• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Democrats Reverse U.S. Policy, Negotiate With Terrorists-Even the Taliban

Read the intro and vote accordingly


  • Total voters
    14
Moderator's Warning:
Quit the ****, Kapeesh?
I would inform tal that the correct spelling is capeche, but i fear it may result in an insubordination penalty with 10 points and a 2 day suspension :doh:lol:
 
I would inform tal that the correct spelling is capeche, but i fear it may result in an insubordination penalty with 10 points and a 2 day suspension :doh:lol:

Italian term or phrase: capice
Italian

English translation:do you understand? do you get it?
Explanation:
usually in the form of a question; the standard Italian form should be "capisci" (second person, informal) or "capisce" (third person, formal)
In the American form the last vowel is dropped, but in Italian all vowels are pronounced.

capice
 
Yeah, how could Islamic fundamentalists who deliberately facilitated the murder of 3,000 Americans possibly be misconstrued as an enemy? :lol:
I prefer to think and reason beyond the silly and childish friends/enemies thing...
Its the extremists who are the problem...that and their ignorance and fear..let them die off and be replaced with those who can think rationally....But I see little wrong in accelerating the process...Its tough, but we must know why these murderous animals hate us so...This is why I favor "negotation"...
They could learn something, and so can we...
 
I don't think negotiations accessorized by a Stryker brigade and platoons of marines is neccessarily what I would call "grovel, appease, and surrender". But let's not let facts get in the way of your blogging enjoyment.


Um...how dare you. It's Marines...not "marines."
 
Do both of these sects not shelter and aid al Qaida?

No, they don't.

This is the main governing council of the Taliban, headed by Mullah [Mohammad] Omar?

Right. Now, they don't have, you know, a permanent office, but they are in the area, and they have meetings there. And it's been tough not only for us but for our Pakistani allies to gain access and control into Quetta, into the surrounding area.

And as you move further north into more mountainous terrain, into South Waziristan, North Waziristan, you get this tribal collection. Many are allied with the Taliban, view themselves as Pakistani Taliban. And others who have resisted have faced some pretty harsh retaliation. Perhaps as many as 200 tribal leaders have been assassinated by the Taliban and Al Qaeda.

FRONTLINE: the war briefing: interviews: henry crumpton | PBS
 
The problem with this: According to the arguments hysterically put forward at every turn for the last eight years by liberals, such "arrogant meddling" in the Islamic world would excuse another decade or two of terrorist attacks against America and continue making us the aggressors for daring to fight back.

Welcome to the national dialogue that thinking, reasonable adults must have with liberals.

The strategy being employed is that which has been spelled out in the new, widely praised Army & USMC Counterinsurgency field manual written, in part, by LTC. John Nagl (Ret.).
 
Here is the best explanation I've read so far to explain the complexity of the situation in Afghanistan and how all the Taliban are not the same.

What do the Pashtuns think of the border?

The Pashtuns don't think much of the border. They go back and forth between it. I'll give you an example.

There is this Pashtun, Jalaluddin Haqqani, who's from the Khost-Miram Shah area. Khost is the Afghan side of the border; Miram Shah, North Waziristan, is the Pakistan side of the border. In the 1980s, back in the day when I was reporting on the mujahideen, Jalaluddin Haqqani used to give interviews to me and other journalists. He was the recipient of U.S./CIA aid. He was a big, fierce fighter against the Soviet occupiers of Afghanistan, and that's why we supported him.

Fast-forward a little bit: We neglected the region after the Soviets fell. We pulled out. Haqqani is a man of utter realism and pragmatism. He eventually allied himself with Al Qaeda, with Osama bin Laden. Haqqani stayed in the region, and lo and behold, he's now one of the most wanted people on the FBI files, or he's up there with the bad guys, all because of our neglect in a way. I don't believe that Haqqani, unlike other mujahideen leaders, was implacably anti-Western. I think he was out for the highest bidder, always.

But anyway, Haqqani and his troops -- and Haqqani is very sick now. His son is really in charge. Haqqani, I believe, has Parkinson's disease. Haqqani's people, his troops, which reputedly were involved in the Indian Embassy bombing in Kabul, move back and forth over this border as if this border doesn't exist. The border is their region of control essentially, both the Afghan side and the Pakistan side. And Haqqani is just one of these figures who's been around for 20 years or more and is a testimony to our neglect and, in [a] way, to our failure in the region.

The other is Gulbuddin Hekmatyar who, unlike Haqqani, has always been implacably anti-Western, implacably pro-Arab, pro-Wahhabi, pro-radical Saudi. Even in the 1980s he took money from the U.S. via the Pakistani intelligence people, but always was very clear in his hatred of the West. Hekmatyar has a presence in Kunar province near Nuristan. He has a presence in Logar province. In these places he's liked; he's respected by the people. He has real territory with tunnels, with tree cover. It's a place where bin Laden might theoretically [be in] hiding if he isn't on the Pakistani side of the border.

Then there's Abdul Razul Sayyaf, again from the 1980s, mujahideen leader, got support from the United States, but implacably anti-Western, implacably anti-American, implacably pro-Wahhabi, pro-radical Saudi, who is, again, still active.

So it's much more complex than just the Al Qaeda and the Taliban and the Karzai government -- the good guys and the bad guys, so to speak. There are a lot of players in this thing, and unless we start breaking off the pieces, dealing with some of the bad guys who are willing to be dealt with, if the price were right, we're not going to make progress.


FRONTLINE: the war briefing: interviews: robert d. kaplan | PBS
 
Back
Top Bottom