• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Why Do African Americans Vote Democrat?

Why do African Americans Vote Democrat?


  • Total voters
    29
1.) Post number 103

2.) That was why I asked if you would review my post for me as I figured you would be an impartial judge (at least I thought you would be before reading that message :p. )

1.) ok ill read it, and to be clear you want to know if 103 comes across as you trying to say that black people were handicapped in any sort of way? right
2.) thanks and of course i will, his dishonest claims about the topic have no effect on your post or my opinion of your posts ;)

give me a sec
 
Again, not once I have said anything remotely close to that so you will have to find something else to clutch your pearls about.

And, once again you've failed to admit the obvious. The reason black people vote overwhelmingly for Democrats is the Republican party is racist as ****.

You can't admit that.

You gotta blame minority wrong-thinking.
 
1.) ok ill read it, and to be clear you want to know if 103 comes across as you trying to say that black people were handicapped in any sort of way? right
2.) thanks and of course i will, his dishonest claims about the topic have no effect on your post or my opinion of your posts ;)

give me a sec

I will explain what I meant after you have read it to make sure the post came out clearly. Just wanted to know if it was genuinely worded poorly or if it was being read in bad faith.
 
Out of curiosity, did my post earlier (103) come across as me trying to say that black people were handicapped in any sort of way? Just wanted to know if I'm going crazy or if Eco is on another gender studies ego trip.

1.) I used to have this conversation all the time with a coworker because I never understood why he would vote Democrat despite disagreeing with virtually everything the party stands for: He is a Deacon for the church, a gun nut, will never vote for a woman, Pro Life, against drug legalization, anti same sex marriage, and the rest but consistently votes Democratic and has all of his life and to top it off his father did so as well (this is an older gentleman so this would put his father literally voting for Jim Crow Democrats in the south).

2.) My theory is that the messaging of the Democratic party speaks to the African American community in ways that the Republican message simply can't.
3.) The Republican message is that of individualism while Democrats preach collectivism.
4.) I think that the years of persecution that African Americans have suffered instilled a need for community and a sense of shared racial identity that white people simply don't have.
5.) Another theory I had was that African Americans are disproportionately poor so that increases the likelihood that they may personally know a friend/family member on welfare and thus would be less likely to want vote for someone that would want to cut social welfare programs. I don't really see this one though as it wouldn't explain my coworkers father who was a lifelong Democrat even during the Jim Crow South.

Ok start to finish NO you most certainly didnt say anything like that at all to anybody normal. I dont fully agree with everything you said but thats meaningless to your question

i will break it down regardless cause i like conversation
1.) I an independent but I dont think being a deacon, gun nut, against drug legalization are antidemocratic.
now being against equal and or current rights is a tougher one and something i feel is VERY hypocritical for a black man and at not really a democratic thing but again i do know dems like him black, white etc.

anyway, i still think the answer to your question is in my post where i quoted myself when i said:
time after time at the GOP upper level bills/laws/rights support/lean/have anti-minority policies/views/language directly or indirectly and its common

things like antigay marriage and prolife are pretty much lost causes IN MY OPINION so i dont know if they are things politically rational people will cling too so taking the lose on those things but not giving into what i just said above seems like the much easier choice to me . .

even though im independent when it comes to president voting it very much is a factor for me . . not locally though and lower level voting

2.) i dont necessarily agree with this the way you worded it but the GOP message, again at the top level, more times than not is antiminority for one reason or another whether they mean it to be or not and thats the real issue. I dont think the democrats are that great at speaking to minorities but they are heads and heels better at not speaking AGAINST them

3.) ive never gotten this vibe from the parties either but again thats just me. I dont think dems speak collectivism at all

4.) this is true in many regards, a GENERAL sense of community is stronger in minorities based on race simply due to a sense of security/protection

5.) while your stats are correct i believe, ive never really heard that being an issue (who people know) but in general, at least stereo-typically, the dems support safety nets for citizens and thats simply typical of individuals that are dems vs a race thing.

But again to reiterate NOT you said nothing along the lines of what you were illogical and falsely accused of.
 
But why did you leave out the most important one that override's the others?

"Follow the money"(wink)

$$$$$$$

Exactly. If incompetent in other ways, democrats are not slow when it comes to embezzling government grant money for personal expenses.

13 Democrats Charged With Embezzling $16 Million In Federal Grants For AIDS Charities

DeBlasio and his wife also absconded with nearly a million dollars in grant money but who in NY expects the crooked NY judicial system will ever investigate that?
 
I will explain what I meant after you have read it to make sure the post came out clearly. Just wanted to know if it was genuinely worded poorly or if it was being read in bad faith.

IMO it was CLEARLY bad faith because i would definitely have ZERO problem telling you if i thought the post was BS or came off degrading to minorities
 
Exactly. If incompetent in other ways, democrats are not slow when it comes to embezzling government grant money for personal expenses.

