- Joined
- Feb 12, 2013
- Messages
- 160,900
- Reaction score
- 57,844
- Gender
- Undisclosed
- Political Leaning
- Centrist
I think you're actually on the wrong track here in that you are mixing two separate issues. You list these things as if they are levels of atheism, even calling them degrees and calling the very first one "agnostic". But you are actually not describing levels of atheism, but rather levels of arrogance and intolerance. The difference between what you describe as Atheist 5th degree and Atheist 1st degree has nothing to do with the person's beliefs about God or the strength of those beliefs; the difference is just that the 1st degree Atheist is an arrogant, intolerant prick and the 5th degree is a nice guy or gal (at least in this area).
I think the very idea of listing these as degrees of atheism is misguided. Someone can hold Atheist beliefs yet be a good person who has no problem accepting that others disagree with his view. The fact he's a good person doesn't mean he's less of an atheist. Your scale is actually measuring arrogance and intolerance, not atheist beliefs, so it just shouldn't be labeled "atheist nth degree".
Yeah, 1st degree atheists have rubbed me wrong in the past too. I agree. They are really annoying when they deny they are 1st degree and cling to the notion that they are 3rd degree, which I agree with you does not really exist in principle but it does as a personality.