• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Can one be Jewish and be a White Nationalist?

Can a Jewish person be a White Nationalist?

  • Total voters
    23
JANFU

JANFU

Land by the Gulf Stream
Supporting Member
DP Veteran
Monthly Donator
Joined
Dec 27, 2014
Messages
59,415
Reaction score
38,983
Location
Best Coast Canada
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Slightly Liberal
Can a Jewish person be a White Nationalist?

Can a Jewish person be a White Nationalist?

Yes
No
No sure

White Nationalist | Definition of White Nationalist by Merriam-Webster

white nationalist noun
Definition of white nationalist

: one of a group of militant whites who espouse white supremacy and advocate enforced racial segregation
Click to expand...

Google search
white nationalist defnition - Google Search

https://www.washingtonpost.com/nati...emitism/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.2af6e563f0cd

A familiar story line played out Monday night for Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.), who condemned one of President Trump’s most trusted advisers, only to end up being accused of anti-Semitism.

“Stephen Miller is a white nationalist,” she tweeted Monday afternoon. “The fact that he still has influence on policy and political appointments is an outrage.” But because Miller, Trump’s senior policy adviser, is Jewish, Omar’s fervent detractors on the right viewed her comments not as incendiary criticism of Miller’s hard-line immigration policies but instead as part of a pattern of targeting Jews.

“During my time in Congress before @IlhanOmar got here, I didn’t once witness another Member target Jewish people like this with the name calling & other personal attacks,” Rep. Lee Zeldin (R-N.Y.), perhaps Omar’s most relentless critic, wrote on Twitter. “In 2019 though, for @IlhanOmar, this is just called Monday.”
Click to expand...
 
Last edited:
"Jewish" refers to one's religion or culture, not one's ethnicity.
 
Are Israelis white national jews?
 
I guess so. Though you may have difficulty getting any actual white nationalist organizations to accept you.
 
lwf said:
"Jewish" refers to one's religion or culture, not one's ethnicity.
Click to expand...
OK
Skeptic Bob said:
I guess so. Though you may have difficulty getting any actual white nationalist organizations to accept you.
Click to expand...

Me I am curious as to one it is like matter- anti matter.


Just some questions for anyone to reply to

We have that phrase that our culture is Judeo -Christian. Many spout that?

Those Jews that Christians and others have persecuted for over 2 millennia including extermination on an industrial scale, regardless of the costs
 
lwf said:
"Jewish" refers to one's religion or culture, not one's ethnicity.
Click to expand...

That's not correct. Jewish can be religion, culture, and ethnicity or just one of those things. There are Jews that are atheists.
 
Can a Jewish person be a White Nationalist?
Click to expand...

I suppose anything's possible; however, the character composition concurrency about which you inquire -- Jewish + white nationalist -- seems only possible existentially if the person in question minimally:
  1. Is ethnically Jewish (i.e., Sephardic, Ashkenazi, Ethiopian or Misrahi),
  2. Has a skin tone seen as white,
  3. Isn't known by other white nationalists as being ethnically Jewish,
  4. Rejects his/her ethnic Jewish heritage, and
  5. Does not practice Judaism.
If the person in question would have his/her white nationalism acknowledged by other white nationalists, s/he may have to meet other requirements such as submitting DNA testing results that verify his/her lack of Jewish or other non-white ancestry.

That said, I don't know what vetting process white nationalist group members undergo, but I presume that no matter what it is, it's more rigorous than that which one must undergo for Trump to appoint one to high public office.


2yd979.jpg
 
lwf said:
"Jewish" refers to one's religion or culture, not one's ethnicity.
Click to expand...

No, it also can refer to ethnicity. Many people with any Jewish ancestry no matter how slight declare themselves to be Jewish, although neither religious no part of any Jewish culture, just like people with almost no Native American claim to be Native American or little black ancestry claim to be black. President Obama claimed he is "black," when he is FAR more white than black, being 50% white by ancestry and 95% white by culture and upbringing.
 
lwf said:
"Jewish" refers to one's religion or culture, not one's ethnicity.
Click to expand...

Fishking said:
That's not correct. Jewish can be religion, culture, and ethnicity or just one of those things. There are Jews that are atheists.
Click to expand...

Correct. I have friends who are old enough to know better, and the whole Jewish religion/ethnicity thing still breaks their brains.
 
joko104 said:
No, it also can refer to ethnicity. Many people with any Jewish ancestry no matter how slight declare themselves to be Jewish, although neither religious no part of any Jewish culture, just like people with almost no Native American claim to be Native American or little black ancestry claim to be black. President Obama claimed he is "black," when he is FAR more white than black, being 50% white by ancestry and 95% white by culture and upbringing.
Click to expand...

I thought all the wing nuts claimed he's from Kenya. Plenty of "Christians" are agnostic, atheist or simply don't bother with any religious practices.
 
O “not sure...what you’re talking about”

Ever hear of Jews for Jesus?
 
joko104 said:
No, it also can refer to ethnicity. Many people with any Jewish ancestry no matter how slight declare themselves to be Jewish, although neither religious no part of any Jewish culture, just like people with almost no Native American claim to be Native American or little black ancestry claim to be black. President Obama claimed he is "black," when he is FAR more white than black, being 50% white by ancestry and 95% white by culture and upbringing.
Click to expand...


