• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Will the United States retain it's status as the world's superpower for the foreseeable future?

Will the United States retain it's status as the world's superpower for the foreseeable future?

  • Yes, the United States will remain on top with no real challenges to it's position.

    Votes: 16 23.9%
  • The US will still be a superpower, but will share it with other countries.

    Votes: 24 35.8%
  • The United States will recede from it's status as a superpower and be replaced by another country.

    Votes: 12 17.9%
  • The US will recede as a superpower, but no other country will be able to fill that spot.

    Votes: 3 4.5%
  • Other (Please Explain)

    Votes: 5 7.5%
  • I really want some eggs, bacon, hashbrown, butter toast, waffles, syrup, and some OJ.

    Votes: 7 10.4%

  • Total voters
    67
My money is on Canada. After the ice melts, that is the place to be.

The US will have trouble just supplying water to LA, PHX, El Paso, Miami and Atlanta.
 
Option 2, because its already well under way.
 
Will the United States retain it's status as the world's superpower for the foreseeable future?

Feel free to explain your choice if you want.

By century’s end, the US will be like Russia is now, a dying economic backwater, but still semi-relevant because of our nuclear arsenal. China will have replaced us as the dominant world power, and the world will descend into tyranny.
 
By century’s end, the US will be like Russia is now, a dying economic backwater, but still semi-relevant because of our nuclear arsenal. China will have replaced us as the dominant world power, and the world will descend into tyranny.

Nah, we'll be saved by brown people who can handle the heat.
 
President Trump is trying to make that happen. Guess what? Democrats hate him for it!

President Trump is going about it the wrong way. He's cosying up to dictators and alienating allies. That's why people oppose his foreign policies.
 
President Trump is going about it the wrong way. He's cosying up to dictators and alienating allies. That's why people oppose his foreign policies.


Allies?
 
By century’s end, the US will be like Russia is now, a dying economic backwater, but still semi-relevant because of our nuclear arsenal. China will have replaced us as the dominant world power, and the world will descend into tyranny.

By century's end? It's more imminent than that. The process is unstoppable. Just a generation ago the world was agog at the US making diplomatic overtures to a bound-up insular China still trying to climb out of 'developing' status and today Trump is trying to negotiate a trade agreement with them. The American dominance that began after WW2 will be the shortest-lived hegemony in history.
 
Will the United States retain it's status as the world's superpower for the foreseeable future?

Feel free to explain your choice if you want.

The issue is going to be managing the decline of China when our tech theft holes are plugged forcing them to create their own R&D to maintain technological relevance, without having a shooting war in the SCS. I say that because some strategists see using the SCS as an economic barrier to keep US products out. Without the SCS sea lanes, it’s a long way around going the southern route.
 
Canada for one. About your staunchest ally.
Unless you figure the US has no allies, you stand alone.




Canada does not like us! They’re pissed because we have a democracy and elected someone they disapprove of.
 
Will the United States retain it's status as the world's superpower for the foreseeable future?

Feel free to explain your choice if you want.

First we must ask, what is the UNITED States of A?
I think the train has left the station, unless we gather together once again in the face of some tragedy (God forbid) that pales partisan nonsense.
My take is this. We have it too good, we are too spoiled. So we are left to complain about the most ridiculous nonsense. I bet you that millions of people would love to trade places with us.
 
Canada does not like us! They’re pissed because we have a democracy and elected someone they disapprove of.

Alright. We'll just let that dumb statement lay on the table in all it's glory.
 
We'll stay on top, so long as we keep the Democrats out.
 
It depends on whether the new progressive-fascist international Democratic Party gains power. If so, no. The United States will rapidly cease to be the super power and soon after not a super at all - militarily, economically or in world influence.
Otherwise, if Trump-like Republicans are in control (they are not now and have not been due to malcontent bad loser Republicans and RINOs), the decline MIGHT be able to be stopped.
The odds are overwhelmingly in favor of China becoming the top super power and overall power and wealth shifting from the West to the East.
 
I doubt you know the half of it

America's High-Tech STEM Crisis




Note the majority of foreign students in US universities are from China, followed by India

Yes, Americans are being denied admissions into American universities on behalf of students from our economic and increasingly military adversaries - underwritten by the Federal Government.

If this were WW2, the new progressive-fascist Democratic Party would send all information, material and scientists about the atom bomb to Germany and Japan, stopping our own program.
 