13 Democrats Charged With Embezzling $16 Million In Federal Grants For AIDS Charities

DeBlasio and his wife also absconded with nearly a million dollars in grant money but who in NY expects the crooked NY judicial system will ever investigate that?

Dude, you're barking up the wrong tree here

I'm talking about the TRILLIONS spent on LBJ's "Great society"

Come on guy...(LOL)


EDITORIAL: The not-so-Great Society turns a rickety 50 - Washington Times
 
Ok start to finish NO you most certainly didnt say anything like that at all to anybody normal. I dont fully agree with everything you said but thats meaningless to your question

i will break it down regardless cause i like conversation
1.) I an independent but I dont think being a deacon, gun nut, against drug legalization are antidemocratic.
now being against equal and or current rights is a tougher one and something i feel is VERY hypocritical for a black man and at not really a democratic thing but again i do know dems like him black, white etc.

anyway, i still think the answer to your question is in my post where i quoted myself when i said:
time after time at the GOP upper level bills/laws/rights support/lean/have anti-minority policies/views/language directly or indirectly and its common

things like antigay marriage and prolife are pretty much lost causes IN MY OPINION so i dont know if they are things politically rational people will cling too so taking the lose on those things but not giving into what i just said above seems like the much easier choice to me . .

even though im independent when it comes to president voting it very much is a factor for me . . not locally though and lower level voting

2.) i dont necessarily agree with this the way you worded it but the GOP message, again at the top level, more times than not is antiminority for one reason or another whether they mean it to be or not and thats the real issue. I dont think the democrats are that great at speaking to minorities but they are heads and heels better at not speaking AGAINST them

3.) ive never gotten this vibe from the parties either but again thats just me. I dont think dems speak collectivism at all

4.) this is true in many regards, a GENERAL sense of community is stronger in minorities based on race simply due to a sense of security/protection

5.) while your stats are correct i believe, ive never really heard that being an issue (who people know) but in general, at least stereo-typically, the dems support safety nets for citizens and thats simply typical of individuals that are dems vs a race thing.

But again to reiterate NOT you said nothing along the lines of what you were illogical and falsely accused of.

Thank you much for the fully thought out post and break down.

IF you had agreed with #3 would you have viewed that as a plausible reasoning for why the Democratic party has such a strong appeal to African Americans in particular?

#5 sounds right and makes sense, but like you said it isn't something you typically hear as a reason for voting.

As far as antiminiority sentiment in GOP bills, I can see that to an extent but think some of it is purposely framed in that way in order to paint the GOP in a negative light (they don't exactly help themselves either).
 
IMO it was CLEARLY bad faith because i would definitely have ZERO problem telling you if i thought the post was BS or came off degrading to minorities

Thank you much, I figured as much. I felt like we disagree and agree on things about equally on threads we have been in together so figured I would get an honest opinion from you.

Edit: It seems from your other post that even though you disagreed with me you ultimately understood what I was talking about.
 
1.) Thank you much for the fully thought out post and break down.
2.)IF you had agreed with #3 would you have viewed that as a plausible reasoning for why the Democratic party has such a strong appeal to African Americans in particular?

#5 sounds right and makes sense, but like you said it isn't something you typically hear as a reason for voting.

3.) As far as antiminiority sentiment in GOP bills, I can see that to an extent but think some of it is purposely framed in that way in order to paint the GOP in a negative light (they don't exactly help themselves either).

1.) no problem
2.) actually no because to me collectivism would mean less individual rights and i cant see minorities really supporting that, would seem very counter productive to me and that doesnt match with how the majority of dems i know either
3.) well i disagree with that to but only partially. I think at times its EXAGGERATED and by SOME individuals its greatly exaggerated but its definitely there none the less. Especially with social issues and not wanting stronger, broader spread individual rights and equal rights. Top level its a HUGE issue IMO for the gop.
 
1.) no problem
2.) actually no because to me collectivism would mean less individual rights and i cant see minorities really supporting that, would seem very counter productive to me and that doesnt match with how the majority of dems i know either
3.) well i disagree with that to but only partially. I think at times its EXAGGERATED and by SOME individuals its greatly exaggerated but its definitely there none the less. Especially with social issues and not wanting stronger, broader spread individual rights and equal rights. Top level its a HUGE issue IMO for the gop.

You got me wanting to start a Individualism vs Collectivism thread now because the Democrats to me are clearly collectivists that believe the greater good deserves more consideration than individual rights (particularly economically/property rights)

EDIT: They are even starting to call themselves Socialists now for goodness sakes

I actually think we agree more than we disagree on #3. I also think a large part of it has to do with the topic of this discussion. I believe it to be more about winning than any sort of racial animosity.
 
