• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

1946 Lynching Case Records Must Remain Sealed

Rogue Valley

Lead or get out of the way
DP Veteran
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
94,343
Reaction score
82,727
Location
Barsoom
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
Records in 1946 Lynching Case Must Remain Sealed, Court Rules | New York Times

No one was ever charged in the killing of two black couples by a group of white men in rural Georgia, known as the Moore’s Ford lynchings.

30xp-lynching-articleLarge.jpg

Mourners carried the coffin of a lynching victim out of Mount Perry Baptist Church in Bishop, Ga.
in 1946. The lynching was a quadruple killing.


3/31/20
A federal appeals court has ruled that grand jury evidence long sought by civil rights activists and historians in a 1946 mass lynching case in rural Georgia must remain sealed. Despite the historical significance of the case, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit in Atlanta ruled Friday that federal judges do not have the authority to unseal federal grand jury records, except for a limited set of circumstances governing grand jury rules of secrecy. The 8-to-4 decision reversed a lower court’s ruling in 2017 that the evidence should be unsealed. That ruling, which had been viewed as a breakthrough in the unsolved murders of two black couples in 1946 by a mob of white men in Walton County, Ga., was also affirmed in 2019 by a three-judge panel made up of members of the circuit court, which heard the case after the Justice Department appealed the lower court’s decision. Last June, the full court voted to rehear the case, which led to Friday’s ruling.

The victims in the lynchings, Roger and Dorothy Malcom and George and Mae Murray Dorsey, were dragged from their car at gunpoint on July 25, 1946, tied up and shot about 60 times at close range in the attack, which was widely considered to be one of the last mass lynchings in American history. It came to be known as the Moore’s Ford lynchings. The killings took place about 60 miles east of Atlanta, where the Moore’s Ford Bridge crosses the Apalachee River. In a 2011 letter to a judicial rules committee, Eric Holder, then the U.S. attorney general, said that federal courts should be allowed to disclose grand jury materials of great historical significance. The rules committee opted not to proceed with the recommendation, the circuit court’s ruling said.

Even after the passage of 74 years, the Trump Justice Department fought against the release of the grand jury testimony. More than 100 people testified before a federal grand jury in December 1946 but no one was indicted.

Reminds me somewhat of the eventual indictment and conviction of Klansman Byron De La Beckwith (1920-2001) for the 1963 assassination of Medgar Evers in his Jackson, Mississippi driveway. After two trials resulted in hung juries in 1964, Beckwith thought he had escaped justice. But in 1994 buried trial documents were unearthed and Beckwith was indicted, convicted of the murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole.
 
Gotta protect twump’s own i guess? He has been known to do what riles up lynch mobs.
 
"Very fine people."

The ugliness is the point.
 
Records in 1946 Lynching Case Must Remain Sealed, Court Rules | New York Times

No one was ever charged in the killing of two black couples by a group of white men in rural Georgia, known as the Moore’s Ford lynchings.

30xp-lynching-articleLarge.jpg

Mourners carried the coffin of a lynching victim out of Mount Perry Baptist Church in Bishop, Ga.
in 1946. The lynching was a quadruple killing.




Even after the passage of 74 years, the Trump Justice Department fought against the release of the grand jury testimony. More than 100 people testified before a federal grand jury in December 1946 but no one was indicted.

Reminds me somewhat of the eventual indictment and conviction of Klansman Byron De La Beckwith (1920-2001) for the 1963 assassination of Medgar Evers in his Jackson, Mississippi driveway. After two trials resulted in hung juries in 1964, Beckwith thought he had escaped justice. But in 1994 buried trial documents were unearthed and Beckwith was indicted, convicted of the murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole.

Another case of hiding the truth
 
Probably a Democrat who did it.

Buh buh democrats derp. Is it any wonder why republicans get laughed out of history classes.
 
Buh buh democrats derp. Is it any wonder why republicans get laughed out of history classes.

Well ya know the world is only 6000 years old.

Where do you think boats came from???
 
Records in 1946 Lynching Case Must Remain Sealed, Court Rules | New York Times

No one was ever charged in the killing of two black couples by a group of white men in rural Georgia, known as the Moore’s Ford lynchings.

30xp-lynching-articleLarge.jpg

Mourners carried the coffin of a lynching victim out of Mount Perry Baptist Church in Bishop, Ga.
in 1946. The lynching was a quadruple killing.




Even after the passage of 74 years, the Trump Justice Department fought against the release of the grand jury testimony. More than 100 people testified before a federal grand jury in December 1946 but no one was indicted.

Reminds me somewhat of the eventual indictment and conviction of Klansman Byron De La Beckwith (1920-2001) for the 1963 assassination of Medgar Evers in his Jackson, Mississippi driveway. After two trials resulted in hung juries in 1964, Beckwith thought he had escaped justice. But in 1994 buried trial documents were unearthed and Beckwith was indicted, convicted of the murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole.

Gotta protect twump’s own i guess? He has been known to do what riles up lynch mobs.

"Very fine people."

The ugliness is the point.

