• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

The real Che Guevara

Reputations are meaningless in this day and age.

Look, there are a dozen + posts calling him various murderous names, but NOT ONE thread of a source or even quotations from people who knew him


That tells me the whole thread is bait & bullshit
Are you trying to tell us Guevara was a communist revolutionary?
And the reason he his admired by some is not because he may have admired Stalin, but because -rightly or wrongly- he could have had a cushy existence in Cuba, but decided to go and fight fir what he perceived as justice in the second poorest country in the hemisphere.
Cuba: Che Guevara: The Fish Die by the Mouth (cubanet.org)
OPINIÓN DE LOS LECTORES
23 de Enero de 2009

By Humberto (Bert) Corzo*

Introduction

The saying “The fish die by the mouth”, refers to those who speak more than the necessary until being fooled by their own speech. Can his mythical reputation survive the publication of his own words?

The objective of this article is to expose the truth about Che, to demystify it in the face of those who feel admiration by this mass murderer, exposing the facts based on his writings, diaries, speeches, letters and conversations with those who knew him.
Click link above for full article.
 
Everyone knows who Guevara was and what he did. What's with the dead horse flogging? Like all "heroes" and conquerors, he was deeply flawed.
 
Che Guevara was a racist, homophobic and mass murdered. He was "a living, breathing instrument" of racism

Quote from the book “The Motorcycle Diaries: Notes on a Latin America Journey” by Che Guevara: “The blacks, those magnificent examples of the African race who have maintained their racial purity thanks to their lack of an affinity with bathing, have seen their territory invaded by a new kind of slave: the Portuguese.

The black is indolent and a dreamer; spending his meager wage on frivolity or drink; the European has a tradition of work and saving, which has pursued him as far as this corner of America and drives him to advance himself, even independently of his own individual aspirations.”
 
Here’s a look back at the history. He was an extremely vain person, without substance, extremely rude, cold and heartless, intentionally deceptive and full of himself as many famous movie star. Cuban children begin their classes each day with the following chant: “Pioneers for Communism, we will be like Che.” As Bert Corzo wrote in Che Guevara The Fish Die by the Mouth, “They will be then the new men; fanatics, liars, assassins and failed men, reaching the total realization of being like Che.…Che was fanatical, dogmatic, spiteful, envious, arrogant, proud, a liar, racist, devoid of morals, mercenary and homophobic, a bloodthirsty murderer, a cold killing machine, that the fanaticism of the left has turned into a hero.”
 
POSTED BY JOHN SUAREZ | OCTOBER 9, 2022

"I'd like to confess, at that moment I discovered that I really like killing." Ernesto "Che" Guevara, in a letter to his father after executing an unarmed man.
1678930903794.png
Che Guevara executed for trying to overthrow Bolivian govt on October 9, 1967

Ideas have consequences and those ideas are sometimes represented in iconic images. This is the case of the image of Ernesto "Che" Guevara and his toxic philosophy of political action that others seek to emulate. He embraced hatred and dehumanization of the other as the means to carry out what he thought necessary actions.

“Blind hate against the enemy creates a forceful impulse that cracks the boundaries of natural human limitations, transforming the soldier in an effective, selective and cold killing machine. A people without hate cannot triumph against the adversary.”
In April 1967, speaking from experience, he summed up his homicidal idea of justice in his "Message to the Tricontinental": "To send men to the firing squad, judicial proof is unnecessary. These procedures are an archaic bourgeois detail. This is a revolution! And a revolutionary must become a cold killing machine motivated by pure hate. We must create the pedagogy of the paredon! (The Wall)"
 
Che Guevara was a cold-blooded psychopath. That is probably why the Left is so enamored of him. He represents all their darkest fantasies.

Guevara's claim to fame was the role he played alongside Fidel and Raul Castro in installing a totalitarian communist dictatorship using violent means, including terrorism, in Cuba then attempting to spread this model using violent means to Africa and Latin America. His efforts failed.

