• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

So I Told My Friend He's a Drunk Today

No, that's not the issue. He had to give his ex half his stuff but we all do in WA state in a divorce - I had to do it.

There's a question I asked you another thread you left unanswered. I remain very curious as to your response. Did you intentionally ignore it?

You don't stand out from other posters. I generally decline to answer questions if I believe that they are not worth my effort.
 
If you feel you know it all, why discuss this on the forum? Drinking while on the drugs he's taking may kill him. I had a brother in law die a year and a half ago while taking opiates and drinking. He quit the drinking, cut down on the pain pills but went back up in dosage when the pain got worse, he died in his recliner. He got his system all messed up stopping the drinking and changing the dose on the pain meds.

Much luck to your friend, this problem is very serious.

You know what? You know what? You're right. I don't know it all and I'll try to think of a way to find out if he's on any addictive meds or illegal drugs.

I must repeat that Cal has been very forthcoming to me with everything else, including admitting he "got the shakes" at work from alcohol starvation. I guess I'm wondering why he'd leave out his heroin use, if he had such a use, for example.

I assure you I will follow-up on this, my concerned friend.
 
You don't stand out from other posters. I generally decline to answer questions if I believe that they are not worth my effort.

Ok, this was a very worthwhile question my friend. Your refusal to answer now is very telling. Please nevermind and carry on with your interesting decision-making process.
 
You know what? You know what? You're right. I don't know it all and I'll try to think of a way to find out if he's on any addictive meds or illegal drugs.

I must repeat that Cal has been very forthcoming to me with everything else, including admitting he "got the shakes" at work from alcohol starvation. I guess I'm wondering why he'd leave out his heroin use, if he had such a use, for example.

I assure you I will follow-up on this, my concerned friend.

Wow, you're kind of out there. I wasn't even considering illegal drugs.
After talking with you in this thread I'm done.

I don't care any longer. You don't seem to know much about addiction.
 
Wow, you're kind of out there. I wasn't even considering illegal drugs.
After talking with you in this thread I'm done.

I don't care any longer.

As you wish. I realize you are only trying to help and am very sorry if I've disappointed, angered or offended you, m'lady.
 
As you wish. I realize you are only trying to help and am very sorry if I've disappointed, angered or offended you, m'lady.

My concern was for your friend, not you. Possibly you should read up on addiction if you truly want to help your friend.
 
I've known Cal for well over 20 years. We became friends at work, he went on to a different company but we remained friends. He used to coach our company softball team. He's got an undergrad, an MBA, and 2 PHD's. He's got a lot of knowledge but not as much common sense as I wish he could have. Anyway, he's my friend, and I love him.

Cal got divorced, roughly the same time as I did, 2 years ago. As friends, we stopped hanging out for awhile because his wife (now his ex) didn't like hanging around our kids. When Cal got divorced we started hanging out again. Cal is still not over his divorce. His ex-wife is a malignant narcissist. She had and has zero empathy for Cal. She announced she was dumping him at work, in the lobby of their office building, the day before Cal was going to head on vacation. He fainted. She couldn't wait to do it, in private, after Cal returned. Suffice to say, Cal had a pretty ****ing ****ty time on that vacation. Anyway, that's the kind of horrible person she is.

Anyway, Cal's still not over her, although me, his family and all his other friends tell him he does not want her back. He agrees and says, "keep telling me that". Well, ok. But he's got to realize it himself.

So, mourning the end of his marriage 2 years ago Cal started self-medicating with booze. Hard alcohol. Every time I've seen him the past 2 years he's had some kind of drink goin'.

He hosted me and my brother, and his former nephew Christmas for dinner. Cal passed out in his recliner right after dinner. We all ended up cleaning up, putting the food away, then we just left and locked him in. This is when I realized I had to do what I could do to stop this. I called Cal at work the next day and told him for the first time, "Cal, I'm worried about your drinking". He said, "Yeah, it's a bit of a problem".

Anyway, he lives between where my kids' mom lives and where I live. After dropping off the kids, I usually stop by and visit with Cal. Tonight I became a real asshole. When Cal let me in tonight, I said, "Hi, Cal! How's the drinking going?". He joked "it's still going, ha, ha, I'm still doing it!, ha ha". Then later this evening he said, "ha ha, a few hours into work I get the shakes, ha, ha".