Will the United States retain it's status as the world's superpower for the foreseeable future?

Feel free to explain your choice if you want.

Unless something very drastic happens to alter the economic and military trajectories of the world's first tier powers, the USA has about another decade as an effective monopolar military and economic superpower. Then the world will slip back into a multipolar superpower situation with China and perhaps India emerging as effective economic rivals and regional superpowers. Russia will remain a very well armed but economically hamstrung power unless it can build alliances and markets in Eurasia and drive a wedge between Europe and North America.

The USA's monopolar, superpower position today is primarily based on economic and military power formerly supported by a strong network of alliances and dependencies. The US economy is changing for the worse and that degradation will eventually undermine your out of control military spending and thus your military hegemony. The economic challenges facing the USA are dwindling productive capacity, surplus labour pools which will grow worse as AI mediated automation and globalisation of production displaces more and more workers. Also you are losing your innovation and engineering primacy to places like India, Israel, Europe and China so out innovating your rivals will soon no longer be a realistic option. Abuse of the US dominated international financial system for political purposes such as sanctioning rivals and restraining trade is causing other nations to develop rival international financial systems which will be more resistant to US interference, so your financial might is also beginning to wane while your rivals adapt and wax in strength and independence.

This all means that the US will face real crises of economy, debt, employment, political and societal unrest and political isolation soon and these crises will rapidly erode liberties, democracy and social peace in America. This is the real threat to Americans. Your government and the private sector are conducting unprecedented surveillance on you. You police are being militarised and mercenary/Private Military Companies are conducting surveillance and suppression programmes on American dissidents in America itself now, using methods perfected in the global war on terror. Your military is focusing on fighting in urban environments and mega-cities. Your governments are becoming less tolerant of dissent and more prone to using draconian measures in the pursuit of maintaining order, control and secrecy. The greatest threat to America short of a thermonuclear attack or a crippling cyber attack is a domestic one, not a foreign one. Your democracy is expertly managed kabuki theatre due to top-down democratic trends, Tweedism and gerrymandering. Your have already crept into an elite-controlled panopticon ruled by militarists, some remaining industrialists, powerful commercial interests, energy conglomerates, media and social-media conglomerates and extremely powerful private financial networks. 6.4 million Americans are already under some degree of penal supervision right now from incarceration to probation.

The next step will be an authoritarian police-state backed up by a significant fraction of a professional and permanent/standing military and a myriad of satellite private security, surveillance and mercenary companies which have been operating for the most part abroad but are now coming home to roost and are increasingly operating openly inside America. The superpower will turn its might inward before turning outward to regain lost hegemony abroad.

Cheers?
Evilroddy.
 
Last edited:
By century's end? It's more imminent than that. The process is unstoppable. Just a generation ago the world was agog at the US making diplomatic overtures to a bound-up insular China still trying to climb out of 'developing' status and today Trump is trying to negotiate a trade agreement with them. The American dominance that began after WW2 will be the shortest-lived hegemony in history.

I was thinking more in terms of America’s decline, than China’s rise per se. Third world immigration will turn our economy to **** by mid-century, but we’ll still have some residual international pull for a few decades thereafter.
 
I was thinking more in terms of America’s decline, than China’s rise per se. Third world immigration will turn our economy to **** by mid-century, but we’ll still have some residual international pull for a few decades thereafter.

Every generation, the same hate.
 
Unless something very drastic happens to alter the economic and military trajectories of the world's first tier powers, the USA has about another decade as an effective monopolar military and economic superpower. Then the world will slip back into a multipolar superpower situation with China and perhaps India emerging as effective economic rivals and regional superpowers. Russia will remain a very well armed but economically hamstrung power unless it can build alliances and markets in Eurasia and drive a wedge between Europe and North America.

The USA's monopolar, superpower position today is primarily based on economic and military power formerly supported by a strong network of alliances and dependencies. The US economy is changing for the worse and that degradation will eventually undermine your out of control military spending and thus your military hegemony. The economic challenges facing the USA are dwindling productive capacity, surplus labour pools which will grow worse as AI mediated automation and globalisation of production displaces more and more workers. Also you are losing your innovation and engineering primacy to places like India, Israel, Europe and China so out innovating your rivals will soon no longer be a realistic option. Abuse of the US dominated international financial system for political purposes such as sanctioning rivals and restraining trade is causing other nations to develop rival international financial systems which will be more resistant to US interference, so your financial might is also beginning to wane while your rivals adapt and wax in strength and independence.