Castro executed thousands of Cubans, locked up hundreds of thousands of Cubans, built a police state, with the assistance of the KGB and the East German Stasi, and imposed revolutionary terror to consolidate power. Credible and conservative estimates of the Castro regime’s death toll against Cuban nationals ran from 35,000 to 141,000, with a median of 73,000. In the beginning executions were televised in Cuba to terrorize the populace.

Che Guevara addressing the United Nations on December 11, 1964 did not mince words: "We must say here something that is a well-known truth and that we have always asserted before the whole world: executions? Yes, we have executed people; we are executing people and shall continue to execute people as long as it is necessary. We know what the result of a losing battle would
During the debate in the United Nations General Assembly where Guevara represented de Cuban government, this was severely attacked because of the firing squad executions without any judicial process and evidence as required by the rule of law. Guevara, on his own voiced, responded:

“Shooting people yes, we have shoot people and will continuo to do so until it will be required.” Video link: YouTube- che guevara"Che Guevara: AnatomÃa de un mito"

Ernesto "Che" Guevara with a Cuban delegation visited Mainland China and met with Mao Zedong, Zhou Enlai, and other high ranking Chinese officials in November 1960 to discuss conditions in Cuba and in Latin America, and the prospects for communist revolution in the Western Hemisphere.
 
1681688093583.png
Mao Ze Dong caused the deaths of an estimated 45 million Chinese people in his communist project through famine and mass executions. He is the greatest mass murderer of the 20th century, and someone Guevara stayed allied to, even after the Castro regime cooled relations with Beijing siding with Moscow.
Communism is a totalitarian movement that seek to exterminate whoever stands in their way in the name of socio-economic equality. One way or another, the shallow graves get filled.

Months after the world came perilously close to a nuclear holocaust in October 1962, Che Guevara was disappointed. The Argentine declared in November 1962: "What we affirm is that we must proceed along the path of liberation even if this costs millions of atomic victims.”
 
Che Guevara told British reporter Sam Russell that “if the nuclear missiles had been under Cuban control (during the Cuban missile crisis), they would have fired them off.” Reportedly, he was disappointed when Khrushchev decided to draw back his weapons in the missile crisis. "If the rockets had remained, we would have used them all and directed them against the very heart of the United States, including New York, in our defense against aggression."
Ernesto Guevara was executed summarily on October 9, 1967 in La Higuera, Bolivia after he and his band of guerrillas were captured trying to overthrow the legitimate government there and install a Castro style dictatorship. His legacy at the time was already one of blood and terror that should be lamented not celebrated.
1683001483811.png
Comandante Ernesto "Che" Guevara is still dead, his ideas are still toxic, and need to be buried along with him.
 
Capitan Gary Prado says that Che simply dropped his gun and surrendered. Prado remembers him responding, “Don't shoot, I'm Che, I'm worth more to you alive than dead.” Che was slightly wounded in the lower calf, and walked helped by a soldier, soldier Montenegro. The firefighter was still raging after Che’s surrender. His men, unlike him, were fighting to the last bullet.

On October 9, 1967 Ernesto "Che" Guevara got a major dose of his own medicine. Without trial he was declared a murderer and shot. Historically speaking, justice has rarely been better served. The butcher of la Cabaña. As the saying says, “he who lives by the sword, die by the sword.” Álvaro Vargas Llosa wrote, “Guevara might have been enamored of his own death, but he was much more enamored of other people’s deaths.”
 
by Tom Rogan, National Security Writer & Online Editor |

October 09, 2017 03:58 PM

This is worth noting because Monday is the 50th anniversary of Guevara's death.

Consider the Che's life story.

In his early years, Guevara seemed genuinely moved by the injustices visited upon the rural peoples of South America. Unfortunately, he took his righteous anger and translated it into a pursuit of perpetual war. Cuba was his first major adventure.

As soon as Castro's revolution had been effected, Guevara became the proud servant of communist moral delusion. Acting as Castro's Treasury Secretary, Guevara ignored the failures and associated moral hardships his collectivist policies imposed. But like Napoleon the pig, Guevara was convinced of his own innate better-knowledge. In Cuba, Guevara's economic leadership would set the tone for the horrors yet to come.

