• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Should the USA adopt the International System of Units (SI)?

Should the USA adopt the International System of Units (SI)?


  • Total voters
    63
Yeah, I think we should switch. The SI system makes so much more sense.

I doubt that we will though, because imperial units are what everyone is used to. It's the same reason we still use Qwerty keyboards when there are much better types available.
 
We should also do d/m/y instead of m/d/y
 
Our firearms (ammo) come in metric.

Actually ammo calibers come in a mix of metric and imperial, depending on when and where the round was invented. Yes, we have 9mm and 10mm, but we also have .380 auto, .40 S&W, .45 ACP, etc.
 
We should also do d/m/y instead of m/d/y

No we shouldn't. That's actually the least useful way of organizing a date. Yes, the increments are in order from smallest to largest, but that's the only thing it's got going for it.

The m/d/y system we currently use is quicker and easier to say. 'July twenty-second twenty-thirteen' is quicker than 'the twenty-second of july twenty-thirteen'. The second version has a couple extra words stuck in there.

If we want to be more logical, it makes far more sense to write dates y/m/d, since that way, the numbers that make up the date will always increment.
 
Actually ammo calibers come in a mix of metric and imperial, depending on when and where the round was invented. Yes, we have 9mm and 10mm, but we also have .380 auto, .40 S&W, .45 ACP, etc.

You're right. The point was mostly that there are a wide range of industries which use metric.
 
There doesn't appear to be a reason to adopt either of them outright. Just use whichever one works best for the situation. :shrug:
 
No we shouldn't.
The m/d/y system we currently use is quicker and easier to say. 'July twenty-second twenty-thirteen' is quicker than 'the twenty-second of july twenty-thirteen'.

Actually, we tend to just say 22 July.
 
Yeah, but when you say "I'm driving with 80 mph" or "I'm 6.5 feet high", I have to scratch my head and go looking for a converter.
See how easy it is with units like watts and minutes? We both know what that is. Why can't it be like that for all units?
Besides, decimal system is much easier than dozens and such. ;)

There's the problem. A sudden conversion would mean that everyone in the US would have to do the thing you are complaining about all the time when they do everyday things, such as drive or weigh themselves.

A sudden and complete conversion will never happen. It's possible to phase it in, but that starts by making imperial to metric conversions a staple of a grade school education (not sure if it's there or not, but it wasn't when I went to school).

I'm often surprised that people here don't know how to convert Imperial to metric and vice versa. It's surprising because you easily can figure out the ratios on your own, provided you know anything about the two scales (and all you have to do is look around a little bit in order to find out those things). With Kilometers and Miles, they can just look at their car's dashboard, it has both the km/h and m/h numbers on it in the US. Look right around 62 mph, and they should see a 100 and a line there. That's 100 km/h. From there they know there are about .62 miles in 1 km. Look at where the 100mph is, and they'll see a smaller 160 near it. That is, again, the km/h number that can be used for conversion (1.6 kilometers per mile).

People don't need to told how to do things, nor do they need put much effort intoto look things up. Pretty much anyone should be able to figure out how to do the conversions if they actually try. They are exposed to them often enough that the effort involved would be minimal.

But even with info readily available, people don't figure it out on their own. They won't put forth that effort on their own. some will, but most won't even consider it important enough to learn. That's why it has to be a school-based effort. It has to be an explicit effort to make children have an unconscious comprehension of various measurements. When they hear that something is a mile away, they have an unconscious idea how far that is without having to think about it because of how much they've been exposed to it. Make sure they have that same unconscious reaction when they hear something is a kilometer away, and they won't need to sit there converting things in their heads.

People who can think in both systems don't have to dick around with conversions.
 
Howdy,

I was thinking, wouldn't it be better if the USA finally adopted the International System of Units? ;)

Because...

So, what do you think?

I think it sounds like someone here hates freedom.

Degrees Freedom.jpg
 
People who can think in both systems don't have to dick around with conversions.
300px-GasCan.jpg


How about three units? Why does it have to be so complicated? :doh
 
The first question that comes to my mind is who will be paying for the conversion of all that machinery currently calibrated in inches and feet?
 
Its metric here where I live but some things I still prefer in the old system.
I am used to temperatures in Celsius but still comprehend Fahrenheit. The big one for me is MPG so much better than L/100KM is. If they did KM/L it would be better but I guess they didn't like the numbers that came up so someone thought of using the silly L/100KM which ill probably get fully used to by the time I die.
I measure my height in feet/inches and weight in pounds, Though I use metric for most other measurements (ie buying potatoes at the store, distance to a destination etc)
 
Howdy,

I was thinking, wouldn't it be better if the USA finally adopted the International System of Units? ;)

Because...



So, what do you think?

I don't care either way, anyone who wants to use either system is free to do so. The cost for forcing a change to metric would be astronomical, though.
 
I don't care either way, anyone who wants to use either system is free to do so. The cost for forcing a change to metric would be astronomical, though.

All those road signs, textbooks, measure tapes, etc., etc. must be made and installed by someone. Just think of the economic growth and job creation! :mrgreen:
 
All those road signs, textbooks, measure tapes, etc., etc. must be made and installed by someone. Just think of the economic growth and job creation! :mrgreen:

I'm talking about individuals and small businesses that will have to replace thousands of dollars worth of tools. We already use both systems; I don't see why we can't continue to use both.
 
The first question that comes to my mind is who will be paying for the conversion of all that machinery currently calibrated in inches and feet?
That has always been the big hurdle for switching to metric.

Most things have to fit together with something else so they have to change over at near the same time or things go south. For example, in housing the length of studs would have to change to accommodate the change from 4x8' sheets of plywood and sheet-rock to 1200x1800 mm. Coming up 3/4" different just wouldn't work or would cost a lot of money cutting off the excess 3/4" (~19 mm) of material, whichever side the excess is. There are also engineering problems where old designs won't easily convert. For machine designs some bolts have to fit within 1/8" (~3 mm) or less of tolerance. A 1" long bolt is almost 5 mm shorter than a 30 cm bolt and a little over 5 mm longer. Anything with these issues would not only require retooling but redesigning as well.
 
Last edited:
Howdy,

I was thinking, wouldn't it be better if the USA finally adopted the International System of Units? ;)

Because...



So, what do you think?

Who has the strongest economy in the World? Who has the strongest military in the world? etc, etc. Why the hell would we want to copy the less successful. Let the less successful copy us.
 
Howdy,

I was thinking, wouldn't it be better if the USA finally adopted the International System of Units? ;)

Because...



So, what do you think?

---------------
No way.
I think we should stand with our courageous allies, Burma and Liberia, against this hideous homogenization.
These crackpot ideas are probably started by chubby people, "...I'm not fat, I only weigh 100 kilos..." and
short people "...I'm not short, I'm 150 centimeters tall...."
You get the picture.
 
The metric system is for people who can't do fractions.

Oh yeah, I'm sure you do your physics work in imperial units. How many ounces of propane do you need to combust to put out 20000 british thermal units?
 
300px-GasCan.jpg


How about three units? Why does it have to be so complicated? :doh

Hey, I was just in Franklin Park 30 minutes ago! My internship site is there. Freaky, considering that you're half a world away and it was just a random picture presumably grabbed on a google search. :lol:

Anyway, using that one can, we could figure out conversions for all three different systems of volume measurement. And we can make ourselves aware of the difference so that we could think in three different units of measurement.
 
Back
Top Bottom