And I just ****ing lost it. I said, "So Cal! You're a drunk!". He said, "Yeah, I'm a drunk". So I told him, "we're going to find a meeting by your house, when I get back Saturday you and I are going to an AA meeting". And he agreed. So we're going to Cal's first AA meeting this Saturday. It's a good start!

I'm hopeful!

Good luck to your buddy. Kudos to you for being a bud, even when being a bud is a bitch.
 
My concern was for your friend, not you. Possibly you should read up on addiction if you truly want to help your friend.

Are there any specific texts you are willing to recommend?
 
Are there any specific texts you are willing to recommend?

These days there is much knowledge about addiction and you could find all you need by using Google.

You seem to be into AA so I would suggest you read the Big Book. Also look up blood pressure drugs, anti depressants and opioids, you'll find drinking with any of these drugs is a no no. In fact I'm surprised his doctor is still giving him his meds when aware he's drinking, possibly he isn't aware. No doctor should be giving him these drugs when he's abusing alcohol while taking them.

Also you're using his divorce as an excuse for his drinking, if he's an alcoholic he has an addiction problem and any excuse will work to drink to much. I don't know your friend and only know what you're sharing but the story doesn't add up because of three professionals in the medical world allowing this 65 yr. old man to kill himself by taking the medication along with abusive drinking. Do you have any ideas how much he's drinking?

Just a start but explains where I'm coming from

https://www.alcoholrehabguide.org/alcohol/drinking-and-drugs/
 
Last edited:
These days there is much knowledge about addiction and you could find all you need by using Google.

You seem to be into AA so I would suggest you read the Big Book. Also look up blood pressure drugs, anti depressants and opioids, you'll find drinking with any of these drugs is a no no. In fact I'm surprised his doctor is still giving him his meds when aware he's drinking, possibly he isn't aware. No doctor should be giving him these drugs when he's abusing alcohol while taking them.

Also you're using his divorce as an excuse for his drinking, if he's an alcoholic he has an addiction problem and any excuse will work to drink to much. I don't know your friend and only know what you're sharing but the story doesn't add up because of three professionals in the medical world allowing this 65 yr. old man to kill himself by taking the medication along with abusive drinking. Do you have any ideas how much he's drinking?

Just a start but explains where I'm coming from

https://www.alcoholrehabguide.org/alcohol/drinking-and-drugs/

Ok, well, I mean I guess I need to ask you, do you think I'm lying about any or all of this stuff? I assure you I'm not.

You seem very angry at me about something.

Thanks for the link.
 
So, it's ironic I'm sitting in a bar as a landing area about 5 min from Cal's house. Don't want to be late.

As I sit here Miss ThoughtIsFree's source of consternation with me has become quite clear.
 
I am in ****ing country music hell! This is only place close to his house that has wifi. I asked them to change it but apparently that's what folks want here.

Oh, G*d. Make it stop!
 
Not allowed to talk about the people at the meeting, but it went ok. Cal wont commit to going to the next one - seeing people who had hit rock bottom disturbed him.

I did ask him about addictive drugs as Miss TIF suggested and Cal did admit that he had access to Valium.

Soo.. that could be a problem. I asked him to be careful not to replace one with another. I sure hope he keeps going to meetings!
 
Not allowed to talk about the people at the meeting, but it went ok. Cal wont commit to going to the next one - seeing people who had hit rock bottom disturbed him.

I did ask him about addictive drugs as Miss TIF suggested and Cal did admit that he had access to Valium.

Soo.. that could be a problem. I asked him to be careful not to replace one with another. I sure hope he keeps going to meetings!

If you did any research you now know all of the medications you said Cal was taking are a danger when taken with alcohol and now Valium included. Also you will find people who are using are not usually honest. Much luck to your friend and yourself, this usually isn't an easy fix. Be prepared for your friend to go through ups and downs etc.

Cal may have to hit his rock bottom before he can recover.
 
If you did any research you now know all of the medications you said Cal was taking are a danger when taken with alcohol and now Valium included. Also you will find people who are using are not usually honest. Much luck to your friend and yourself, this usually isn't an easy fix. Be prepared for your friend to go through ups and downs etc.