That's important to note, because Guevara's Cuba period is that most idolized by his fans. Yet the history shows that Guevara in Cuba wasn't a Robin Hood for the people, but rather, an ideological fanatic. Indeed, the Latin American Nikita Khrushchev was determined to one-up the Soviet overlord. When Khrushchev removed nuclear warheads from Cuba and ended the Cuban Missile Crisis, Guevara was furious: he hated America and would never yield to compromises for peace.

This evil fanaticism to a broader point: Guevara may have been a psychopath.
Click link above for full article.
Che was disappointed when Khrushchev decided to draw back his weapons during the Cuban Missile Crisis: “If the missiles had remained, we would have used them against the very heart of America including New York. We must never establish peaceful coexistence. In this struggle to the death between two systems we must gain the ultimate victory. We must walk the path of liberation even if it costs millions of atomic victims.” Che had a deep hatred against the United States.
 
Seems that this Che was no nice person.
 
Communism is a totalitarian movement that seek to exterminate whoever stands in their way in the name of socio-economic equality. One way or another, the shallow graves get filled.

Months after the world came perilously close to a nuclear holocaust in October 1962, Che Guevara was disappointed. The Argentine declared in November 1962: "What we affirm is that we must proceed along the path of liberation even if this costs millions of atomic victims.”


:rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: o_O o_O o_O
 
Here is Che recounting the execution of Eutimio Guerra for betraying the Cuban revolution: “I fired a 32 caliber bullet into the right hemisphere of his brain which came out through his left temple. He moaned for a few moments, then died.”

The world is better without him around, and would have been much better if he had been taken out sooner. Che only lived long enough to slay a few thousand, but his followers still are at it.
 
No, Che was not nice.
 
To excuse the total brutality of the US and the US-backed dictatorship by accusing those who responded to it with some brutality of their own is just so provocative. Yes, they where communists, but in South America during this time it was only the communists that stood up to the facist regime that US backed or, like in Cuba, created. Guevera was so much more than a vilian. He was instrumental in creating an independent radio station in 1958, which broadcast news to the Cuban people and provided radiotelephone communication between the rebels across the island. Without him the people of Cuba wouldn't have stood a chance to overthrow the oppressors.

And, let's face it, without Foco, Cuba may still be a facist regime with starvation and murder by abundance in it's wake. Cuba is not by a longshot in a good place today, but in more than one way, US is to be blamed for the developement into the communistic dictatorship it is. If US hadn't impossed the sanctions and restrictions on Cuba, it might have been a democracy today.

Put the blame where the blame is due...

Starting to get really weary of your propaganda threads I need to repeat myself'

To be fair (and I am not pro-Cuban, but right should be right) before Fidel Castro and the revolution, 95 % of the people where starving big time. They had no access to electricity. Corruption was double the one in Russia of today. Unemployeement enourmous, those who had jobs had to except levels for wages equal to those in 1910. Demonstrating students and workers where systematically killed. Trade union premises were occupied. Opposition( mostly communists) and union leaders where systematically murdered. The rest (5%) living in luxury though... The corruption was enormous much worse than the one in Russia of today. Infront of the 1952 elections, the Orthodox Party (in which Fidel Castro was a member) was on its way to a certain victory. But the election never took place. With US support, Batista staged a military coup in March 1952.

And yes, the US has since the occupation (1902) very much been the reason for Cubas demise and developement. US companies looted Cuba, within the economic agreements concluded between the United States and its puppet regimes on Cuba (the 5% that had good living standards, or in more modern terms, the Cuban oligarchs...)). In the 1920s, the United States controlled almost the entire Cuban economy. Companies such as United Fruit heavily exploited the island for export crops, sugar, tobacco and bananas. The distortion of the country's economy was driven to such an extent that, despite agriculture being the main industry, large quantities of food had to be imported. USA monopolies not only owned sugar mills, oil refineries, banks, small industries, telephone and electric grids, but the US embassy was also the one that effectively controlled the court, government and president. This neo-colonialism differs from the old colonialism mainly in that the exploited country, Cuba, itself was forced to bear the costs of the oppressive apparatus and staff it. For Cuba, this meant that the countryside was underdeveloped, and that prostitution and gambling flourished in Havana and elsewhere where crime, mafia rule and racial discrimination thrived.

