• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Context

Apocalypse said:
Your posts unfortunately for you are documented here, your denial is futile. One post in response to Palestinian terrorism says "yeah but all people do violence at one point..." and another in response to Israeli actions is "yeah but it shouldn't matter what other people do". Hypocrisy revealed, your response is hysterical.
Click to expand...

Nothing unfortunate about the documenting of my posts. It's been a different story for you of late though. Tough week for your credibility and all

They're not even proper quotes from me , I never use " yeah " that's why yo don't provide links or even the context for the use of paraphrasing

Youre sore , I get it , move on
 
Apocalypse said:
He who rapes the woman with the short skirt will claim she provoked him into raping her by wearing the short skirt.
Click to expand...

And how many people are going to buy that ? It's pathetic , like your analogy. Get real

It's nowhere near the same argument and you know it , it 's just that if you can portray people with some sympathy for the plight of the Palestinians as supporters of rape you will feel as though a mission has been accomplished. It hasn't , your analogy is complete rubbish


Israel's existence is as legitimate as a woman choosing to wear a short skirt.
Click to expand...

What happens if we put the Palestinian in a skirt ?

It's her legitimate right to self determination and you are the one violating her right by denying it


The Jewish right to self determination is as legitimate as the individual's right to choose what to wear.
Click to expand...

And the Palestinian right to self determination too. Sad that you have to be reminded

Your response to terrorism against Jews is a justification of it the same way such response to an act of rape is a justification of that act.
Click to expand...

My response to terrorism is that it's a crime no matter who does it , well documented here

I would say that your support for and defence of Israeli policies which deny the Palestinians their legitimate right is more of a direct support for your hypothetical rapist then anything I have said or written

Haven't thought this through have you ?
 
oneworld2 said:
Palestinian defiance in the face of persistent monthly acts of Israeli state terrorism and violent suppression .
Click to expand...

AKA, Rockets, bombs, knives...

20,000 + acts of terrorism.

And the rockets fell BEFORE the blockade.

oneworld2 said:
If the blockade of the Straits of Tiran was considered to be an act of war in 1967 then , if we wish to be consistent , the blockade of Gaza , predominantly by Israel , is likewise an act of war against the people of Gaza.
Click to expand...

20,000 acts of war against Israel.

As to the blockade.

Are they stopping all humanitarian and food supplies?

oneworld2 said:
Do you agree ?
Click to expand...

I agree Hamas made their bed... They shouldn't cry about how it sleeps.
 
Fledermaus said:
AKA, Rockets, bombs, knives...

20,000 + acts of terrorism.

And the rockets fell BEFORE the blockade.
Click to expand...

The suppression , occupation and state violence against the Palestinians predates even Hamas by some distance

Israel attacked Gaza and violated , including such as murder and torture/imprisonment, a large swathe of the population there when it also attacked Egypt in 1956. That's before the blockade too

The slaughtered a load more in 1967 when the brutal repressive occupation started. That was before the blockade


As to the blockade.

Are they stopping all humanitarian and food supplies?
Click to expand...

They are not permitted to stop that as the occupying power. Yes it's still under effective control by Israel so the charge of an occupation from without has validity and many groups/people recognize this


I agree Hamas made their bed... They shouldn't cry about how it sleeps.
Click to expand...

The Israeli slaughters of Palestinians and others in Gaza predate Hamas. Unfortunately , you have to deal with this fact
 
oneworld2 said:
The suppression , occupation and state violence against the Palestinians predates even Hamas by some distance

Israel attacked Gaza and violated , including such as murder and torture/imprisonment, a large swathe of the population there when it also attacked Egypt in 1956. That's before the blockade too

The slaughtered a load more in 1967 when the brutal repressive occupation started. That was before the blockade




They are not permitted to stop that as the occupying power. Yes it's still under effective control by Israel so the charge of an occupation from without has validity and many groups/people recognize this




The Israeli slaughters of Palestinians and others in Gaza predate Hamas. Unfortunately , you have to deal with this fact
Click to expand...

What you blithely ignore is the fact Israel gave up land to the Palestinians and immediately they began to use it as a launching point for tens of thousands of attacks...

Israel gave up land for peace and instead got war... Period.

Are they stopping all humanitarian supplies?

Yes or no?

Here is a CLUE. Many of the 122MM Soviet bloc rockets were imported. They came from somewhere other than Gaza.. A no orchard in Gaza grows Mortar rounds.. Maybe those are some of the reasons for a blockade...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom