• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

'Army of Islam' would be world's biggest military

Status
Not open for further replies.

American

Trump Grump Whisperer
DP Veteran
Monthly Donator
Joined
Mar 11, 2006
Messages
96,099
Reaction score
33,416
Location
SE Virginia
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Conservative
‘Army of Islam’ would be world’s biggest military

WASHINGTON – When Turkey’s semi-official newspaper Yeni Safak called for urgent action in forming a 57-nation “Army of Islam” to besiege and attack Israel, a suggestion undoubtedly approved with at least a wink and nod by President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, it would signal the possible intent to create the largest military force on the planet – one nearly as large as the total population of the Jewish state.


The report came just ahead of the summit of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation and was published under the headline, “What if an Army of Islam was formed against Israel?” It was translated by the Middle East Media Research Institute.
But it wasn’t a rhetorical question. It was actually a suggestion to combine the military forces of all Islamic countries to overwhelm the Israeli army in manpower, budget and equipment – even boasting with statistics.
What do YOU think? Will Muslims join to create an ‘Army of Islam’? Sound off in the WND Poll
On December 12, 2017, ahead of the summit of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) in Istanbul, the Turkish daily Yeni Şafak, which is close to Erdoğan and his ruling AKP party, published an article titled “A Call for Urgent Action,” which also appeared on the paper’s website under the title “What If an Army of Islam Was Formed against Israel?”

Let's not get wrapped around the axle about the source. Let's just discuss the question, even hypothetically, about such a scenario. Assume it happens, what would follow?
 
next thing that happens, when they get geared up & busy? Some heads are gonna roll .........
 
‘Army of Islam’ would be world’s biggest military



Let's not get wrapped around the axle about the source. Let's just discuss the question, even hypothetically, about such a scenario. Assume it happens, what would follow?

I don't see it happening any time soon. Muslims are far from united. Do you think for a minute that Sunnis and Shia are going to march side by side into Israel? They'd kill each other before they got there.
 
More ridiculous hyperbolic nonsense from the usual suspects. Islam is not one monolithic religion- there are many sects, with many different outlooks. Muslims kill other Muslims more than they do others.
 
More ridiculous hyperbolic nonsense from the usual suspects. Islam is not one monolithic religion- there are many sects, with many different outlooks. Muslims kill other Muslims more than they do others.

I agree. And I would add, we're fortunate for said infighting.
 
The argument doesn’t quite hold up in some ways; for example, history shows that groups which the theory would presume would ally themselves due to cultural similarities deeply hate each other

Fair point. I wasn't arguing in favour necessarily, just offering some meat to a theory that has been around for a while. I covered it in an international relations module.
 
More ridiculous hyperbolic nonsense from the usual suspects. Islam is not one monolithic religion- there are many sects, with many different outlooks. Muslims kill other Muslims more than they do others.

Far and away most victims of terrorism are Muslims.
 
‘Army of Islam’ would be world’s biggest military



Let's not get wrapped around the axle about the source. Let's just discuss the question, even hypothetically, about such a scenario. Assume it happens, what would follow?

Hopefully NOTHING.

I'm being very good here, American, and following your rules. In this wildly hypothetical situation, hopefully America would not drag the rest of the world into WW3. I know it tried with Korea, and will likely succeed with Russia, but FFS, if the middle east wants to implode, let them. These people have been trying to kill each other for thousands of years. If you're really concerned, let the ones who want nothing to do with it immigrate, and let the rest of them have at it. Maybe Israel would work a little harder towards peace if they didn't feel certain America and their allies would bail them out every time. I, for one, don't want to see another Canadian dollar spent in fighting over that desert, I don't care how much oil is there.
 
More ridiculous hyperbolic nonsense from the usual suspects. Islam is not one monolithic religion- there are many sects, with many different outlooks. Muslims kill other Muslims more than they do others.

No really, I'm sure Iran, Saudi Arabia and dozens of other nations that hate each other with the passion of a thousand suns are all going to team up into a monolithic super army.

‘Army of Islam’ would be world’s biggest military
Let's not get wrapped around the axle about the source. Let's just discuss the question, even hypothetically, about such a scenario. Assume it happens, what would follow?

Let's not get wrapped up on whether my OP is complete and total fantasy bull**** or not, let's just assume it's legit and from a trustworthy source. Classic American.
 
That was one of the principals behind the Caliphate push which has been pretty much been stuffed back into its box.

But they didn't have the armies of every Muslim state involved.
 
You'd crawl even further under your bed at night and make certain that your mom left the light on.

That's cute, but you couldn't make a living at it, so keep your day job.
 
It’s so implausible it simply wouldn’t happen, short of Israel going insane and nuking Mecca.

I guess you missed the part about something hypothetical?
 
No really, I'm sure Iran, Saudi Arabia and dozens of other nations that hate each other with the passion of a thousand suns are all going to team up into a monolithic super army.



Let's not get wrapped up on whether my OP is complete and total fantasy bull**** or not, let's just assume it's legit and from a trustworthy source. Classic American.

Nasty, useless and unresponsive post.....Classic RA.
 
‘Army of Islam’ would be world’s biggest military



Let's not get wrapped around the axle about the source. Let's just discuss the question, even hypothetically, about such a scenario. Assume it happens, what would follow?

US forces would wipe the Army of Islam from the face of the Earth in defense of the attempted genocide of the nation of Israel.
The Palestinians would get evicted.
Israel would establish a security zone to protect itself.
The UN would denounce the actions of Israel and the US, while ignoring the attempted genocide by the Muslims.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom