• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

More than half of transgender teachers face harassment in their workplace

So you are ok with your kids being educated by mentally ill people?
Do you let crack dealers babysit them on friday nights as well? I mean, why not be inclusive, right? lol
I understand some people dont believe they have problems, but that is obviously incorrect. The WHO lists that as an illness.. are they intolerant as well? Or perhaps they are just realistic?

I'm a Navy Vet, have two children, a wonderful spouse, a good job, pay taxes, vote GOP 95% of the time, own guns, obey the law.
Did I mention I'm also a Pre-op Trans woman with a wife?

I am not mentally ill, and you really need to reconfigure your views on the Transgendered. You're completely, and utterly wrong.
 
^ This. Sometimes Yankintx is nicer than I am.

I think the idea that transgenderism is a mental illness is nonsense, though. I can tell you that if I woke up tomorrow morning to find that someone had carved a vagina into me, I'd want my dick back stat. That's all you have to do to understand why some trans folks go under the knife...they feel exactly like you would if someone carved a vagina into you (or plugged you up and put a dick on you, I'm making assumptions you're a dude)...except they've had to live with it all their lives. That conflict, or the steps one takes to resolve it, in no way impacts whether they can teach reading and writing to kids. Your "basic biology" comments are ignorant...this phenomenon exists in nature, therefore it is a part of "basic" biology, which of course has never been "basic", even before the transgender discussion. Biology is infinitely complicated...who better to teach that than someone struggling with that complexity?

Finally, the assertion that changing genders is "the in thing", as if it were a trend like fidget spinners or the Macarena, is preposterous. Given the challenges these people face on every level, physical, mental, social, etc., I promise you, there is nothing "trendy" about it. These people have to make massive sacrifices to find peace in this life, and if, even under that strain, they still have it in their hearts to teach children, then THAT'S the teacher I want my kid to have, vs. half these idiots out there that phone it in and wait for their summer holiday.

It is a mental illness by definition. Maybe you should protest webster and oxford to change their dictionaries, to fit your beliefs.
 
I'm a Navy Vet, have two children, a wonderful spouse, a good job, pay taxes, vote GOP 95% of the time, own guns, obey the law.
Did I mention I'm also a Pre-op Trans woman with a wife?

I am not mentally ill, and you really need to reconfigure your views on the Transgendered. You're completely, and utterly wrong.

do you just want to be the opposite sex? Or do you feel you ARE the opposite sex?
 
do you just want to be the opposite sex? Or do you feel you ARE the opposite sex?

I feel I was born the wrong gender. I live as Renae, I am on hormones, and as soon as I can, I will have corrective surgery to make things "right".
 
It is a mental illness by definition. Maybe you should protest webster and oxford to change their dictionaries, to fit your beliefs.

Perhaps, by definition...I was giving my opinion. You can tell with little hints like "I think" before the statement. When I state a fact, you'll know it, because I cite sources.

Speaking of which, how's your proof coming, anyway? Or do you just get off hating on transgendered folks? So far that's all you've shown as fact here.
 
Perhaps, by definition...I was giving my opinion. You can tell with little hints like "I think" before the statement. When I state a fact, you'll know it, because I cite sources.

Speaking of which, how's your proof coming, anyway? Or do you just get off hating on transgendered folks? So far that's all you've shown as fact here.

Proof for what, exactly?
 
I feel I was born the wrong gender. I live as Renae, I am on hormones, and as soon as I can, I will have corrective surgery to make things "right".

So your mind is the problem?
 
Sorry to be frank but i rest my case.

On what? Your uneducated personal opinion? I can live with that. People like you are full of inaccurate information. I am a perfectly sane individual, I am not mentally ill. Please show otherwise or apologize for your ignorance.
 
On what? Your uneducated personal opinion? I can live with that. People like you are full of inaccurate information. I am a perfectly sane individual, I am not mentally ill. Please show otherwise or apologize for your ignorance.

You have done that for me. You literally just described a mental illness.
 
Trans people are ****ing warriors. They go through so much just to be who they are, and then some people want to harass and make their lives even harder. That, is the pure definition of an asshole.
 
You have done that for me. You literally just described a mental illness.

