not our economic system ?

So a country with the same legal system as the USA should have roughly the same per capita wealth ?


...this is due to the type of society that emerged...

What "type" of society do we have, and many many "types" are there ?



...the Celts were pre-Romanesque Germanic tribes, who migrated from Indo-European areas to virtually all of Europe, and even areas in Asia or Africa, in my opinion, mainly due to the strong expansion of the Roman Empire.


What is an Indo-European area ?

"The Celts were a collection of tribes with origins in central Europe that shared a similar language, religious beliefs, traditions and culture. It’s believed that the Celtic culture started to evolve as early as 1200 B.C. The Celts spread throughout western Europe—including Britain, Ireland, France and Spain—via migration...."

Who Were Celts - HISTORY


Where in Asia or Africa can we find evidence of their migration ? (should be hard if they were from Indo-Europe as you claim)

If they're pre-Roman (as they were as 1200 BC is well before the dawn of the Roman Empire), how would the Rise of the Roman empire in the later part of 1st century BC affect their migration?
 
And which modern day countries are those ?





Not our economic system ?

So a country with the same legal system as the USA should have roughly the same per capita wealth ?




What "type" of society do we have, and many many "types" are there ?






What is an Indo-European area ?

"The Celts were a collection of tribes with origins in central Europe that shared a similar language, religious beliefs, traditions and culture. It’s believed that the Celtic culture started to evolve as early as 1200 B.C. The Celts spread throughout western Europe—including Britain, Ireland, France and Spain—via migration...."

Who Were Celts - HISTORY


Where in Asia or Africa can we find evidence of their migration ? (should be hard if they were from Indo-Europe as you claim)

If they're pre-Roman (as they were as 1200 BC is well before the dawn of the Roman Empire), how would the Rise of the Roman empire in the later part of 1st century BC affect their migration?

Almost all the countries of the European Union and the Common Wealth are very rich; for now they are the richest in the world. However, they have and have had quite different political systems. The cause of their wealth must be sought in common circumstances related to their culture and laws; And there are.
Of course, GDP per capita, today, is an economic indicator of low quality, because most countries have acquired very important debts.

I live about 10 miles from what was one of the greatest Celtic settlements in history and it is known that they arrived by the carbon tests 14 some 100 years before Christ. The Romans were already very dangerous in the eyes of the Indo-European tribes several hundred years before Christ.
In any case, it is obvious that there were important migrations before the rise of the Roman Empire.
I think the cause is not well known; perhaps issues related to food or even religious beliefs that sometimes made them build strange monuments.
 
Last edited:
Almost all the countries of the European Union and the Common Wealth are very rich;for now they are the richest in the world ...

EU Members
Coatia
Bulgaria
Ireland
Estonia
Latvia
Poland
Romania
Slovakia
Slovenia


Countries | European Union


Commonwealth Countries
Antigua
Bangladesh
Barbados
Belize
Botswana
Brunei
Cameroon
Dominica
Fiji
The Gambia
Ghana
Grenada
Grenadines
Guyana
Jamaica
Kenya
Kiribati
Lesotho
Malawi
Mauritius
Mozambique
Namibia
Nauru
Nigeria
Pakistan
Papua New Guinea
Rwanda
Samoa
Seychelles
Sierra Leone
Solomon Islands
Sri Lanka
St Christopher and Nevis
St Lucia
St Vincent and the
Swaziland
Tonga
Trinidad and Tobago
Tuvalu
Uganda
Tanzania
Vanuatu
Zambia
Zimbabwe


List of Commonwealth Countries - voting rights | Tendring District Council


Yeah lots of fabulously wealthy countries there


.... however, they have and have had quite different political systems. The cause of their wealth must be sought in common circumstances related to their culture and laws...

What would be the circumstance of their wealth ?


......the Romans were already very dangerous in the eyes of the Indo-European tribes several hundred years before Christ....


Just when do you think the Romans were any more than a small force in central Italy ?



...it is obvious that there were important migrations before the rise of the Roman Empire....

Yes, such as the Celts



...I think the cause is not well known; perhaps issues related to food or even religious beliefs that sometimes made them build strange monuments.

What strange monuments ?
 
Back
Top Bottom