• Please read the Announcement concerning missing posts from 10/8/25-10/15/25.
  • This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Was Albert Einstein Racist? A hypocrite?

Was Albert Einstein Racist? A hypocrite?

  • Yes, Einstein was a hypocrite on racism

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    33

truthatallcost

DP Veteran
Joined
Aug 1, 2014
Messages
26,719
Reaction score
6,278
Location
California
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Other
In 1946, speaking at Lincoln University, the first degree-granting historically black university in the U.S., Einstein said that racism was a "disease of white people" and added “I do not intend to be quiet about it," according to a 2007 article in the Harvard Gazette.

But Albert Einstein's newly translated private travel diaries from the 1920s reveal that he was racist in his early life, especially towards Chinese people.

The diaries were written between October 1922 and March 1923. In one entry Einstein wrote that the “Chinese don’t sit on benches while eating but squat like Europeans do when they relieve themselves out in the leafy woods. All this occurs quietly and demurely. Even the children are spiritless and look obtuse.”

Speaking about the “abundance of offspring” and the “fecundity” of the Chinese, he continued: “It would be a pity if these Chinese supplant all other races. For the likes of us the mere thought is unspeakably dreary.”

Einstein also derided the people of Ceylon, which is now known as Sri Lanka. In Ceylon, he wrote, the locals “live in great filth and considerable stench at ground level,” before adding they “do little, and need little. The simple economic cycle of life.”

Einstein also gave his thoughts on Japanese people, who he viewed in a more positive light, calling them "unostentatious, decent, altogether very appealing.” However, he also wrote the “intellectual needs of this nation seem to be weaker than their artistic ones – natural disposition?”

Einstein's diaries contain shocking details of his racism | Fox News

Given the fact that Einstein worked to craft the public image of a humanitarian that abhorred racism, it's interesting to know his true feelings that he held privately. Einstein's comments about racism being " the disease of white people" seems to contradict his beliefs that the Japanese were natually mentally unambitious, and Sri Lankans were content to live in filth. What's your opinion: Was Albert Einstein Racist? A hypocrite?
 
When he was young he suffered from that disease which later in life he so firmly opposed.
 
People in the 1920's had an excuse for racism. Products of the time. Something to strive to overcome, as Einstein strived.

Nearly 100 years later, we have people who are trying to take us back to those times. Those people will gladly welcome the notion of Einstein being racist as they attempt to deflect the critical spotlight from their abhorrent goals.
 
It isn’t hypocritical to hold a different set of views in old age than you did when you were young. In fact, if you don’t change your mind on some thing in all that time then you have probably lived a fairly sheltered and boring life.
 
When he was young he suffered from that disease which later in life he so firmly opposed.

But those are your words, not his. Did Einstein confess to being racist in his youth, and then overcoming it? If not, then I'm inclined to think he chose to craft his public persona in a manner that was contrary to his own diary, which he didn't intend the public to ever read.
 
Last edited:
Given the fact that Einstein worked to craft the public image of a humanitarian that abhorred racism, it's interesting to know his true feelings that he held privately. Einstein's comments about racism being " the disease of white people" seems to contradict his beliefs that the Japanese were natually mentally unambitious, and Sri Lankans were content to live in filth. What's your opinion: Was Albert Einstein Racist? A hypocrite?

SO changing your beliefs based on further information and experience is hypocrisy now? Do you know how to use a ****ing dictionary?
 
SO changing your beliefs based on further information and experience is hypocrisy now? Do you know how to use a ****ing dictionary?

Prove that he changed his beliefs, and wasn't merely stating things in public about himself that weren't true in private, as so many celebrities have done before.
 
Given the fact that Einstein worked to craft the public image of a humanitarian that abhorred racism, it's interesting to know his true feelings that he held privately. Einstein's comments about racism being " the disease of white people" seems to contradict his beliefs that the Japanese were natually mentally unambitious, and Sri Lankans were content to live in filth. What's your opinion: Was Albert Einstein Racist? A hypocrite?

Those diary entries came before the Holocaust, during six months between 1922-1923. Having experienced racism when the nazis came to power, he changed and spoke out against racism and advocated for minorities where he found the chance:

From a link in your own link:

In 1946, the Nobel Prize-winning physicist traveled to Lincoln University in Pennsylvania, the alma mater of Langston Hughes and Thurgood Marshall and the first school in America to grant college degrees to blacks. At Lincoln, Einstein gave a speech in which he called racism “a disease of white people,” and added, “I do not intend to be quiet about it.” He also received an honorary degree and gave a lecture on relativity to Lincoln students.

The reason Einstein’s visit to Lincoln is not better known is that it was virtually ignored by the mainstream press, which regularly covered Einstein’s speeches and activities. (Only the black press gave extensive coverage to the event.) Nor is there mention of the Lincoln visit in any of the major Einstein biographies or archives.
-snip-
According to Jerome and Taylor, Einstein’s statements at Lincoln were by no means an isolated case. Einstein, who was Jewish, was sensitized to racism by the years of Nazi-inspired threats and harassment he suffered during his tenure at the University of Berlin. Einstein was in the United States when the Nazis came to power in 1933, and, fearful that a return to Germany would place him in mortal danger, he decided to stay, accepting a position at the recently founded Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, N.J. He became an American citizen in 1940.