Not in the least, and even the Experts disagree with you.
(CNN) - The American Psychiatric Association announced this month approved changes in its official guide to classifying mental illnesses.

Among the major announced revisions to the manual, known as DSM-5, is that Asperger's syndrome will now be included in the diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder "to help more accurately and consistently diagnose children with autism," the association said in a statement.

But the group made another big change that did not make as many headlines, though it is considered by many to be important.

The new DSM eliminates the term "gender identity disorder," long considered stigmatizing by mental health specialists and lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender activists.

That old diagnosis meant that a man who believed he was destined to be a woman was considered mentally ill.

No longer so.


The new DSM refers to "gender dysphoria," which focuses the attention on only those who feel distressed by their gender identity.
Being transgender no longer a mental 'disorder' in diagnostic manual ? In America - CNN.com Blogs
 
Thats great to hear! I appreciate success.
How is having a discussion trolling? Because you dont agree with my stance?

You are new here yes ? One of your first post you generalize about TG and mental illness. Usually trolls set the fire and piss off. You have hung with it, which in its self tells me you actually believe what you wrote in your first post. How many TG folks have you talked to, have you discussed your theory in an academic setting? Do you have cites to back up your claim? You must have some clinical studies to fall back on to prove your point. Otherwise, its your opinion not fact. You are entitled to your opinion, until you have reputable cites its all it is, therefore the rebuttals do not have to disprove an unproven theory. Cites dude ?
 
Also, Who doesn't classify Transgender as mental illness, you are so behind the science times.
https://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/27/health/who-transgender-medical-disorder.html
Come back when you are educated.

LOL it is STILL listed as a mental illness. Sorry to burst your bubble.
The only "science" they are using to change that fact is because is everyone would not say anything, they would be more secure and happy. By definition, it would STILL be an illness, just not a "dysphoria"
IMO, its all partisan crap. Just like when the APA removed it a few decades ago. Their board voted on it, and they voted to keep it classified as an illness. They removed it anyways..
 
You are new here yes ? One of your first post you generalize about TG and mental illness. Usually trolls set the fire and piss off. You have hung with it, which in its self tells me you actually believe what you wrote in your first post. How many TG folks have you talked to, have you discussed your theory in an academic setting? Do you have cites to back up your claim? You must have some clinical studies to fall back on to prove your point. Otherwise, its your opinion not fact. You are entitled to your opinion, until you have reputable cites its all it is, therefore the rebuttals do not have to disprove an unproven theory. Cites dude ?

Cites for a personal opinion? Or cites for it being a mental illness? I will gladly post the ICD list if it will satisfy you.
 
It is a mental illness by definition. Maybe you should protest webster and oxford to change their dictionaries, to fit your beliefs.

Perhaps, by definition...I was giving my opinion.

Not by definition and not by science. Harley can't just stroll in and set medical science on its head.
 
Its a personal opinion. How could i prove that?

By telling us how you came up with that personal opinion...what are you basing that opinion on? Are there statistics you would share? A study you would like to link to? Surely something other than fear and hatred made you come up with this summary opinion...cuz if that's all you got, no one is going to listen to you for long. Given how enthusiastically you've ducked the questions you've been given, I'm already starting to lose interest. Is there something to debate here, or are you just scared of transgendered folks?
 
Not by definition and not by science. Harley can't just stroll in and set medical science on its head.

Yes, i forged an oxford dictionary and the ICD list that was complied by the WHO that is accepted in most countries. You got me! Im a fraud!
 
mental illness
NOUN

A condition which causes serious disorder in a person's behaviour or thinking.
That is exactly what you claimed earlier.
You can argue with oxford and webster if you want. Im not one to argue definitions of words.

Dictionary-educated people are difficult to convince.
 
By telling us how you came up with that personal opinion...what are you basing that opinion on? Are there statistics you would share? A study you would like to link to? Surely something other than fear and hatred made you come up with this summary opinion...cuz if that's all you got, no one is going to listen to you for long. Given how enthusiastically you've ducked the questions you've been given, I'm already starting to lose interest. Is there something to debate here, or are you just scared of transgendered folks?

I need statistics for not wanting people with a mental illness teaching kids? Seriously?
I will ask again, are you ok with all mentally ill people teaching children, or just this one?
 
Back
Top Bottom