It makes complete sense.
That you have taken an unsupportable position is -your- problem. Nothing in taking the position that there is no God in any way necessitates that anyone first even attempt to prove God.
In other words, you're not interested in logical analysis, you just want to see the other side fail...because that's all that matters, right?
Even if the atheist makes such a ridiculous claim, it doesn't make yours correct. Just the same as someone who points out a mistake of someone's, doesn't make you any more correct.
Not if --everythnig-- is created by the laws of physics, you don't.
If --everything-- is created by the laws of physics, then you create NOTHING, including decisions on what you're doing for dinner or any other 'choice' you think you made. ALL of this was pre-determined at the moment of the big bang.
Yes, yes. We know already, you're speaking about the illusion of free will. I've actually remembered our last couple of posts, you don't need to repeat it.
Sure you can -- if everything was created by the laws of physics, then it is, necessarily, not 'authentic' free will.
And how does that affect your life? Show me how it is self-evident.
I can show you how I can choose my dinner. I can have pork chops or baked potatoes, or maybe even both tonight. Or, maybe I'll decide to eat out. Or, maybe I'm feeling lazy and I'll be content with instant noodles. THIS is self evident. I make my own choices.
If there is no free will, and you think my choice in dinner is just the illusion of free will, how does it affect my life? If I had chosen pork chops, am I less happy with my fake choice? Will I be depressed, will I be disappointed, will I be unsatisfied? I don't think so. In the end, I still did whatever it is I chose to do, whether it's authentic free will or the illusion of free will.
If the opposite is so self-evident to you, then show me.