“Einstein realized that African Americans in Princeton were treated like Jews in Germany,” said Taylor. “The town was strictly segregated. There was no high school that blacks could go to until the 1940s.”

https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2007/04/albert-einstein-civil-rights-activist/

Read the entire article, there is much more. His hard experience taught him to reject racism to be a better person.

Since your poll options are dishonest in view of that information, I vote he was once a racist and became a better person, not a hypocrite.
 
The Chinese back then were mostly coolies in the 1920s and Einstein probably had never met educated or wealthy Chinese individuals in his entire life. On the contrary, Einstein had more positive perceptions of the Japanese he met, who were "unostentatious, decent, altogether very appealing", and he admired the country.

The publication of Albert Einstein’s private diaries detailing his tour of Asia in the 1920s reveals the theoretical physicist and humanitarian icon’s racist attitudes to the people he met on his travels, particularly the Chinese.

Einstein’s perceptions of the Japanese he meets are, in contrast, more positive: “Japanese unostentatious, decent, altogether very appealing,” he writes. “Pure souls as nowhere else among people. One has to love and admire this country.” But Rosenkranz points out that he also concludes that the “intellectual needs of this nation seem to be weaker than their artistic ones – natural disposition?”

https://www.theguardian.com/books/2018/jun/12/einsteins-travel-diaries-reveal-shocking-xenophobia
 
Those diary entries came before the Holocaust, during six months between 1922-1923. Having experienced racism when the nazis came to power, he changed and spoke out against racism and advocated for minorities where he found the chance:

From a link in your own link:



https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2007/04/albert-einstein-civil-rights-activist/

Read the entire article, there is much more. His hard experience taught him to reject racism to be a better person.

Since your poll options are dishonest in view of that information, I vote he was once a racist and became a better person, not a hypocrite.

That's fine, but since his anti-Asian stance comes from his own writings, and not the writings of academics who are attempting to soften the severity of Einstein's racism, I'd like to read Einstein's account of his transformation, in his own words.

My poll options are dishonest? I don't believe so. Einstein called racism "a disease of white people", which is such a strong denunciation of both racism and white people at the same time, that's its highly shocking to learn Einstein was a racist.
 
I could not care less if moderns decide that this guy did not live by their rules on this artificial construct called race, he was plenty within the bounds of what was acceptable for his time.
 
That's fine, but since his anti-Asian stance comes from his own writings, and not the writings of academics who are attempting to soften the severity of Einstein's racism, I'd like to read Einstein's account of his transformation, in his own words.

My poll options are dishonest? I don't believe so. Einstein called racism "a disease of white people", which is such a strong denunciation of both racism and white people at the same time, that's its highly shocking to learn Einstein was a racist.

His own actions later in his life are demonstrable. Read the article.

Here are some quotes and they were not hard to find:

Being a Jew myself, perhaps I can understand and empathize with how black people feel as victims of discrimination,” he said in an interview with family friend Peter Bucky.

Einstein took the opportunity to applaud civil rights efforts, but also to encourage African-Americans not to let racists drag down their self-worth. “This ... more important aspect of the evil can be met through closer union and conscious educational enlightenment among the minority,” he wrote, “and so emancipation of the soul of the minority can be attained.”

“There is separation of colored people from white people in the United States,” said the renowned physicist, using the common term in the day. “That separation is not a disease of colored people. It is a disease of white people. I do not intend to be quiet about it.”

“It must be pointed out time and again that the exclusion of a large part of the colored population from active civil rights by the common practices is a slap in the face of the Constitution of the nation,” he said in the address.

For his anti-racist activism, he was placed under FBI surveillance by J. Edgar Hoover. While Hoover’s FBI refused to investigate the Ku Klux Klan and other white terrorist organizations, there wasn’t a civil rights group or leader they didn’t target. By the time of his death, the FBI had amassed 1,427 pages of documents on Einstein, without ever demonstrating criminal wrongdoing on his part.
From the Smithsonian: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/scie...used-fame-denounce-american-racism-180962356/

There are attributions in the article which I did not include due to Fair Use. He also joined the NAACP, was great friend with Paul Robeson and W.E.B. Du Bois. I know it doesn't matter what I provide, you're going to demure to "historians softening his image". For the rest of us, the Smithsonian has weighed in by publishing the article on their website.

Yes, your options do not allow for the accurate depiction of the man and his change of heart after the nazis began persecuting Jews. If that evil didn't cause a person to change, they are truly, morally lost. So kudos to Mr. Einstein. As the information I provided supports, he was a racist who became a better person. Not a hypocrite. Calling racism a disease of white people, is not racist. Some white people are racist. Not all and calling it a disease is not precise. It's a learned behavior, that spreads like a disease.
 
Last edited:
Having lived in Japan for several years I find it ironic that Einstein, who must have had many contacts with Japanese in order to form his opinion of them, should then restrict his definition of racism as a disease of white people. The Japanese are a very racist people in general. Just ask any Koreans. They had the same status as Blacks once did here. And it is very difficult, even today, to gain Japanese citizenship for any foreigner. I was a Gaijin, not exactly a compliment.

