- Joined
- Jul 14, 2012
- Messages
- 16,516
- Reaction score
- 8,229
- Location
- Montreal, QC
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Liberal
In WW I MacArthur was awarded the Silver Star seven times. Patton said MacArthur was "the bravest man I ever met." It was when MacArthur was promoted to brig. gen. As reform superintendent of West Point where MacArthur had graduated first in his class he prepared the officer corps for the mechanized, airborne and tank warfare of WW II in Europe. Legend had it MacArthur personally shot the Army's last horse.
In the Pacific in WW II for every combatant who died under MacArthur's command 7 Japanese combatants died.
As military governor of Japan MacArthur shipped in supplies from allied forces to prevent a post war famine. MacArthur oversaw the Japan post war Constitution by which democracy was established and women got the franchise. MacArthur assumed his duty as a mission.
At Inchon MacArthur had air superiority while the NK generals positioned their forces everywhere but Inchon. When you look at the list of alternative sites prepared by MacArthur's staff the NK generals had established defenses at each one, except Inchon. He made the 1st Marine Division lead in the Inchon successful order of battle which stopped Potus Truman in his tracks trying to incorporate USMC into the Army. The Navy's success at Inchon also arrested Truman's trying to fold up the WW II Navy and its aircraft carriers in particular. While Inchon did not defeat the NK Army it did relieve US and SK forces encircled at Busan and it liberated SK.
MacArthur's reforms at USMA focused on the following questions among others that led to the Army's Louisiana Maneuvers of 1940-41:
Just because more Japanese died than Americans does not mean that his plan was not wholly unnecessary. Every American who died in the Philippines campaign was an unnecessary death, the whole campaign was solely to settle MacArthur's personal score. It was clear that the Navy's plan was better, and involved a much smaller human cost.
Then in the Korean War his decisions heavily contributed to the Chinese joining the war, if they didn't we would probably have no North Korea today.
From your post it sounds like he was a much better administrator than general.