Red:

7mPF.gif


What's funny about the "red" statement has nothing to do with its factual accuracy (or inaccuracy). What's funny about it is your having cited that "corollary" example given the context of the thread. Plenty of ethnic Jews are, as you noted with your "blue" remark and absent DNA test results, visually indistinguishable from white non-Jews and can thus conceivably "pass" as white and thereby, should they ascribe to white nationalism and despite white nationalism's revulsion for Jews, be accepted by white nationalists.

The same cannot be said of folks who look like Obama and whose ancestry and acculturation may make them ostensibly more white than non-white. I mean, really. Who having brown skin will be seen as credible, to say nothing of accepted among white nationalists, should s/he attest to being a white nationalist? A white-skinned Jew can conceivably complete such subterfuge, but no brown-skinned person can....I know white nationalists are a "special kind of stupid," but even they aren't that stupid, and neither are the rest of us.
 
White Nationalism is a ridiculous concept that could only be born in a cultureless and soulless nation that lacks a proper ethnos, so it is hardly a surprise that the concept as such only exists in America. White Nationalism is an oxymoron because what constitutes a nation is not melanin, it is blood.

Although White Nationalists tend to be obsessed with their "Joo Boogiemann", I guess a Jew could self-identify as White Nationalist in the same sense some men identify as Feminists (self-hating beta-cuck mentality).

A Jewish-American could - however - be an (American) Nationalist without it being strange or contradictive.
 
Re: Can a Jewish person be a White Nationalist?

JANFU said:
Can a Jewish person be a White Nationalist?

Yes
No
No sure

White Nationalist | Definition of White Nationalist by Merriam-Webster



Google search
white nationalist defnition - Google Search

https://www.washingtonpost.com/nati...emitism/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.2af6e563f0cd
Click to expand...


I saw a black nazi on either jerry spring or maury popvich like a decade ago so lol :shrug:

regardless though it doesnt matter by defintion any white nationalist is a vile scumbag and IMO the world is better without.
 
Re: Can a Jewish person be a White Nationalist?

It might get a bit awkward for the Jewish person at White Nationalist gatherings but sure, why not a White Nationalist?
 
Re: Can a Jewish person be a White Nationalist?

LouC said:
It might get a bit awkward for the Jewish person at White Nationalist gatherings but sure, why not a White Nationalist?
Click to expand...
White Nationalism is laughably r-tarded and rather Leftist as they apply the "Workers of the World, unite!"-rhetoric onto skin tone. Ethnicity is a socio-biological category; something constructed in a set place throughout a longer period of history-making and social interaction. It has never been about skin tone. In fact, massive nations is a fairly new concept to humans. Man has a natural attraction to regionalism and this can be seen in many places throughout the world still today - Try telling the Basque to just accept Spanish rule "because after all, you are both White!" or try telling a Lithuanian to bow down for Russia and dance with them in the moonlight "because after all, they are both White!"

Makes about as much sense as a Jew being a "Middle Eastern Nationalist" advocating the Israelis to get along with the people who want them dead because "Hey! We are all Middle Eastern!"

Garbage ideology.
 
Re: Can a Jewish person be a White Nationalist?

Dacke said:
White Nationalism is laughably r-tarded and rather Leftist as they apply the "Workers of the World, unite!"-rhetoric onto skin tone. Ethnicity is a socio-biological category; something constructed in a set place throughout a longer period of history-making and social interaction. It has never been about skin tone. In fact, massive nations is a fairly new concept to humans. Man has a natural attraction to regionalism and this can be seen in many places throughout the world still today - Try telling the Basque to just accept Spanish rule "because after all, you are both White!" or try telling a Lithuanian to bow down for Russia and dance with them in the moonlight "because after all, they are both White!"

Makes about as much sense as a Jew being a "Middle Eastern Nationalist" advocating the Israelis to get along with the people who want them dead because "Hey! We are all Middle Eastern!"

Garbage ideology.
Click to expand...

Thanks.

If I am ever in the market for a new ideology I will definitely avoid that garbage one!

:2wave:
 
Re: Can a Jewish person be a White Nationalist?

JANFU said:
Can a Jewish person be a White Nationalist?

Yes
No
No sure
Click to expand...

Since a white nationalist is more inline with being a Nazi or a member of the Ayran nation I can't image a Jew being a Nazi or white Nationalist any more than a non black being a member or the New Black Panthers.
 
Re: Can a Jewish person be a White Nationalist?

LouC said:
It might get a bit awkward for the Jewish person at White Nationalist gatherings but sure, why not a White Nationalist?
Click to expand...

I would awkward for a hooded Jewish person with a star of David around his neck at KKK meeting and taking off the hood for drinks at the local watering hole after the meeting....
 
Re: Can a Jewish person be a White Nationalist?

antiquity said:
I would awkward for a hooded Jewish person with a star of David around his neck at KKK meeting and taking off the hood for drinks at the local watering hole after the meeting....
Click to expand...

Awkward, but talk about Chutzpah!

:lamo
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom