• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Prostitution

Should prostitution be legalized?


  • Total voters
    117
My notion that I got from the State department, and others...

Your notion is based off of a fallacy. You are using opinions that are not from experts on the subject. You literally sourced a site that lists both opinions for and against prostitution and then selected the against arguments as if that some how created an airtight rebuttal. Then you make an appeal to government statements despite that fact that governments are not infallible moral sources.

The hyperbole and fallacy come from you.

Nope. Not at all.
 
I'm sorry, did you provide some sort of evidence that the State Department is lying about this?

No?


Yes I did. I gave you a statistic of crime rates. They directly contradict the claim made.
 
No, it's a human rights violation by its very nature. You are purchasing and selling women's bodies.

The polite thing to do when replying to my post is to quote me so that I can go see your response. Not doing so is like whispering a rebuttal and then saying "see he has no response!". Of course your sexism is also showing with this statement in that you refuse to equate prostitution with men. Why don't you dismiss men being raped (by women no less) while you're at it?

"The redefinition of prostitution as 'commercial sex work' is just an attempt to legitimize sex trafficking. It should come as no surprise the ACLU and Planned Parenthood have signed on. While both groups are considered 'pro-woman', it is odd that they support an industry of flagrant abuse of women...

<snip>

Zin pretty much said all I was going to say so I'll not bother to repeat.

As our own State Department says:

"Where prostitution is legalized or tolerated, there is a greater demand for human trafficking victims and nearly always an increase in the number of women and children trafficked into commercial sex slavery..."

Citation on that? Otherwise I have to guess you made up a quote. I mean if you claimed to have paraphrased something you think you remembered reading I'd give you some credit, but you went with a actual quote.
 
So then it's your opinion again...not based on it being legal? You keep bouncing back and forth.

And apparently keep imagining more and more about what 'may go on.' It's a similar thing I've found in the SSM threads...all their thoughts and focus is on a sex act and not the actual people. Makes you wonder where their thoughts are when they look anywhere....sexualizing everything?

And then that's what they 'believe' everyone else is thinking too.....no wonder they seem to see perverts and deviants everywhere!

Is prostitution legal. No, so your what if and hyperbole hold no water.
 
Andrea Dworkin, an author, activist, and former prostitute, stated in her Oct. 31, 1992 speech at the University of Michigan Law School:

"I ask you to think about your own bodies--if you can do so outside the world that the pornographers have created in your minds, the flat, dead, floating mouths and vaginas and anuses of women. I ask you to think concretely about your own bodies used that way. How sexy is it? Is it fun? The people who defend prostitution and pornography want you to feel a kinky little thrill every time you think of something being stuck in a woman. I want you to feel the delicate tissues in her body that are being misused. I want you to feel what it feels like when it happens over and over and over and over and over and over and over again: because that is what prostitution is.

"...And so, many of us are saying that prostitution is intrinsically abusive. Let me be clear. I am talking to you about prostitution per se, without more violence, without extra violence, without a woman being hit, without a woman being pushed. Prostitution in and of itself is an abuse of a woman's body. Those of us who say this are accused of being simple-minded. But prostitution is very simple. And if you are not simple-minded, you will never understand it. The more complex you manage to be, the further away from the reality you will be--the safer you will be, the happier you will be, the more fun you will have discussing the issue of prostitution. In prostitution, no woman stays whole."

Wow one prostitute? she must represent every last one of them... oh wait...

Not All Prostitutes Are Victims: #NotYourRescueProject

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/kitty-stryker/some-people-enjoy-being-prostitutes_b_1405004.html

I am a prostitute working in a legal brothel in Australia. AM(or my partner)A (NSFW!) : IAmA
 
Andrea Dworkin, an author, activist, and former prostitute, stated in her Oct. 31, 1992 speech at the University of Michigan Law School:

"I ask you to think about your own bodies--if you can do so outside the world that the pornographers have created in your minds, the flat, dead, floating mouths and vaginas and anuses of women. I ask you to think concretely about your own bodies used that way. How sexy is it? Is it fun? The people who defend prostitution and pornography want you to feel a kinky little thrill every time you think of something being stuck in a woman. I want you to feel the delicate tissues in her body that are being misused. I want you to feel what it feels like when it happens over and over and over and over and over and over and over again: because that is what prostitution is.

"...And so, many of us are saying that prostitution is intrinsically abusive. Let me be clear. I am talking to you about prostitution per se, without more violence, without extra violence, without a woman being hit, without a woman being pushed. Prostitution in and of itself is an abuse of a woman's body. Those of us who say this are accused of being simple-minded. But prostitution is very simple. And if you are not simple-minded, you will never understand it. The more complex you manage to be, the further away from the reality you will be--the safer you will be, the happier you will be, the more fun you will have discussing the issue of prostitution. In prostitution, no woman stays whole."