Cal may have to hit his rock bottom before he can recover.

That's exactly what we talked about in the car on the way back. (Not revealing any names or specifics from the meeting we're not supposed to) but I said something like, "Cal a lot of those folks we saw either have or are hitting rock bottom" I said something to the effect that I'd sure not like to see it get that far with him. He seemed to understand. I also passed along your suggestion that his pschyc take special heed to his med combination. That's all I can do right now until I see something else. My hope is that seeing that seeing some of the folks in the tough shape they were in, (one person had just got out of a month rehab) will shake Cal up a little bit.

That's my hope right now because he doesn't seem too keen now about going to another meeting :(
 
That's exactly what we talked about in the car on the way back. (Not revealing any names or specifics from the meeting we're not supposed to)... :(

Maybe you know a bit about Al-Anon. In 2012, a Florida State agency pushed me into it.

https://www.seattle-al-anon.org/

It has it's faults. In short, I conlude: 1. Bill W had many character defects. 2. The 12-Step programs provides affordable and easy-to-access help to countless people.
 
I've known Cal for well over 20 years. We became friends at work, he went on to a different company but we remained friends. He used to coach our company softball team. He's got an undergrad, an MBA, and 2 PHD's. He's got a lot of knowledge but not as much common sense as I wish he could have. Anyway, he's my friend, and I love him.

Cal got divorced, roughly the same time as I did, 2 years ago. As friends, we stopped hanging out for awhile because his wife (now his ex) didn't like hanging around our kids. When Cal got divorced we started hanging out again. Cal is still not over his divorce. His ex-wife is a malignant narcissist. She had and has zero empathy for Cal. She announced she was dumping him at work, in the lobby of their office building, the day before Cal was going to head on vacation. He fainted. She couldn't wait to do it, in private, after Cal returned. Suffice to say, Cal had a pretty ****ing ****ty time on that vacation. Anyway, that's the kind of horrible person she is.

Anyway, Cal's still not over her, although me, his family and all his other friends tell him he does not want her back. He agrees and says, "keep telling me that". Well, ok. But he's got to realize it himself.

So, mourning the end of his marriage 2 years ago Cal started self-medicating with booze. Hard alcohol. Every time I've seen him the past 2 years he's had some kind of drink goin'.

He hosted me and my brother, and his former nephew Christmas for dinner. Cal passed out in his recliner right after dinner. We all ended up cleaning up, putting the food away, then we just left and locked him in. This is when I realized I had to do what I could do to stop this. I called Cal at work the next day and told him for the first time, "Cal, I'm worried about your drinking". He said, "Yeah, it's a bit of a problem".

Anyway, he lives between where my kids' mom lives and where I live. After dropping off the kids, I usually stop by and visit with Cal. Tonight I became a real asshole. When Cal let me in tonight, I said, "Hi, Cal! How's the drinking going?". He joked "it's still going, ha, ha, I'm still doing it!, ha ha". Then later this evening he said, "ha ha, a few hours into work I get the shakes, ha, ha".

And I just ****ing lost it. I said, "So Cal! You're a drunk!". He said, "Yeah, I'm a drunk". So I told him, "we're going to find a meeting by your house, when I get back Saturday you and I are going to an AA meeting". And he agreed. So we're going to Cal's first AA meeting this Saturday. It's a good start!

I'm hopeful!

Good for you, but the odds of it working out are not good. It is sorry that I have to say that but you cannot stop with an addiction for anyone else, you can only stop if you are convinced you hit rock bottom. But I hope he beats the odds on this and goes on to live a sober life.
 
Not allowed to talk about the people at the meeting, but it went ok. Cal wont commit to going to the next one - seeing people who had hit rock bottom disturbed him.

I did ask him about addictive drugs as Miss TIF suggested and Cal did admit that he had access to Valium.

Soo.. that could be a problem. I asked him to be careful not to replace one with another. I sure hope he keeps going to meetings!

