• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Nazi or Antifa as neighbor... [W:236]

Who would you rather have as a neighbor?

  • Total voters
    78
  • Poll closed .
OlNate said:
Alright, so we've seen polls today on whether or not we support Nazis or Antifa, as two separate polls, which makes things very easy to answer - clearly, since violence is involved, very few are going to say they support either.

However, if forced to pick between a Nazi neighbor, highly involved in Nazi activism, or an Antifa neighbor, highly involved in Antifa activism, which one would you have, and why, if you like. :)

I went with the Antifa... A) they're not Nazis, B) they are against fascism, and C) since they engage primarily in counter demonstrations, chances are it's not going to go down on my street, and if it does, they are protecting me from a Nazi invasion.

How about you guys?

{...poll incoming...}
Click to expand...

I'd rather have a Nazi for a neighbor, even though they are essentially the same. There are only a handful of Nazis and everybody hates them. I could scrape together enough ammo to keep them out of my house if I needed to. Antifa, on the other hand, are a much larger and more dangerous group. Those assholes would call me a Nazi and vandalize my property. We wouldn't be able to be neighbors.
 
Moderate Right said:
So, those who are against government, against the police, and are for pursuing their agenda through violence, aren't deplorables?
Click to expand...

What about those that don't pursue that agenda through violence but, through privileged access to the state?
 
Moderate Right said:
What the hell is privileged access to the state?
Click to expand...
For example, when was the last time you had a personal meeting with your representative or head of state?

For example, how good would your legal representation be in comparison if you were charged with the same crime as Bill Gates? Assuming that a case even made it to court in the case of Bill Gates.
 
Last edited:
William Rea said:
For example, when was the last time you had a personal meeting with your representative or head of state?

For example, how good would your legal representation be in comparison if you were charged with the same crime as Bill Gates? Assuming that a case even made it to court in the case of Bill Gates.
Click to expand...

I must confess to having a hard time debating with socialists because their brains are wired so differently they just don't make any sense. The right is the right. The left is the left and the middle is the middle and I pretty much understand their thinking, even when I disagree with it. But, socialists are on a planet all to themselves. It is like debating Mork from Ork.
 
Moderate Right said:
I must confess to having a hard time debating with socialists because their brains are wired so differently they just don't make any sense. The right is the right. The left is the left and the middle is the middle and I pretty much understand their thinking, even when I disagree with it. But, socialists are on a planet all to themselves. It is like debating Mork from Ork.
Click to expand...

Personally, I think you see my lean and nothing else and it's your problem if you can't get over that. Your post indicates that you clearly can't get over it but, that's fine because, I treat my lean as a filter for that kind of thing.

If you really cannot perceive that your access to the state is not equivalent to that of someone like Bill Gates for example, then I cannot help you.
 
OlNate said:
Alright, so we've seen polls today on whether or not we support Nazis or Antifa, as two separate polls, which makes things very easy to answer - clearly, since violence is involved, very few are going to say they support either.

However, if forced to pick between a Nazi neighbor, highly involved in Nazi activism, or an Antifa neighbor, highly involved in Antifa activism, which one would you have, and why, if you like. :)

I went with the Antifa... A) they're not Nazis, B) they are against fascism, and C) since they engage primarily in counter demonstrations, chances are it's not going to go down on my street, and if it does, they are protecting me from a Nazi invasion.

How about you guys?

{...poll incoming...}
Click to expand...


The only substantive difference between Hitler and Stalin was: Hitler chose his victims by race and religion and Stalin chose his victims by political ideology.

That is also the only difference between the White Supremacists and the Group of Fascist calling themselves Anti-Fa.
 
William Rea said:
Personally, I think you see my lean and nothing else and it's your problem if you can't get over that. Your post indicates that you clearly can't get over it but, that's fine because, I treat my lean as a filter for that kind of thing.

If you really cannot perceive that your access to the state is not equivalent to that of someone like Bill Gates for example, then I cannot help you.
Click to expand...

I do understand that you think a druggie homeless bum on the street is equivalent to Bill Gates but that is not reality and never will be. The socialistic societies that have existed on Earth have all been pretty much the same - 99.9% of the citizens are more or less equal while a select handful have everything. I also know that you think that that is the way it is in the US but it is not. We have many classes of people in all shapes, sizes, and income levels - the way it is supposed to be. Many people have money in the US, not just the .1% and not just the 1%. Socialism does not work and it has been proven over and over and over again. You have been reduced to nothing more than a person with wishful thinking, along with all of the other socialists.
 
Moderate Right said:
I do understand that you think a druggie homeless bum on the street is equivalent to Bill Gates but that is not reality and never will be. The socialistic societies that have existed on Earth have all been pretty much the same - 99.9% of the citizens are more or less equal while a select handful have everything. I also know that you think that that is the way it is in the US but it is not. We have many classes of people in all shapes, sizes, and income levels - the way it is supposed to be. Many people have money in the US, not just the .1% and not just the 1%. Socialism does not work and it has been proven over and over and over again. You have been reduced to nothing more than a person with wishful thinking, along with all of the other socialists.
Click to expand...
I thought we were talking about Antifa but, all you want to do is attack Socialism so, just forget it and go hack with someone else. Not interested.
 
What a horrid choice. I don't think there is any difference. If Antifa were to come into power, they would behave exactly like the Nazi's. Both would be mass murderers, both are racists. And if you don't think either would turn you over to the 'authorities' if you miss-stepped you're fooling yourself. Antifa to me are fascists communists. They have no idea what they are protesting. The seem to be type to have messy houses with overgrown grass and broken windows because someone else should take care of their house. On the other hand Nazi's are more disciplined and would take care of their property. But they have no compassion. If I HAD to choose I'd rather have a Nazi next door. At least I wouldn't have worry about rats inside my house, just outside.
 
If one just takes a look at antifa attacking Asian guys because they are right wing, it's easy to see that these people whom gladly enjoy in thier ranks people flying stalin's hammer and sickle, that, you would ultimately be no better if they ever got the power, than the nazis.
 
Re: Nazi or Antifa as neighbor...

Get one of each and make them fight.
 
Re: Nazi or Antifa as neighbor...

I would have to pick Nazi because they would probably spend most of their time watching the History Channel (AKA the Hitler Channel), while the Antifa might not like the kind of car I drive and would flip it over and set it on fire...
 
Re: Nazi or Antifa as neighbor...

Neither. They're both racists and crazy.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom