• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!
  • Welcome to our archives. No new posts are allowed here.

Sen Cassidy's Obamacare repeal bill gets blasted by the health-secretary of his state

Rogue Valley

Lead or get out of the way
DP Veteran
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
93,292
Reaction score
81,299
Location
Barsoom
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
Full Title: Sen. Cassidy's Obamacare repeal bill gets blasted by the health secretary of his home state


By Michael Hiltzik
September 19, 2017

AR-170919797.jpg&maxh=400&maxw=667

Senators Bill Cassidy of Louisiana (L) and Lindsay Graham of South Carolina (R).

Senate Republicans are preparing to vote on their last-gasp Affordable Care Act repeal bill without estimates from the Congressional Budget Office of its effects on the deficit, health insurance coverage, or premiums. So someone else has to step in to inform the senators of the measure’s grim consequences. Enter Rebekah Gee, the secretary of the Department of Health in Louisiana—which happens to be the home state of the measure’s chief sponsor, Sen. Bill Cassidy. In a letter to Cassidy dated Monday, Gee offers chapter and verse on how the bill would cut health coverage for 433,000 of Cassidy’s constituents enrolled in Medicaid expansion; eliminate protection for people with pre-existing medical conditions, driving many of them into the “increasingly battered and tattered safety net of public assistance”; and threaten the health of “the unborn and their mothers.” Like all the GOP repeal proposals before it, Gee wrote, Cassidy’s bill “uniquely and disproportionately hurts Louisiana due to our recent expansion and high burden of extreme poverty.” Gee calculates that the bill’s elimination of expansion and capping of federal funding to states would cost Louisiana $3.2 billion through 2026, making Louisiana the eighth biggest loser among all states, “and by far the poorest and sickest state affected by these cuts.” That’s a major threat to “critical access and care for our most vulnerable Medicaid populations including the disabled, children, and pregnant women,” Gee wrote.

Gee’s broadside isn’t unique—virtually every responsible healthcare expert and medical organization has said much the same, as has the fiscal analysis firm Fitch Ratings, which judged the measure “more disruptive for most states than prior Republican efforts.” As many as 32 million Americans could lose their health coverage, according to legislative analyses—far more than under previous GOP repeal bills. Cassidy, like Gee a physician, hardly needs to be reminded of the effects of his bill, which is dubbed Cassidy-Graham to acknowledge the co-sponsorship of Sen. Lindsay Graham (R-S.C.). If he cared, he wouldn’t have introduced it in the first place. Yet the Republican Senate caucus appears determined to push the bill through without even the semblance of considered discussion. The Congressional Budget Office informed the Senators on Monday that it would be able to produce only “a preliminary assessment” of the measure early next week, but would need at least several weeks more to provide specific estimates of “the effects on the deficit, health insurance coverage, or premiums.” That would place the CBO analysis past the Sept. 30 deadline for the Senate to pass the bill on a reconciliation basis, which requires only 50 votes plus a tie-breaker by Vice President Mike Pence. After that, the bill would need 60 votes to overcome a certain filibuster by Democrats.

A scathing and deserved broadside at Sen. Cassidy by the Health Secretary of his home state of Louisiana. Senators Cassidy and Graham have [purposefully] introduced this Cassidy-Graham bill at a late date which will prevent the Congressional Budget Office from having the time necessary to fully study the bill and deliver solid data on its merits and demerits. Healthcare analysts who have reviewed the bill characterize it as worse that the previous failed GOP Senate attempts the Better Care Reconciliation Act and the 'skinny BCRA'. It is critical for success that Cassidy-Graham is voted on in the next week when only 50 Senate GOP votes (including VP Pence if necessary) are required to pass the measure. After September 30, 60 Senate votes will be necessary to pass the bill. This is yet another GOP repeal & replace bill with no Democrat input whatsoever. GOP Senators Susan Collins, Lisa Murkowski, and Rand Paul are expected no votes. Sen. John McCain may again vote no because like the other GOP healthcare attempts, this measure also falls short of his principles to “hold hearings, receive input from members of both parties, and heed the recommendations of our nation's governors” on healthcare.

