Yes, the forced removal of the Jews to replace them with Arab Palestinians. Ethnic cleansing.
I'm always confused where people put things out there that they think makes their point but actually makes precisely the opposite point. Nicely done.
And no, getting someone of the same ethnic group to do the cleansing on behalf of the other group doesn't make it any better. It just makes all parties complicit.
You keep doing the same dance but don't move off the spot.
Why wasn't the disengagement from Gaza and the subsequent removal of illegal Jewish settlers considered to be an ethnic cleansing ?
People who live illegally in the territory of another state, protected by an occupying army but retaining the civilian status of their own state shouldn't be considered to be the same as people residing legally in their own state who are forced from that territory by the outside forces of another state wishing to remove them so as to use the space for its own people
It is this sort of perversion of the concept of ethnic cleansing that shows how disgusting many of the Israeli misrepresentations/underminings of solid HRs laws/inernational norms really are. Consider the sheer arrogance of the above. Recall that you have supported two authentic ethnic cleansings and still demand those people not be allowed to return just because they are Arabs. But with Jews you ignore their illegal status and their impact on the Palestinian state in as breathtaking an example of double standards as it is possible to witness.
Then we get to the other alternative that you have completely ignored
They could renounce their Israeli citizenship agree to live in peace with their neighbours and opt to become Palestinian citizens living in the Palestinian state. You won't say but it's obvious the thought makes you balk because it is yet another double standard based on ethnicity.
Ethnic cleansing are fine if it's Arabs being cleansed but Jews , heaven forbid.
Arab citizens of Israel can be used as a banner for the sanctitiy of the Jewish state but Jews being forced into returning to their own state or renouncing it to live in the Palestinian one , heaven forbid, that's something to be foisted on the Arabs only, not Jews
There is no confusion here in my view just a very obvious difference between two people , one who thinks Arabs are inferior to Jews and one who applies the same standards to both peoples.
Two direct questions you have simply tried to avoid answering.
If what you say is true , how come nobody refers to the disengagement from Gaza and the removal of illegal Jewisg settlers living there an ethnic cleansing ?
Why can't the illegal settlers left in the West Bank and Golan be given the option to either move to their own state or stay put and become citizens of the state whose land they illegal live in ?