We're all at a disadvantage because we don't know what you saw, but I'll just reiterate that there are likely many groups with many personalities. Some in my area frequently have a pretty big population of those just coming in (i.e. somewhere right at their bottom) and they're depressing for me, and I've been sober a while. I just don't go to them anymore - I sometimes felt worse coming out and that's a bad thing.

My current main group isn't like that. We have a lot of working and retired professionals, and lots of men and some women across the income scale from cooks to business owners with lots of years sober, so they're often pretty upbeat, and before and after meetings is very upbeat. We get quite a few first timers - white chip meetings is what we call them - and they're usually great. The goal is to inspire people, not drag them down.

It would be great if you or your friend could find someone who's been in the program just to talk about AA, what to expect, and what meetings might suit him. You don't have to know the person well - many/most people in AA would be happy to meet for coffee or lunch or whatever, just for the asking. I've done it several times with/for people I don't know at all, friends of friends of friends. The bottom line is someone who doesn't want to go or be there isn't likely to get a lot of benefit.

A couple of people above talked about hitting 'bottom.' I've been in maybe 50 meetings where that's discussed, and I'm not sure it's a helpful concept at some level, mainly because no one from the outside (anyone who isn't the drunk) can know where that is. And for some people, many people, if left to find their own bottom that could mean literally dead. If not from drinking and the many health problems directly or indirectly associated with alcoholism, then from suicide, or a wreck, whatever. Or 'rock bottom' could be married, with a good job and understanding wife and great kids, but just realizing that this **** just cannot go on forever, so it's got to stop. At my regular meeting it ranges from homeless for years and literally barred from the Salvation Army "Until Jesus returns" for fighting and stealing, to a guy who is owner of a major local investment firm, first wife, still married. I knew that guy pretty well through my best friend, and drank with him many times, and it never occurred to me he had a problem, until I went to my current group for the first time and there he was, came in three years before I did.... So from the outside, 'bottom' isn't possible to see and waiting on it IMO is a mistake.

What people absolutely DO have to decide is that it's time, and that being sober and how bad that sucks for a few weeks or months or whatever is better than drinking. That's how I look at 'hitting bottom' and let's all hope your friend's 'bottom' is a high one. Friends (and a great wife) that care went a long way keeping mine from being FAR worse than it could have been, so you're doing the right thing, but at the end of the day that decision was mine and mine alone and my wife and others put up with a lot of **** for a long time before I came around. Whatever happens it's never your fault - that's ALL with the guy with the addiction, not even a little, ever, with those trying to help. :peace
 
Last edited:
Not allowed to talk about the people at the meeting, but it went ok. Cal wont commit to going to the next one - seeing people who had hit rock bottom disturbed him.

I did ask him about addictive drugs as Miss TIF suggested and Cal did admit that he had access to Valium.

Soo.. that could be a problem. I asked him to be careful not to replace one with another. I sure hope he keeps going to meetings!

Don't mean to double reply, but I'll also repeat that AA sure as hell isn't for everyone. If you're in a decent sized city, you might try helping your friend try to find a medical professional that deals with addiction as a regular part of the practice, but that aren't 12-step based.

In my experience, medical doctors who don't regularly TREAT addiction are nearly completely ignorant about it. So just because he's got a doctor doesn't mean that doctor knows anything about treatment. But there are drugs that the evidence shows work.

https://baclofentreatment.com/backg...lofen-in-alcoholism-just-how-effective-is-it/
 
We're all at a disadvantage because we don't know what you saw, but I'll just reiterate that there are likely many groups with many personalities. Some in my area frequently have a pretty big population of those just coming in (i.e. somewhere right at their bottom) and they're depressing for me, and I've been sober a while. I just don't go to them anymore - I sometimes felt worse coming out and that's a bad thing.

My current main group isn't like that. We have a lot of working and retired professionals, and lots of men and some women across the income scale from cooks to business owners with lots of years sober, so they're often pretty upbeat, and before and after meetings is very upbeat. We get quite a few first timers - white chip meetings is what we call them - and they're usually great. The goal is to inspire people, not drag them down.

It would be great if you or your friend could find someone who's been in the program just to talk about AA, what to expect, and what meetings might suit him. You don't have to know the person well - many/most people in AA would be happy to meet for coffee or lunch or whatever, just for the asking. I've done it several times with/for people I don't know at all, friends of friends of friends. The bottom line is someone who doesn't want to go or be there isn't likely to get a lot of benefit.