Bipartisan group of governors ask Senate to reject Graham-Cassidy Obamacare repeal

Repeal and replace is back, and scarier than ever
 
Re: Sen Cassidy's Obamacare repeal bill gets blasted by the health-secretary of his s

Full Title: Sen. Cassidy's Obamacare repeal bill gets blasted by the health secretary of his home state




A scathing and deserved broadside at Sen. Cassidy by the Health Secretary of his home state of Louisiana. Senators Cassidy and Graham have [purposefully] introduced this Cassidy-Graham bill at a late date which will prevent the Congressional Budget Office from having the time necessary to fully study the bill and deliver solid data on its merits and demerits. Healthcare analysts who have reviewed the bill characterize it as worse that the previous failed GOP Senate attempts the Better Care Reconciliation Act and the 'skinny BCRA'. It is critical for success that Cassidy-Graham is voted on in the next week when only 50 Senate GOP votes (including VP Pence if necessary) are required to pass the measure. After September 30, 60 Senate votes will be necessary to pass the bill. This is yet another GOP repeal & replace bill with no Democrat input whatsoever. GOP Senators Susan Collins, Lisa Murkowski, and Rand Paul are expected no votes. Sen. John McCain may again vote no because like the other GOP healthcare attempts, this measure also falls short of his principles to “hold hearings, receive input from members of both parties, and heed the recommendations of our nation's governors” on healthcare.

Bipartisan group of governors ask Senate to reject Graham-Cassidy Obamacare repeal

Repeal and replace is back, and scarier than ever

I think the last 3 Senators that voted against the last bill, will do so again.
Though AZ Gov is in favor, I think McCain will vote against due to the lack of prcess, hearings avoided on this bill, as he did on the last.
Recall his speech when he returned to the Senate after his cancer diagnosis. it was heavy on processes, deliberation and hearings.

Link has video and full text

McCain's speech on the Senate floor (full text and video) - CNNPolitics
 
Re: Sen Cassidy's Obamacare repeal bill gets blasted by the health-secretary of his s

I think the last 3 Senators that voted against the last bill, will do so again.
Though AZ Gov is in favor, I think McCain will vote against due to the lack of prcess, hearings avoided on this bill, as he did on the last.
Recall his speech when he returned to the Senate after his cancer diagnosis. it was heavy on processes, deliberation and hearings.

Link has video and full text

McCain's speech on the Senate floor (full text and video) - CNNPolitics

Let's remember that Graham is McCain's buddy. Doubt if he will vote against. Perhaps Paul will take his place in blocking.
 
Re: Sen Cassidy's Obamacare repeal bill gets blasted by the health-secretary of his s

Let's remember that Graham is McCain's buddy. Doubt if he will vote against. Perhaps Paul will take his place in blocking.

McCain voted against the last bill. He voted to bring it to the floor, then on the final vote, thumbs down.
 
Re: Sen Cassidy's Obamacare repeal bill gets blasted by the health-secretary of his s

McCain voted against the last bill. He voted to bring it to the floor, then on the final vote, thumbs down.

That wasn't Graham's bill.
 
Re: Sen Cassidy's Obamacare repeal bill gets blasted by the health-secretary of his s

That wasn't Graham's bill.

Whose was it- Cassidy??
And what difference does it make?
 
Re: Sen Cassidy's Obamacare repeal bill gets blasted by the health-secretary of his s

Let's remember that Graham is McCain's buddy. Doubt if he will vote against. Perhaps Paul will take his place in blocking.

wash, as a slightly liberal poster you have to stop thinking like a conservative. conservatives cant grasp the concept of a politician doing his job and putting the people first. Slightly liberal posters understand that it can happen. I know its extremely rare when a republican does his job and puts the people first but McCain has actually done it a couple of times.
 
Back
Top Bottom