Last edited:
If Democrats are good for them then they are smart for supporting them. If Democrats are bad for them then they are stupid for supporting them. There is no option C. One of those things must be the truth, you just don't want to expose what you really are by answering the question.

Such desperation to demonstrate your lack of depth, an empty suit.
 
1.) You got me wanting to start a Individualism vs Collectivism thread now because the Democrats to me are clearly collectivists that believe the greater good deserves more consideration than individual rights (particularly economically/property rights)
2.)I actually think we agree more than we disagree on
3.) I also think a large part of it has to do with the topic of this discussion.
4.) I believe it to be more about winning than any sort of racial animosity.

1.) could be an interesting thread but it seems really subjective, i just simply used the basic definition of collectivism and i dont see either party being that way since this is america. Collectivism doesnt really work on any large scale with america period.

ALso i dont get your examples at all.
economical? unless you mean in a VERY general way i dont see it and i dont see the gop being different other than what they want economically
property rights? youd have to give me an example of that too and again i cant imagine either party not being guilty of whatever example that is provided just in a different way

3.) we probably do, like i said the exaggeration is definitely there, and even abused by some but the foundation its built on actually exists is still reality
4.) not sure what you mean about this, are you saying the GOP may have those policies based on winning using its base than animosity?
 
You have some explaining to do to why 90% of blacks vote democrat right?

they don't, another poster explained that already
 
I missed it

Could you kindly explain it to me?

well given so many blacks don't vote, the real assertion is that 90% of those who bother to vote, generally are a monolithic vote for Dems. but since many do not, 90% of blacks don't vote for the dems.
 
well given so many blacks don't vote, the real assertion is that 90% of those who bother to vote, generally are a monolithic vote for Dems. but since many do not, 90% of blacks don't vote for the dems.

well given so many blacks don't vote,

So in other words they mean absolutely Nada, zero and zip then?
 
well given so many blacks don't vote, the real assertion is that 90% of those who bother to vote, generally are a monolithic vote for Dems. but since many do not, 90% of blacks don't vote for the dems.

. but since many do not, 90% of blacks don't vote for the dems.

*sigh*



"One of the penalties for refusing to participate in politics is that you end up being governed by your inferiors".

- Plato
 
Just a little bit history.

General:

GOP wants to create more working places and to tear poor out.
Dems lying and cheating minorities, need gullible voters only

the-two-platforms-the-democratic-platicrm-the-repandlican-platform-democrats-26110159.png
 
1.) could be an interesting thread but it seems really subjective, i just simply used the basic definition of collectivism and i dont see either party being that way since this is america. Collectivism doesnt really work on any large scale with america period.

ALso i dont get your examples at all.
economical? unless you mean in a VERY general way i dont see it and i dont see the gop being different other than what they want economically
property rights? youd have to give me an example of that too and again i cant imagine either party not being guilty of whatever example that is provided just in a different way

3.) we probably do, like i said the exaggeration is definitely there, and even abused by some but the foundation its built on actually exists is still reality
4.) not sure what you mean about this, are you saying the GOP may have those policies based on winning using its base than animosity?

1. Take the concept of wealth, for Republicans wealth is the property of the individual that earned it but for Democrats wealth isn't earned by the individual but generated and distributed by the state. This is why you see Republicans calling for tax cuts as they believe that money is the property of the individual and thus the government should take as little as possible. For Democrats, a tax cut is a "give away" to the rich as the money belongs not to the individual that earned it but to the state.


4. No, I'm saying what is typically viewed as animosity toward minorities has nothing to do with the color of their skin and more to do with how they vote. For instance, if Mexican immigrants voted largely for Republicans then the positions of the parties would flip over night.
 
For over 5 decades running close to 90% of African American voters have voted Democrat. That's almost the entire African American Race. Why do they keep doing that?

....both of the poll options are stupid?
 
Why Do African Americans Vote Democrat?

Silly question. Ever watched a Trump rally?

Long term Kennedy and LBJ
 
For over 5 decades running close to 90% of African American voters have voted Democrat. That's almost the entire African American Race. Why do they keep doing that?

The vote Democratic now because the southern Dixiecrats turned to the Republicans after The Civil Rights Act.
 
I see. You are saying blacks vote democrat because they favor democrat policies like abortion, homosexuality, gun bans, Bible bans, restrictions on Christian testimony, prayer restrictions, anti-American socialism, illegal, immoral, and unethical persecution of republicans, disrespect for cops. legalization of mind-altering drugs, dismissal of charges against drug pushers for selling drugs to the poor, and so forth.

No what I said was different in that it was based on facts, statistics, and didn't involve conspiracy theories and off the wall insane accusations.
 
For over 5 decades running close to 90% of African American voters have voted Democrat. That's almost the entire African American Race. Why do they keep doing that?

Ask this question next November. :cool:
 
Back
Top Bottom