So to all the 5% relatives, who now live in the US where they fled during the revolution, and who still justify the impoverishment, exploitation and theft from the Cuban people and think they should be entitled to the loot they didn't manage to take with them on the run to USA, I say Fxxx you…claiming the loots of murderers and bandits
 
To excuse the total brutality of the US and the US-backed dictatorship by accusing those who responded to it with some brutality of their own is just so provocative.
One detail of Cuba before Castro:

What the tourists didn’t see, or didn’t want to, was the underclass, people of poverty like the macheteros — sugarcane cutters — who worked only during the four month season, and the rest of the year were unemployed and angry.


 
Here is Che recounting the execution of Eutimio Guerra for betraying the Cuban revolution: “I fired a 32 caliber bullet into the right hemisphere of his brain which came out through his left temple. He moaned for a few moments, then died.”

The world is better without him around, and would have been much better if he had been taken out sooner. Che only lived long enough to slay a few thousand, but his followers still are at it.
Che Guevara was a cold-blooded psychopath. That is probably why the Left is so enamored of him. He represents all their darkest fantasies. It goes to show that Che is not the martyr that leftists and brainless kids who wear his shirts believe he is, as his hands are stained with the blood of hundreds of summarily executed victims.
 
Ciro Roberto Bustos, a committed Communist up to his death on January 1, 2017, who was Che's right-hand man in Argentina and Bolivia, in his book “Che Wants to See You”, said: “Guevara was in deed a 'synthesis of pathological sadism and fundamentalist extremism.” The French writer Regis Debray, author of "Revolution in the revolution", wrote about Che that: "He was adept of the totalitarianism up to the last body hair.” Che impulsive cruel behavior inflicted physical and psychological pain on others to assert his power. He literally interpreted the Marxism doctrine and engaged in arm struggle to enforce it.
 
Che Guevara: Bolivian General Gary Prado Salmón who captured revolutionary dies - BBC News
1690786494958.png
Gary Prado Salmón in 2007 - he wrote a book about the capture of Che Guevara
The Bolivian general who captured the Cuban revolutionary Ernesto "Che" Guevara and became a national hero has died aged 84.
In 1967 Gary Prado Salmón led a military operation in Bolivia, backed by US secret service agents, that defeated a communist insurrection organised by Che Guevara.

At the time Bolivia had a right-wing military government.

An army officer executed Argentina-born Guevara a day after his arrest.

The Cold War between the US and Soviet Union was at its height and Washington was extremely concerned about communist influence in Latin America, including Che Guevara's activities.

He had left Cuba after the triumph of the 1959 revolution there, to lead guerrilla movements in other countries. He was a key ally of Cuban communist leader Fidel Castro and became a hero for communists worldwide.

Gen Prado's son described his father as "an extraordinary person", who left "a legacy of love, integrity and courage".

The Bolivian officer who shot and killed Che Guevara was Mario Terán, who died last year.
Click link above for full article.
Che’s Diary in Bolivia contains the following observations: “The Army is showing more effectiveness in its action and the rural masses do not help us in any way and they become informers….The rural masses do not help us at all” was the melancholic conclusion of Guevara in his Bolivian diary. The 26 of September he write down in his diary, "defeat", in reference to “the disastrous ambush of La Higuera.”
 
Gary Prado Salmón, in his book “How I capture Che Guevara”, recalls his final hours in Bolivia. Prado says, my soldiers helped Che walk, because of his wounded calf. As we walked, Che said to me: ‘I’m more use to you alive than dead.’ Che was clearly worried about what was going to happen to him. I told him that a military court would judge him as they did with Régis Debray and Ciro Bustos in Santa Cruz.

