• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

What is a good age to have the FULL sex talk?

What is a good age to have the FULL sex talk?


  • Total voters
    30
I disagree. I still leave the room when a sex scene comes up in a movie when my parents are around. It is just uncomfortable and awkward. But kudos for you daughter to coming up and talking to you about it.

She went to her mom actually, but we were pretty open. I mean we are not talking watching a sex scene with your parents.

PS I feel ya, I can't do that either but it really has no bearing.
 
Last edited:
Your right I am just naive, don't listen to a guy who's daughter is married and is an engineer. Hell what do I know?

Wow she is marriaed and an engineer, that means that ALL girls will ask when they want to know hahahahahahahahaha
yes I think you just proved on this subject you are naive
Im also an engineer and my daughter is in the gifted and advance classes that doe not mean she will ask nor do I have faith in such a silly claim

thanls for you reply though
 
sorry I also think this is niave,i do not think that all kids will ask and that is a proven fact
I like to THINK she will, I HOPE she would but its not worth the risk IMO

Proven by who??? Was every kid in the world polled? Please.

I agree w/BD & 10. Kids will let you know when they're ready, and it comes in increments. If you have a trusting relationship with your child(ren), they will ask.

I initiated some with my son when he was 8, and all he did was laugh ("You have a vaGINA??? :laughat: Hahaaaaaaaa!!" ). So I let it go. He came to me at 10 with some questions. I tailored my responses for his age.
 
Wow she is marriaed and an engineer, that means that ALL girls will ask when they want to know hahahahahahahahaha
yes I think you just proved on this subject you are naive
Im also an engineer and my daughter is in the gifted and advance classes that doe not mean she will ask nor do I have faith in such a silly claim

thanls for you reply though

Man I raised a fine daughter. She came to us as do most kids with questions. Not necessarily about sex, but Pre-sex questions. I mean it's not that difficult to figure out.

Then you come on a message board asking for help and when it is offered you call me naive? :roll:

At least I knew enough not to need a bunch of strangers on the Internet to help me raise my children. :doh
 
Proven by who??? Was every kid in the world polled? Please.

uhm are you serious? its easily proven since i dont need to poll every kid there only has to be ONE that doesnt ask and since there are kids that dont ask that makes my statement a fact an proven
so since you said please ill simply say yes you may ;)

I agree w/BD & 10. Kids will let you know when they're ready, and it comes in increments. If you have a trusting relationship with your child(ren), they will ask.
sorry you are just wrong, they MIGHT ask, there is no promise and unless my school district, friends people i grew up with have the most untrusting realationships with thier parents I say its a save "guess" that most kids dont ask cause very few of my friends did, I didnt ask either and I totally trusted my parents, I MIGHT have however but they beat me to it

I initiated some with my son when he was 8, and all he did was laugh ("You have a vaGINA??? :laughat: Hahaaaaaaaa!!" ). So I let it go. He came to me at 10 with some questions. I tailored my responses for his age.

yeah I agree with this part you do have to "tailor" it
 
Man I raised a fine daughter. She came to us as do most kids with questions. Not necessarily about sex, but Pre-sex questions. I mean it's not that difficult to figure out.
again this means nothing as all kids will not ask and I doubt even the majority do
also how you raised your daughter is meaningless too

Then you come on a message board asking for help and when it is offered you call me naive? :roll:

At least I knew enough not to need a bunch of strangers on the Internet to help me raise my children. :doh

nice try at an insult but has usual you fail with egg on your face, again, i clearly already said my game plan which is already planned LOL i was just curious on peopls opinion im still stcking to my game plan, whooops:laughat:
 
She went to her mom actually, but we were pretty open. I mean we are not talking watching a sex scene with your parents.

PS I feel ya, I can't do that either but it really has no bearing.

Well good for you guys. I was pretty open with my parents too about everything but wanting to talk about sex. And I only brought up the sex in movies because many kids are not only feel awkward talking to their parents about sex, but also just watching a scene in a movie, even if there is no sex. Hell it is even worse now thanks to my girlfriend who I love deeply (she is sitting next to me so I had to type that part.)
 
My dad never had any "sex talk" with me, but he knew I read a lot, he did nothing to restrict my reading material at any age, and he knew I'd ask him if I had questions, because I asked him questions about anything I wanted to know about.
The idea of talking to my dad about sex made me really uncomfortable.
It still does, actually.