Again no citation that would allow verification. Additionally this still is all her opinion. I will grant that she might well have a more personal insight on it that those who have not prostituted, but there are those who do so because they enjoy it and enjoy the money they make on the side. The bold? When one doesn't get paid then it's just being promiscuous. I don't see abuse being associated with them because of it "...happen(ing) over and over and over and over and over and over and over again..." So once again a fallacy has been brought into play by you.

Well, it aint legal now is it.

True, but we're not discussing now, we're discussing if it becomes legal. Mind you that is the basis of this sub line not the thread entirely. It started with the false concept that if prostitution were to be made legal that somehow there would suddenly be hookers on the corners of "good neighborhoods".
 
Gambling is legal in many parts of Florida, but I dont want you rolling craps on the side of my house.

Well for it to be on the side of your house then there would be a trespassing violation and the legality of the action otherwise is irrelevant. Your parallel fails. Please try again.
 
Meh. You are laboring under the sordid and dirty practice of the illegal sex trade of yesterday. No one is suggesting a continuation of status quo with legalization. You are warped by stigma. You cant or wont see what a legal prostitution business could be.

Try again. I have zero stigma towards prostitution. I couldn't care less how consenting adults choose to define the nature of their relationship - money for sex or otherwise.
 
My notion that I got from the State department, and others...

The hyperbole and fallacy come from you.

Isn't that the same government that in other threads you claim is entirely incompetent? And yet, you're going to argue with someone who says the numbers are not accurate? Perhaps I'm mistaking you for a different poster and you trust the government.
 
Well for it to be on the side of your house then there would be a trespassing violation and the legality of the action otherwise is irrelevant. Your parallel fails. Please try again.

Because, again, hookers are known for keeping off the sides of homes and buildings while doing business. You try again. You want it in your neighborhood? Good for you. We dont.
 
Pushing a Pro Prostitution agenda, clearly a liberal concept. Yet the Conservatives are waging a war on women. Go figure.
 
Pushing a Pro Prostitution agenda, clearly a liberal concept. Yet the Conservatives are waging a war on women. Go figure.

What in the actual hell are you yammering about now?
 
Because, again, hookers are known for keeping off the sides of homes and buildings while doing business. You try again. You want it in your neighborhood? Good for you. We dont.

Again false comparison. You are trying to compare the behavior of prostitutes under a prohibition system verses one where it is permitted. Do you have any hookers against your house right now? So why would they suddenly start because prostitution was legal? Are prostitutes leaning against houses against the building owner's wishes a problem in countries where it is legal?
 
Pushing a Pro Prostitution agenda, clearly a liberal concept. Yet the Conservatives are waging a war on women. Go figure.

You think only women sell their bodies?
 
Over your head? People are pushing legalizing hooking, done predominately by women. Pushed by predominately by liberals.

Legalizing prostitution would lessen the victimization of prostitution.
 
Try again. I have zero stigma towards prostitution. I couldn't care less how consenting adults choose to define the nature of their relationship - money for sex or otherwise.
Then you CAN see where legalized prostitution can actually be a positve thing? My bad. I didnt get that from your comments.
 
Should prostitution be legalized?

No, because it legitimizes it and makes it a possible legitimate way for young women think they have to make a living. I understand why legalizing it would be of benefit, but I think the bad effects outweigh the good.

I believe that it demoralizes a woman to sell her body, and the effects are permanent. So although legalizing it would help protect women who are prostitutes, it would encourage more young women to do that instead of, say, waittressing or whatever.

I think the French had it right in the old days, with the use of courtesans, and the Japanese had it right with geishas. Although they were prostitutes, it was a one-on-one relationship where the woman was regarded as a person, rather than just a body for sale. She could live all her young life on the payments and gifts and houses. Her future was protected. And although not considered ladies like non-prostitutes, there was a certain regard for these women in their societies. That is not the case with American prostitutes.
 
Should prostitution be legalized?

I think if one truly believes a woman has control over her body and that no one should be able to tell her what to do with her body, of course it should be legal. *
 
Then you CAN see where legalized prostitution can actually be a positve thing? My bad. I didnt get that from your comments.

Yep. And I am also aware of the potential negatives.
 
Yep. And I am also aware of the potential negatives.
So...it would be like any business then. Except with a lot less criminal activity..
 
Anyone who works a job is a prostitute.
 
Gambling is legal in many parts of Florida, but I dont want you rolling craps on the side of my house.

There's lots of things I dont want on my property or on my street.....what's your point? Are you living in America?

We're talking about legalizing prostitution and you are dreaming up more stuff you dont like. Seems like a personal problem to me.
 
Victims are the bread and butter of the prostitution business.

Please share how pro-female you are again, as you fight hard to draft more and more into prostitution and abortion clinics...

Still not real clear on choice, free will, & personal liberty huh?
 
Back
Top Bottom