Probably a Democrat who did it.

Buh buh democrats derp. Is it any wonder why republicans get laughed out of history classes.

Probably. And almost certainly a conservative.

" Harry S. Truman created the President's Committee on Civil Rights and his administration introduced anti-lynching legislation in Congress, but could not get it past the Southern Democratic block. "

Democrats blocked it...

"The state of Georgia and the FBI finally closed their cases in December 2017, again unable to prosecute any suspect."

Under Democrat Clinton's Justice Department.

Moore's Ford lynchings - Wikipedia
 
" Harry S. Truman created the President's Committee on Civil Rights and his administration introduced anti-lynching legislation in Congress, but could not get it past the Southern Democratic block. "

Democrats blocked it...

"The state of Georgia and the FBI finally closed their cases in December 2017, again unable to prosecute any suspect."

Under Democrat Clinton's Justice Department.

Moore's Ford lynchings - Wikipedia

Course they did. Southern conservatives were Democrats because Lincoln was a Republican. George Wallace for example.
There used to be liberal Republicans too. Nelson Rockefeller, for example.
I don't get the reference to Clinton but he was a conservative too, mostly.
 
Course they did. Southern conservatives were Democrats because Lincoln was a Republican. George Wallace for example.
There used to be liberal Republicans too. Nelson Rockefeller, for example.
I don't get the reference to Clinton but he was a conservative too, mostly.

The whole thing is stupid... that is my point. Just more whiners whining about Trump.

Just another gaggle of people sniveling in a corner crying about Trump.

You did not do this and I included you just to get interest. Clinton was added to show that the President's Justice Department, on both sides, do things that are not good... nobody is bashing Clinton about this... in fact, I bet nobody even noticed back in the day... but TRUMP!!!
 
Records in 1946 Lynching Case Must Remain Sealed, Court Rules | New York Times

No one was ever charged in the killing of two black couples by a group of white men in rural Georgia, known as the Moore’s Ford lynchings.

30xp-lynching-articleLarge.jpg

Mourners carried the coffin of a lynching victim out of Mount Perry Baptist Church in Bishop, Ga.
in 1946. The lynching was a quadruple killing.




Even after the passage of 74 years, the Trump Justice Department fought against the release of the grand jury testimony. More than 100 people testified before a federal grand jury in December 1946 but no one was indicted.

Reminds me somewhat of the eventual indictment and conviction of Klansman Byron De La Beckwith (1920-2001) for the 1963 assassination of Medgar Evers in his Jackson, Mississippi driveway. After two trials resulted in hung juries in 1964, Beckwith thought he had escaped justice. But in 1994 buried trial documents were unearthed and Beckwith was indicted, convicted of the murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole.

Gee, I thought for a moment there you were going to start a thread that wasnt some mindless attempt to blame trump for something. My bad.
 
I don't get the reference to Clinton but he was a conservative too, mostly.

William Jefferson Clinton had nothing to do with this case.

On the other hand, Trump's DOJ fought to keep the grand jury testimony buried, even after 74 years.

One can only wonder what/who they are protecting with this dick move.
 
Gee, I thought for a moment there you were going to start a thread that wasnt some mindless attempt to blame trump for something. My bad.

It is Trumps DOJ is it not?
 
It is Trumps DOJ is it not?

Trump loses a lot of court battles. What was the legal argument for keeping the case sealed? Its been sealed for 74 years so there is obviously a legal reason for that that goes beyond the dreaded Trump, no?
 
Trump loses a lot of court battles. What was the legal argument for keeping the case sealed? Its been sealed for 74 years so there is obviously a legal reason for that that goes beyond the dreaded Trump, no?

The testimony would have been unsealed sans the Trump DOJ objection.
 
The testimony would have been unsealed sans the Trump DOJ objection.

How do you know that? And Trump has been in office for only 3 years. Those files have been sealed since before he was born. Why? What is the legal argument for keeping them sealed? I suspect you dont care. You are just looking for a club to bash the president with. As usual.
 
" Harry S. Truman created the President's Committee on Civil Rights and his administration introduced anti-lynching legislation in Congress, but could not get it past the Southern Democratic block. "

Democrats blocked it...

"The state of Georgia and the FBI finally closed their cases in December 2017, again unable to prosecute any suspect."

Under Democrat Clinton's Justice Department.

Moore's Ford lynchings - Wikipedia

More buh buh democrats durr. Its typical distraction from twumpusts.
 
More buh buh democrats durr. Its typical distraction from twumpusts.

It makes a point that *WHOOOSH* went way over your head.
 
It makes a point that *WHOOOSH* went way over your head.

The op is about twump and not releasing the records. Its typical response by people that still think the segregationists are still democrats.
 
The op is about twump and not releasing the records. Its typical response by people that still think the segregationists are still democrats.

Trump has nothing to do with releasing records or not... Trump is not a Master of Puppets controlling everything in government.
 
Trump has nothing to do with releasing records or not... Trump is not a Master of Puppets controlling everything in government.

He does pick those under his cabinet and demands fealty. Read the op.
 
Back
Top Bottom