I never talked to my kids much about sex, either. Their dad talked to them, I guess.
I did talk to them a little bit about puberty and stuff.
It just seems like, by the time you feel maybe you should talk to them, they already know.
And when you try to broach the subject, it's like "Stop! I already know all this, okay? I already know! Just stop."

I just felt like, clearly, they were uncomfortable discussing this with me, just like I was uncomfortable discussing it with my dad.
So I didn't force it.
I figured they probably did already know; they're smart like I was, and they have the added benefit of the internet. There aren't many questions you can't find answers to online.

:shrug:

I hoping to avoid that
we are already pretty open has often i am please and surprised at the stuff she asks me that she hears at school or at sports etc
she does seem gun shy about her girl stuff though so it leaves me suspect, like the spotting at 10, she was not going to tell me or atleast didnt for a while, now once i asked her she opened the gates but i thought it was a little weird not to tell with a kid dealing with blood

oh well like i said im gonna send out some feelers ask her what she knows and feel in the blanks
thanks
 
These days, you'd better start earlier rather than later. Girls probably between 10-12. Boys, 12-13. It does depend to some degree on how mature they are and how much intrest they have in the opposite sex, but don't be 100% sure that they don't have MORE intrest than you THINK they do. Better to be safe and start early.

I don't really believe in having ONE big "talk", though. More like several dozen small talks, based on what they're mature enough to handle, starting at whatever age they start asking questions... and maybe anywhere from two or three (or a dozen) medium-size talks in their early to mid teens as their maturity and intrests grow and change.

At age 5 and under they don't really need to know much. "Babies are made by Mommies and Daddies and come out of Mommy's tummy" is about all they need to hear. That and maybe "good touch/bad touch" and "stranger = danger".

Age 6 to 8... "Sex is something adults who are married and love each other very much do together, and sometimes it makes babies. It's not something you need to worry about much because you're too young yet."

Around 9 to 11 you can sort of go into some of the clinical, technical basics, and just sort of mention that there are risks to having sex outside of marriage (or whatever you believe, if otherwise), that girls can get pregnant the first time and you can catch terrible diseases that never go away if you're not careful, "so don't do it". :)

Somewhere between 11 and 14 you're going to need to be kind of explicit, but it doesn't have to be all in one huge overwhelming dose.

I like the concept of "teachable moments". This is when your kid has a question, or a subject comes up and they're actually listening and intrested in what you have to say about it.... possibly because something has happened or they've seen/heard something that makes it relevant to them. These kind of talks stick with them much better than if the parent just picks some random day and time, interrupts the kid in the middle of his or her homework/video game/ TV time/whatever and says "we need to have a Talk". The latter tends to be much more awkward and more likely to go in one ear and out the other.

One thing I've always done though: I never lie to my child. I may tell him something is none of his business, or I may tell him he isn't ready for some level of information just yet... but I never lie. No storks or cabbage patches or other BS. When he asked me if Santa was real (at age 6), I told him the truth: how the real person St. Nicholas began the custom of giving gifts at Christmas and that he was the source of the Santa legends, but no there really isn't a man in red suit with flying reindeer, sorry. :mrgreen: It's a trust thing: he KNOWS that he can trust anything I tell him and believe me.
 
These days, you'd better start earlier rather than later. Girls probably between 10-12. Boys, 12-13. It does depend to some degree on how mature they are and how much intrest they have in the opposite sex, but don't be 100% sure that they don't have MORE intrest than you THINK they do. Better to be safe and start early.

In this day and age, opposite sex is not a guarantee either by any stretch of the imagination.
 
These days, you'd better start earlier rather than later. Girls probably between 10-12. Boys, 12-13. It does depend to some degree on how mature they are and how much intrest they have in the opposite sex, but don't be 100% sure that they don't have MORE intrest than you THINK they do. Better to be safe and start early.

I don't really believe in having ONE big "talk", though. More like several dozen small talks, based on what they're mature enough to handle, starting at whatever age they start asking questions... and maybe anywhere from two or three (or a dozen) medium-size talks in their early to mid teens as their maturity and intrests grow and change.

At age 5 and under they don't really need to know much. "Babies are made by Mommies and Daddies and come out of Mommy's tummy" is about all they need to hear. That and maybe "good touch/bad touch" and "stranger = danger".

Age 6 to 8... "Sex is something adults who are married and love each other very much do together, and sometimes it makes babies. It's not something you need to worry about much because you're too young yet."

