• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

30 Years ago in China

TheParser

DP Veteran
Joined
Jul 12, 2018
Messages
15,613
Reaction score
8,013
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Moderate
I have been waiting for someone else to discuss this (and for someone who knows how to post images or even videos).

But -- to the best of my knowledge -- no other member has mentioned it: 30 years ago occurred the Tiananmen Square massacre.

Students in Beijing (and in other cities) were demanding a little more democracy.

The old men who ruled China (with a few notable exceptions) were afraid of losing power (and maybe even being arrested).

So they brought in the soldiers (who may have been envious of the university-educated students).

The soldiers killed hundreds or thousands in Beijing.

No one knows.

The massacre is a taboo in China.

But for some strange reason, the Chinese government decided to mention it this year. As you can imagine, the spokesperson justified the crackdown.

Perhaps the most famous photograph is that of a young man who persuaded a file of tanks to stop simply by standing in front of the lead tank.

Nobody knows what happened to him.

I'm old enough to remember how CNN's live feed from Beijing was suddenly cut by the censors. (To think of how low CNN has fallen during the last two years makes me sick.)

Let's all hope that someday the Chinese government will apologize for the massacre and give the people a little more participation in the affairs of their country.
 
Last edited:
I have been waiting for someone else to discuss this (and for someone who knows how to post images or even videos).

But -- to the best of my knowledge -- no other member has mentioned it: 30 years ago occurred the Tiananmen Square massacre.

Students in Beijing (and in other cities) were demanding a little more democracy.

The old men who ruled China (with a few notable exceptions) were afraid of losing power (and maybe even being arrested).

So they brought in the soldiers (who may have been envious of the university-educated students).

The soldiers killed hundreds or thousands in Beijing.

No one knows.

The massacre is a taboo in China.

But for some strange reason, the Chinese government decided to mention it this year. As you can imagine, the spokesperson justified the crackdown.

Perhaps the most famous photograph is that of a young man who persuaded a file of tanks to stop simply by standing in front of the lead tank.

Nobody knows what happened to him.

I'm old enough to remember how CNN's live feed from Beijing was suddenly cut by the censors. (To think of how low CNN has fallen during the last two years makes me sick.)

Let's all hope that someday the Chinese government will apologize for the massacre and give the people a little more participation in the affairs of their country.

WAPO had a good article this morning. If you are caught speaking of the event, chances are good that bad things will follow;

https://www.washingtonpost.com/worl...119780-7708-11e9-a7bf-c8a43b84ee31_story.html
 
Too many people, both economically and by military, are in on the aristocracy and governance of China. Because of that we have little hope for any real change anytime soon, this is amplified by most western nations turning a blind eye to the matter of what China has become both socially and economically so long as there was benefit to aristocracy in these western nations via trade.

Justification for continuance of this model of dominance and control over the populace, or even the government mentioning the events of Tiananmen Square, is no different than any other nation that leans authoritarian.

In the saddest of terms, any nation that trades with China empowered what we see today.
 
If anyone wants an in-depth article about the massacre, there's an article entitled "China's 'Black Week-end' " by Ian Johnson in the June 27, 2019, print issue of The New York Review of Books. (I assume it's available online.)


*****



I will cite just two points from the article.


1. The villain of the massacre was Deng Xiaoping.


2. Some "experts" believe that the massacre was the beginning of the end of the Chinese (so-called) Communist Party's rule. Of course, no one knows when it will fall, but it eventually will -- just as the USSR fell.


a. Let's hope that they are right.
 
Back
Top Bottom