This all means that the US will face real crises of economy, debt, employment and political isolation soon and these crises will rapidly erode liberties, democracy and social peace in America. This is the real threat to Americans. Your government and the private sector are conducting unprecedented surveillance on you. You police are being militarised and mercenary/Private Military Companies are conducting surveillance and suppression programmes on. American dissidents in America itself now. Your military is focusing on fighting in urban environments and mega-cities. Your Governments are becoming less tolerant of dissent and more prone to using draconian measures in the pursuit of maintaining control and secrecy. The greatest threat to America short of a thermonuclear attack or a crippling cyber attack is a domestic one, not a foreign one. Your have already crept into an elite-controlled panopticon ruled by militarists, some remaining industrialists, commercial interests, energy conglomerates, media and social-media conglomerates and extremely powerful private financial networks. 6.4 million Americans are already under some degree of penal supervision right now from incarceration to probation.

The next step will be an authoritarian police-state backed up by a significant fraction of a professional and permanent/standing military and a myriad of satellite private security, surveillance and mercenary companies which have been operating for the most part abroad but are now coming home to roost and are increasingly operating openly inside America.

Cheers?
Evilroddy.

India is unlikely to be a superpower. It is not spending enough on infrastructure and overall education to move up to a superpower level. It can and likely will be an upper level power, but will be beset by internal issues preventing it from getting to the top level. At least for the foreseeable future.

Potential Superpowers in 15 years

US, US will likely remain a superpower, and in 15 years still be the strongest of any, if only from legacy weapon systems that were built 20+ years ago (it will have 9+ nuclear powered supercarriers, and in 15 years, China might have 1 or two)

China, not a superpower at this point, but a very strong regional power. In 15 years, it should be at about 50% the strength of the US military in power projection. But it would be far more regionally focused, in that it is very unlikely to have military bases spread across the world, but along trade routes in Asia, and east Africa.

EU, with the UK leaving, the chances for a stronger union that has its own unified military is quite a bit higher. The economic, current military might a tighter EU would make them a superpower. Legacy systems would still mean a much weaker military than the US at the time when it comes to power projection. Not that it would need to project its power very far

Russia will not be a superpower, but due to its resources and nuclear weapons will remain a strong military power.

India will be around the same level as Russia at that point

So barring an economic crisis, in which the US has to retire much of the legacy weapon systems it currently has in 15 years it will still be the predominate military power in the world
 
There is no country ready to challenge US military power. We won't become a second rate power because of our military, but if we lose the edge in high tech, all bets are off. We will be beaten economically. China's stated goal and the goal of their 2025 Project is to dominate 90% of the world's high tech by 2025. To do so they will spy, hack, cheat, steal and/or buy that technology, which is at the core of the dispute between Trump and the Chinese. If the Chinese ever do dominate the world as the economic and military leader it will be a very different world. They will not be content to be simply a regional superpower. They are investing heavily in Africa, and the rest of the Third World. They do so to gain influence and access. They don't look at a harbor development project as simply a profit/loss equation, but at how that harbor can be of use to them militarily in the future. To those America haters hoping the US will fall, be careful what you wish for.
 
Last edited:
China for sure.

They're investing smarter in infrastructure and technology. And thanks to Trump, they're a more reliable trading partner than the U.S.
 
It takes several things to be a super power.
1. A strong economy
2. A large population
3. Strong allies
4. Enough natural resources to sustain you military should you be isolated from your sources
5. A commitment to have and maintain a strong military
6. A first rate education system
7. Enough food production to feed your nation

Only the United States has these.

Some mentioned Russia. Without nukes they would rank below Poland on the power range. They have no economy, a lousy education system, no allies, and no military budget.

Some mentioned China. They produce enough food to feed 25% of their population, they totally lack natural resources, their economy is almost totally dependent on trade with the US, they have no allies, and their education system at the higher levels is second rate.
 
Yes, Americans are being denied admissions into American universities on behalf of students from our economic and increasingly military adversaries - underwritten by the Federal Government.

If this were WW2, the new progressive-fascist Democratic Party would send all information, material and scientists about the atom bomb to Germany and Japan, stopping our own program.

Why do you support and promote a Marxist USA?
 
Back
Top Bottom