A couple of people above talked about hitting 'bottom.' I've been in maybe 50 meetings where that's discussed, and I'm not sure it's a helpful concept at some level, mainly because no one from the outside (anyone who isn't the drunk) can know where that is. And for some people, many people, if left to find their own bottom that could mean literally dead. If not from drinking and the many health problems directly or indirectly associated with alcoholism, then from suicide, or a wreck, whatever. Or 'rock bottom' could be married, with a good job and understanding wife and great kids, but just realizing that this **** just cannot go on forever, so it's got to stop. At my regular meeting it ranges from homeless for years and literally barred from the Salvation Army "Until Jesus returns" for fighting and stealing, to a guy who is owner of a major local investment firm, first wife, still married. I knew that guy pretty well through my best friend, and drank with him many times, and it never occurred to me he had a problem, until I went to my current group for the first time and there he was, came in three years before I did.... So from the outside, 'bottom' isn't possible to see and waiting on it IMO is a mistake.

What people absolutely DO have to decide is that it's time, and that being sober and how bad that sucks for a few weeks or months or whatever is better than drinking. That's how I look at 'hitting bottom' and let's all hope your friend's 'bottom' is a high one. Friends (and a great wife) that care went a long way keeping mine from being FAR worse than it could have been, so you're doing the right thing, but at the end of the day that decision was mine and mine alone and my wife and others put up with a lot of **** for a long time before I came around. Whatever happens it's never your fault - that's ALL with the guy with the addiction, not even a little, ever, with those trying to help. :peace

Keep it up, buddy! Thanks.
 
Keep it up, buddy! Thanks.

Perspective after 6.5 years of 12-Step (in my case, Al-Anon) participation:

1. Attendees, with rare exception, intimately know the feeling of wallowing in chaos, melodrama and insanity... and the feeling of a reactive instead of proactive lifestyle.
2. You create your own regimen.. in terms of how often you attend meetings, what program tools you use during and between meetings.
3. At some point, participation led to a sense of understanding the underlying culture via familiarity with steps, traditions, concepts, corny slogans, sharing experience, strength and hope.
4. Incredibly affordable and accessible: you only donate what you want; you can easily find a meeting.
5. While most meetings occur in churches.. admittedly, for me, a religious bias exists, the program has plenty of non-religious people (including me) who actively participate.

My backstory included divorce, four children from three women, sex addiction and familiarity with alcohol and drugs ( I owned a bar in the 1990s). By 2012, I turned 56 that summer, my unsustainable lifestyle caught up with me. The Florida Dept. of Children and Families (DCF) ordered me into Al-Anon... using access to one of my minor children as leverage. I gamed participation in Al-Anon the first two years. In 2014, my home group needed a group representative. No one wanted to serve. I have a decades long background in condo mgmt and as a real estate broker. I accepted the service position. My knowledge of 12-Step accelerated appreciably!
 
Perspective after 6.5 years of 12-Step (in my case, Al-Anon) participation:

1. Attendees, with rare exception, intimately know the feeling of wallowing in chaos, melodrama and insanity... and the feeling of a reactive instead of proactive lifestyle.
2. You create your own regimen.. in terms of how often you attend meetings, what program tools you use during and between meetings.
3. At some point, participation led to a sense of understanding the underlying culture via familiarity with steps, traditions, concepts, corny slogans, sharing experience, strength and hope.
4. Incredibly affordable and accessible: you only donate what you want; you can easily find a meeting.
5. While most meetings occur in churches.. admittedly, for me, a religious bias exists, the program has plenty of non-religious people (including me) who actively participate.

My backstory included divorce, four children from three women, sex addiction and familiarity with alcohol and drugs ( I owned a bar in the 1990s). By 2012, I turned 56 that summer, my unsustainable lifestyle caught up with me. The Florida Dept. of Children and Families (DCF) ordered me into Al-Anon... using access to one of my minor children as leverage. I gamed participation in Al-Anon the first two years. In 2014, my home group needed a group representative. No one wanted to serve. I have a decades long background in condo mgmt and as a real estate broker. I accepted the service position. My knowledge of 12-Step accelerated appreciably!