And as smart as Einstein was, how could he have not noticed that lots of "people" don't like other people; even consider them less than human. Ask an Armenian how the Turks feel about them. Or ask Kurds, who are not Arabs, how Arabs treat them.

This list could go on and on. This world has been a hotbed of racism. It's not restricted to whites. Einstein knew better. He was speaking at a black college; I think he shrewdly offered up a comment on race he knew would play well with that audience.
 
Speaking your truth is not racism.

That is untrue, completely and utterly untrue. That is as ridiculous as saying that Hitler was not anti-semitic because he was speaking his truth. And that Mengele was not a monster because his truth was that he was just doing some medical experiments. Total and utterly untrue.
 
Given the fact that Einstein worked to craft the public image of a humanitarian that abhorred racism, it's interesting to know his true feelings that he held privately. Einstein's comments about racism being " the disease of white people" seems to contradict his beliefs that the Japanese were natually mentally unambitious, and Sri Lankans were content to live in filth. What's your opinion: Was Albert Einstein Racist? A hypocrite?
Possible.

But most the people we were taught to revere turn out to be hypocrites in some way, I think everyone may be.

Doesn't make their good accomplishments any less good, IMO.
 
Einstein may have been racist in his younger years, but grew out of it later in life, even beginning to despise it. Quite vocally, at that.

It's not hypocritical to change your mind on matters as you grow older. You're exposed to new ideas and become less ignorant about the world. Hopefully. And with those new ideas comes a better understanding of things you were once ignorant on. This is how people grow up to become mature human beings.

EDIT: I meant to write the name of the revolutionary scientist, not the anti-semetic painter.
 
Last edited:
Hitler may had been racist in his younger years, but grew out of it later in life, even beginning to despise it. Quite vocally, at that.

It's not hypocritical to change your mind on matters as you grow older. You're exposed to new ideas and are become ignorant about the world. Hopefully. And with those new ideas comes a better understanding of things you were once ignorant on. This is how people grow up to become mature human beings.


Hitler?
 
Having lived in Japan for several years I find it ironic that Einstein, who must have had many contacts with Japanese in order to form his opinion of them, should then restrict his definition of racism as a disease of white people. The Japanese are a very racist people in general. Just ask any Koreans. They had the same status as Blacks once did here. And it is very difficult, even today, to gain Japanese citizenship for any foreigner. I was a Gaijin, not exactly a compliment.

And as smart as Einstein was, how could he have not noticed that lots of "people" don't like other people; even consider them less than human. Ask an Armenian how the Turks feel about them. Or ask Kurds, who are not Arabs, how Arabs treat them.

This list could go on and on. This world has been a hotbed of racism. It's not restricted to whites. Einstein knew better. He was speaking at a black college; I think he shrewdly offered up a comment on race he knew would play well with that audience.

Well, I may like the Japanese culture in general, I am not impressed with the work culture, it really is poor and not constructive. And the managers they sent to Europe are usually idiots LOL.

And yes, Japanese are difficult and enormously xenophobic and racist.

And Einstein changed when he grew older and wiser. And when he spoke those words at a black school, seeing all the racism around him, it is highly understandable why he said what he did at that school.
 
Prove that he changed his beliefs, and wasn't merely stating things in public about himself that weren't true in private, as so many celebrities have done before.

It was perfectly acceptable by society at large back then to hold racist views. There was no net good will to be earned by him faking his position against racism. Sure, a person renouncing racism today could solely be motivated by the desire to earn good will but that reasoning wouldn’t make sense back then.
 
Having lived in Japan for several years I find it ironic that Einstein, who must have had many contacts with Japanese in order to form his opinion of them, should then restrict his definition of racism as a disease of white people. The Japanese are a very racist people in general. Just ask any Koreans. They had the same status as Blacks once did here. And it is very difficult, even today, to gain Japanese citizenship for any foreigner. I was a Gaijin, not exactly a compliment.

And as smart as Einstein was, how could he have not noticed that lots of "people" don't like other people; even consider them less than human. Ask an Armenian how the Turks feel about them. Or ask Kurds, who are not Arabs, how Arabs treat them.

This list could go on and on. This world has been a hotbed of racism. It's not restricted to whites. Einstein knew better. He was speaking at a black college; I think he shrewdly offered up a comment on race he knew would play well with that audience.

The Japanese are not racist, they are more nationalist. They don't so much care about the race as the country, with other countries being inferior. And even that is a broad generalization of a spectrum of views.
 
Well, I may like the Japanese culture in general, I am not impressed with the work culture, it really is poor and not constructive. And the managers they sent to Europe are usually idiots LOL.

And yes, Japanese are difficult and enormously xenophobic and racist.

And Einstein changed when he grew older and wiser. And when he spoke those words at a black school, seeing all the racism around him, it is highly understandable why he said what he did at that school.

I agree regarding the Japanese, but Einstein, smart as he was, knew better. He had to have seen racism in other parts of the world. He was being disingenuous.
 
Back
Top Bottom