I asked: ‘Why did you come here to offer people land when we’ve had a very profound land reform already? That’s why no peasants are joining your movement.’ He replied: ‘Yes, we were wrong about that, we had the wrong information.’



[BC1]
 
The Castroist regime says it recovered Guevara's remains from Bolivia and laid them to rest at a monument in Santa Clara, Cuba. Villoldo disputes that account, saying the makeshift grave the remains were pulled from, held seven bodies while he buried only three. Who is buried in Che’s tomb? Eventually will be find out through DNA identification proses.
 
Date: June 17, 2022
1694759859618.png
Antonella Marty | Associate Director at the Center for Latin American at Atlas Network

This week 94 years ago, Che Guevara was born. And, for many Americans, his birthday is an annual cause for celebration.

On college campuses, his face is a more common sight than Ronald Reagan or even John F. Kennedy. Even more common are the tributes to Che's supposed altruism and compassion, penned by those who share his communist sympathies. As one British union official recently wrote in U.K.-based Tribune Magazine, "[He] committed his life to the cause of the oppressed—and in the process, became one of the twentieth century's most influential figures." Che's writings, according to his union allies, reveal "charm and tenderness, as well as an absolute political commitment to finding out how we can win, and keep, a world run by and for the people."

That's one way of putting it. But the real Che is far, far removed from the figure romanticized by the radical left. I was born in the same city as Che—Rosario, Argentina, also the birthplace of Lionel Messi—and his worldview is hardly a myth to people from Rosario. We feel like we know Che personally, so it's easy to demystify his political views. It's easy to expose the myth that has become Che Guevara.

First and foremost, Che Guevara was a cold-blooded communist, who found an ally in Cuban revolutionary Fidel Castro. In 1955, he met Castro in Mexico City, joined his 26th of July Movement, and eventually became a high-ranking government official in the new regime. Che served as both president of the national bank and later as the country's minister of industries, tightening Castro's grip on Cuba's entire economy.
Click link above for full article.
Antonella Marty, was born in the same city as Che, Rosario, Argentina, and knows his real life very well. As she says: “The peaceful, romantic view of Che is mere fiction. The facts are death, destruction, and despair that can still be felt in the repressive Cuba he left behind.” Well said.
 
i do not really believe that anyone is a 'different race' because race is myth. it has no standing aside from our wish to believe that people that do not look like we do must be fundamentally different. they are not.

yes, i know that Guevara had Irish heritage. So do I. So does the fella in the ugly caricature that i posted. che was argentinian, spanish and irish.

that was the point. white? depends on whom you ask. he did not look like an ape. and if it is your wish to NOT seem like a racist you would be well advised to abjure the tactics of racism.

geo.
We are all apes :)
 
Date: June 17, 2022
1696117217567.png
Antonella Marty | Associate Director at the Center for Latin American at Atlas Network

This week 94 years ago, Che Guevara was born. And, for many Americans, his birthday is an annual cause for celebration.

On college campuses, his face is a more common sight than Ronald Reagan or even John F. Kennedy. Even more common are the tributes to Che's supposed altruism and compassion, penned by those who share his communist sympathies. As one British union official recently wrote in U.K.-based Tribune Magazine, "[He] committed his life to the cause of the oppressed—and in the process, became one of the twentieth century's most influential figures." Che's writings, according to his union allies, reveal "charm and tenderness, as well as an absolute political commitment to finding out how we can win, and keep, a world run by and for the people."

That's one way of putting it. But the real Che is far, far removed from the figure romanticized by the radical left. I was born in the same city as Che—Rosario, Argentina, also the birthplace of Lionel Messi—and his worldview is hardly a myth to people from Rosario. We feel like we know Che personally, so it's easy to demystify his political views. It's easy to expose the myth that has become Che Guevara.
Click link above for full article.
Antonella Marty, was born in the same city as Che, Rosario, Argentina, and knows his real life very well. As she says: “The peaceful, romantic view of Che is mere fiction. The facts are death, destruction, and despair that can still be felt in the repressive Cuba he left behind.” Well said.
 
Back
Top Bottom