Wow, Trip! What a story. Thanks for your words of wisdom and I wish you much success and continued sobriety!
 
Wow, Trip! What a story. Thanks for your words of wisdom and I wish you much success and continued sobriety!

When I first attended, while never having gone to a 12-Step meeting, I had vague familiarity for decades with A.A. and N.A.... not a whiff of Al-Anon. Somehow, I went to meetings off and on for two years, 2012-2014, without knowing anything about AA roots, Bill W, his wife Lois or his friend Dr. Bob Smith.

Taking on a Service Position led to in-depth research. Bill W (Wilson), among the majority of 12-Step participants, seems to hold Exalted Status.

After research, my quick impressions: by 1935, using his adeptness with IPOs and as a stockbroker, aided by a financial sponsor, his wife Lois and his recovering alcoholic friend Dr. Smith, and dozens of volunteers, Bill W shepherded the creation and publication of the Big Book. Bill W diverted Copyright Royalties to himself. This created dissension among volunteers. Dr. Bob helped quell the riot. Bill W. rewarded Dr. Bob with 10% interest in the Royalties. A.A.'s ensuing success elevated Bill W's socio-economic status to the level of a national celebrity.

Bill and Lois never had children. Lois tolerated Bill having numerous affairs. In the 1950s, Bill, during an affair with an actress, almost sought a divorce. Bill broke the actress off on the Big Book royalties.

Bill W battled depression. He also had a keen interest in psychic phenomena... frequently participating in seances. In 1956, under clinical conditions, he experimented with LSD. Bill W led quite an interesting life!
 
That's exactly what we talked about in the car on the way back. (Not revealing any names or specifics from the meeting we're not supposed to) but I said something like, "Cal a lot of those folks we saw either have or are hitting rock bottom" I said something to the effect that I'd sure not like to see it get that far with him. He seemed to understand. I also passed along your suggestion that his pschyc take special heed to his med combination. That's all I can do right now until I see something else. My hope is that seeing that seeing some of the folks in the tough shape they were in, (one person had just got out of a month rehab) will shake Cal up a little bit.

That's my hope right now because he doesn't seem too keen now about going to another meeting :(

I'm taking it you went to an open AA meeting? Your friend needs to find a sponsor if he wants to get involved in AA but with saying that he too needs to find a group that suits him. Sounds like the group you attended didn't fit his needs according to him. AA doesn't work for everyone but it's a good start. There's also NA meetings if Cal does have a drug problem too. Either one would work. All kinds of twelve step programs for many different addictions.

You're getting some good advice now in the posts on the thread. Like I've said in other posts, it would be good if you researched and read up on the disease of alcoholism, addiction etc.

I was disappointed you didn't know more about it than you do and were trying to help your friend but the advice being given to you now is very good advice. Just remember you can't do it for him but it's good you care. Good for Cal he has people who care about him. When you have an addiction problem you can end up alienating everyone who cares about you and it's much easier to get sober and stay sober if you know you have someone who loves and cares about you. Doesn't guarantee a recovery or a quick recovery but it helps a lot Also the post telling you all doctors are not educated in treating addiction is true and may be what Cal is experiencing.
 
Serenity Prayer: "God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change..
courage to change the things I can... and wisdom to know the difference."

Al-Anon Declaration: Let it Begin with Me
When anyone, anywhere, reaches out for help, let the hand of Al-Anon and Alateen always be there--
and--Let it Begin with Me.

Trippy T's fondness for a condensed four step version: 1. Give up (with some of your old program).. enough to absorb some of the steps, traditions, concepts and principles. 2. 'Fess up... as in put the focus on yourself and own your situation; invest in some quiet introspective thought. 3. Make up... make amends, when reasonable, for past and current missteps. 4. Keep up... one day at a time, with the steps, traditions, concepts and principles.

I spend about 3 to 4 minutes total a day reading from each of three daily readers: One Day at a Time; Hope For Today; Courage to Change. Al-Anon has many conference approved books and pamphlets. Al-Anon has a Service Manual.

Good Luck!
 
Back
Top Bottom