Around 9 to 11 you can sort of go into some of the clinical, technical basics, and just sort of mention that there are risks to having sex outside of marriage (or whatever you believe, if otherwise), that girls can get pregnant the first time and you can catch terrible diseases that never go away if you're not careful, "so don't do it". :)

Somewhere between 11 and 14 you're going to need to be kind of explicit, but it doesn't have to be all in one huge overwhelming dose.

I like the concept of "teachable moments". This is when your kid has a question, or a subject comes up and they're actually listening and intrested in what you have to say about it.... possibly because something has happened or they've seen/heard something that makes it relevant to them. These kind of talks stick with them much better than if the parent just picks some random day and time, interrupts the kid in the middle of his or her homework/video game/ TV time/whatever and says "we need to have a Talk". The latter tends to be much more awkward and more likely to go in one ear and out the other.

One thing I've always done though: I never lie to my child. I may tell him something is none of his business, or I may tell him he isn't ready for some level of information just yet... but I never lie. No storks or cabbage patches or other BS. When he asked me if Santa was real (at age 6), I told him the truth: how the real person St. Nicholas began the custom of giving gifts at Christmas and that he was the source of the Santa legends, but no there really isn't a man in red suit with flying reindeer, sorry. :mrgreen: It's a trust thing: he KNOWS that he can trust anything I tell him and believe me.

thanks!
and I agree with very much of this and have also done it
especially the teachable moments at the younger age, at older ages i feel it might be too late as the "moment" may have happened without me there, you know what I mean

I have also practiced the trust thing and told mine about santa early
seems like my plan is solid and fitting and not uncommon
 
In this day and age, opposite sex is not a guarantee either by any stretch of the imagination.

agreed and this will never be a problem in my house hold as there will be no fear if she is gay, she has already questioned gay and that was one of the mini talks. It was about when she was 9 or 10 I simply told her some girls like girls and some guys like guys, she responded, "oh, ok".

so easy, i wish all talks were that simple ;)
 
In this day and age, opposite sex is not a guarantee either by any stretch of the imagination.


I started to say "the opposite, or whatever, sex", but I just couldn't quite bring myself to do so.
 
I started to say "the opposite, or whatever, sex", but I just couldn't quite bring myself to do so.

yeah, gotta deal with reality though
 
again this means nothing as all kids will not ask and I doubt even the majority do

Please point out where I said all kids do? I said MINE did. :doh

After that I said they will. Again nothing about all kids. Even your initial reply was an attack that had very little to do with my statement.

also how you raised your daughter is meaningless too

You asked for peoples opinions.

nice try at an insult but has usual you fail with egg on your face, again, i clearly already said my game plan which is already planned LOL i was just curious on peopls opinion im still stcking to my game plan, whooops:laughat:

:roll:
 
Last edited:
I meant to vote 13, not 9. Oops.

I think a talk on sex is something that should happen the moment you become a teenager.
 
Im having it this month with my daughter has Im a single dad with full custody and she has finally started her period and is talking about boys.

We have had small talks starting at 10( since some girls get their period this early and she did have spotting that went away) but not the full talk so I really want her to know she is "bad" for having thoughts or the "devil" and I really want to be there for her so I can fill in any questions and we have a open door communication built.

Dont want her learning/thinkin stupid things I hear kids say like girl on top cant get pregnant, or do it under water and you cant get pregnant. IMO information is always the way to go.

Also in 2 years her sex ed will be waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay more than I ever had at her age has i saw her future health book, man its crazy but yet great at the same time.

I voted "other".

There should always be an open line of communication. She should feel safe coming to you with her questions. Answer them as they are asked. "The talk" begins as soon as they can understand speach and continues until one of you die.

If i had a daughter that age, I might find a woman I trusted to go over the feminine issues with her.
 
Last edited:
Please point out where I said all kids do? I said MINE did. :doh
After that I said they will. Again nothing about all kids. Even your initial reply was an attack that had very little to do with my statement.
attack? lol you are so sensitive
point it out? thats easy. too easy
you said you answered other because they will ask when they are ready
i asked how will you know whan a child is read
you said "Because my daughter asked me. The child will let you know when they are ready because they will ask."

if that is not implying that all kids will ask then you should have said it differently, since my question was about kids in general LOL

You asked for peoples opinions.
sure did but i didnt ask you how your kids turned out so you repeating my daughter is this or tthat or my daughter is fine etc has no barring on whether a child will ask their parents which is what i was disputing. she could be 1st femal president no bearing on whether she or any other kid will ask



hard to eye roll with egg on your face isnt it :D
 
I voted "other".

