- Joined
- Jan 6, 2007
- Messages
- 4,829
- Reaction score
- 1,223
- Location
- beneath the surface
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Undisclosed
What I mean is that the term 'free will' invites the definition that we're at will to dictate any outcome. But that needn't be the case for it to operate.
I liken free will to electrical cable. The coloured wires representing possible courses to a destination. The outer covering being limitation. The destination as foregone, not illustrative of the means by which we arrive there. Only that we will.
You wouldn't equate your inability to jump over Mount Everest, as proof of there being no free will. Only that your choices, whilst numerous, are defined by limitation. Hence lack of omnipotence not invalidating the capacity to choose.
You have the capacity to make choices, but not to reorder the universe.
I see.
That's not quite how I described the situation though, with my Adam and Eve scenario. I'll use a different analogy:
Let's say that I have an animal, and we'll call him Bobo. Bobo is not an aquatic creature, he's reptilian in nature, and moves slow like a sloth.
Judging by what I know of Bobo, I would guess that Bobo is not able to swim, and that if I were to drop him into a lake, he would drown. In fact, I'm quite certain of it. 100% certain Bobo will drown.
Now Bobo, as a sentient being, he's able to choose to do things and act upon them. Meaning he has free will. However, If I were to drop him in the middle of a lake, what choices would Bobo have? He can either swim or drown. However, we've already determined that Bobo would be unable to swim, and the two choices presented is misleading because in fact, drowning was the only choice that was actually possible. Just like how jumping over Mt. Everest shouldn't be counted as a possible choice.
The fact that Bobo cannot choose to swim, leads him with the only choice, which strips him of his free will. Essentially, that is the situation that God placed on Adam and Even. It was impossible to obey God 100% because humans are by definition imperfect. The one and only perfect being is God. Therefore, the only choice that was possible for Adam and Eve was to disobey. Having only the one choice, means that there is no free will. The other choices being impossible should not be considered as choices.