• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Who benefits the most from the government? Rich or poor?

Who benefits the most?

  • Rich.

    Votes: 29 78.4%
  • Poor.

    Votes: 8 21.6%

  • Total voters
    37
Pshhhh the rich by far....

any proof of that? so tell me

do 47% of the voters who pay NO INCOME tax use less government benefits that are funded by the income tax than one guy making say 1,5 million a year who pays several hundred thousand in income taxes yearly>

It is your position that he uses more than 100 million people combined?
 
any proof of that? so tell me

do 47% of the voters who pay NO INCOME tax use less government benefits that are funded by the income tax than one guy making say 1,5 million a year who pays several hundred thousand in income taxes yearly>

It is your position that he uses more than 100 million people combined?



Lol any proof ...do you have any proof of ANYTHING you say
 
I ask you again, why do I have a duty to pay more taxes because you have been handed a crappy roll of the dice?


It is the law of the land get use to it.

And if you don't like our healthcare system move to Mexico or some other place where they have a costco approach.
 
Last edited:
I ask you again, why do I have a duty to pay more taxes because you have been handed a crappy roll of the dice?

These values almost seem as unethical as those of the average lawyer's .. lol! I guess some people just don't care about the welfare of their fellow man/woman. Oh well.

Besides, if it weren't for the poor, the wealthy wouldn't exist .. its seems pretty obvious to me .. don't understand why some people don't get it
 
Last edited:
Lol any proof ...do you have any proof of ANYTHING you say

more projection. can you answer the question. do 47% of the voters who pay no income tax use less of the governmental benefits funded by the FIT than one millionaire who pays 300K a year in income taxes?
 
These values almost seem as unethical as those of the average lawyer's .. lol! I guess some people just don't care about the welfare of their fellow man/woman. Oh well.

Besides, if it weren't for the poor, the wealthy wouldn't exist .. its seems pretty obvious to me .. don't understand why some people don't get it

wh do socialists think the only way to help others is by jacking up the taxes on those who pay a ton of taxes?
 
It is the law of the land get use to it.

And if you don't like our healthcare system move to Mexico or some other place where they have a costco approach.

ah the statist approach

if its law its moral and right

that's a pathetic answer but expected
 
These values almost seem as unethical as those of the average lawyer's .. lol! I guess some people just don't care about the welfare of their fellow man/woman. Oh well.


Something also that he doesn't realize is that currently I'm studied and upon death or heart transplant scientist studying this very unique heart condition will be very excited to get their hands on me.

And that is a freebie:)
 
Something also that he doesn't realize is that currently I'm studied and upon death or heart transplant scientist studying this very unique heart condition will be very excited to get their hands on me.

And that is a freebie:)

obviously you dont have the right to live because someone might be taxed

or that seems to be what some argue
 
Last edited:
wh do socialists think the only way to help others is by jacking up the taxes on those who pay a ton of taxes?

Umm ... in that post did I don't believe I said anything about "jacking up the taxes on the wealthy" .. I have always supported fair tax rates for the wealthy and true equal opportunity will be the only way people will be able to "help" themselves enough to have enough money to pay taxes
 
Something also that he doesn't realize is that currently I'm studied and upon death or heart transplant scientist studying this very unique heart condition will be very excited to get their hands on me.

And that is a freebie:)

ho would anyone "realize that" until you stated it? here is a song for you though

 
more projection. can you answer the question. do 47% of the voters who pay no income tax use less of the governmental benefits funded by the FIT than one millionaire who pays 300K a year in income taxes?

Does one multimillionaire that never was in the service..deserve more than a guy that went through hell for his country if hes one of the 47 million that does not make much money or didnt
 
Umm ... in that post did I don't believe I said anything about "jacking up the taxes on the wealthy" .. I have always supported fair tax rates for the wealthy and true equal opportunity will be the only way people will be able to "help" themselves enough to have enough money to pay taxes

your concept of fair has no rational relationship to reality though
 
your concept of fair has no rational relationship to reality though

You have no sense of fairness...you only I WANT WHAT I WANT then I WANT THE REST
 
Does one multimillionaire that never was in the service..deserve more than a guy that went through hell for his country if hes one of the 47 million that does not make much money or didnt

LOL-never in the service of the USA. Why are you changing the parameters now? were you one of those trade school enlistments who thinks the world owes him a perpetual living? So what do you do now?
 
Something also that he doesn't realize is that currently I'm studied and upon death or heart transplant scientist studying this very unique heart condition will be very excited to get their hands on me.

And that is a freebie:)

You have a great way of looking on the bright side of things. I hope things work out for you and it is very honorable for you to be thinking of how you will be a help to society while you are suffering from a heart condition.

Similarly .. my cadaver (I don't have a heart condition or anything like that) will also be invaluable as I am an organ donor.. its sad that some don't want their body to be used for science or for the good of others after death.
 
Last edited:
You have no sense of fairness...you only I WANT WHAT I WANT then I WANT THE REST

more personal attacks based on emotobabbling.

I have an objective sense of fairness

claiming that a group that makes 22% of the income but pays 40% of the income tax are not paying enough or "their fair share" is objectively insane
 
ah the statist approach

if its law its moral and right

that's a pathetic answer but expected


Ah now you are trying to fling insults, classy dude:lol:

And I'm fairly certain the National Institutes of Health and or SS has either benefited you or someone close to you.

And if you don't like the system you can move to a third world nation with a costco approach.

Them's the breaks bub.
 
more personal attacks based on emotobabbling.

I have an objective sense of fairness

claiming that a group that makes 22% of the income but pays 40% of the income tax are not paying enough or "their fair share" is objectively insane


Prove it...
 
Ah now you are trying to fling insults, classy dude:lol:

And I'm fairly certain the National Institutes of Health and or SS has either benefited you or someone close to you.

And if you don't like the system you can move to a third world nation with a costco approach.

Them's the breaks bub.

uh I am bashing your claims not you. your claim is a statist approach
 
So turtle...do you think veterans getting military disablity are parasites too ? do you think career military with 30 yrs shouldnt get a govt a pension ?
 
your concept of fair has no rational relationship to reality though

actually I think it's the other way around, if anything, it is your concept of "fair" does not have any "rational relationship to reality"
 
Back
Top Bottom