There should always be an open line of communication. She should feel safe coming to you with her questions. Answer them as they are asked. "The talk" begins as soon as they can understand speach and continues until one of you die.

If i had a daughter that age, I might find a woman I trusted to go over the feminine issues with her.


agreed as im also doing this which is her gram, my mom since they are very close. When i first suspected spotting at 10 I had my mom feel it out then I joined and let her know im fully aware of girl stuff, i can be talked too and of course always want to know

thanks
 
Im having it this month with my daughter has Im a single dad with full custody and she has finally started her period and is talking about boys.

We have had small talks starting at 10( since some girls get their period this early and she did have spotting that went away) but not the full talk so I really want her to know she is "bad" for having thoughts or the "devil" and I really want to be there for her so I can fill in any questions and we have a open door communication built.

Dont want her learning/thinkin stupid things I hear kids say like girl on top cant get pregnant, or do it under water and you cant get pregnant. IMO information is always the way to go.

Also in 2 years her sex ed will be waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay more than I ever had at her age has i saw her future health book, man its crazy but yet great at the same time.

I think both of my kids asked me to explain sex sometime when they were in elementary school, but since that time, there have been dozens of other discussions on everything you can even imagine. I'd say 11 is peak time. I wouldn't necessarily try to cover it all at once, which might be awkward for both of you, but do it gradually, in small pieces, as subjects come up.
 
I meant to vote 13, not 9. Oops.

I think a talk on sex is something that should happen the moment you become a teenager.

cant say i disagree I voted other because I think it does depend on the child but i also admit that I wouldnt wait past 8th grade, 14 or so
 
Say that when your daughter comes home to tell you that she's knocked up.

My daughters and step daughter don't make a move that I don't know about.

no offense, but this is how I was raised, and as soon as I went to college, I went nuts. Introducing kids gradually to some degree of freedom allows the teenager to internalize their own values and own them, versus having them forced on them by the parent (and the kids never really take ownership of them).
 
I think both of my kids asked me to explain sex sometime when they were in elementary school, but since that time, there have been dozens of other discussions on everything you can even imagine. I'd say 11 is peak time. I wouldn't necessarily try to cover it all at once, which might be awkward for both of you, but do it gradually, in small pieces, as subjects come up.

agree, i call it big talk only because im going to keep it going as long as seems fitting as most other small talks I cut once intial questions were answered, not always but most times
 
I never talked to my kids much about sex, either. Their dad talked to them, I guess.
I did talk to them a little bit about puberty and stuff.I figured they probably did already know; they're smart like I was, and they have the added benefit of the internet. There aren't many questions you can't find answers to online.

:shrug:


What kids can't find on the internet is a value system to help them sort out and make choices about their sexuality. The conversations I have had with my kids have never involved mechanics. They've involved things like how you know when you're ready to have sex, what affect sex has on your life, what it all means.

ONe of the best conversations I ever had with my daughter was after she found condoms in her dad's car. It was about how people deal with sex and protection, and how her dad's philosophy is kind of to fly by the seat of his pants and be prepared for anything, but my philosophy is that I don't enjoy sex with strangers or without that emotional connection, and how I usually know well in advance if I'm going to have sex, so I don't keep condoms in my car, just in case. In an ideal world, sex is best between two people who are in an exclusive relationship and who love each other, and she should make sure that a guy deserves her. But when and if she does choose to have sex, it's really important to protect herself, and to always plan for that, however that works for her. what I wanted her to get out of it was that there are a lot of possible risks connected to sex, and that she will have a lot of friends who view sex differently, but that for me, ideally, she'll be picky and only choose to be with a guy who really adores her and proves that over time.

Kids don't need conversations these days about "this is a penis, and it goes into a vagina." They need conversations about how to protect themselves emotionally, how to say no gracefully, and the ramifications of having sex at 16. For instance, one conversation my daughter and I've had repeatedly is about the fact that having sex with a high school boy is basically like having sex with the entire high school, because he'll tell all his buddies, and they'll tell all their buddies, and on and on, so there is basically no privacy about that sort of decision at her age. And, that is stuff that she needs to know and think about, and have reinforced by experiences that she observes, over time. Same with her brother.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom