• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

why czechs dont speak german, how soon Will Belarusian do the same with mongol juchi language (Musco

Litwin

Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
Sep 2, 2017
Messages
33,607
Reaction score
5,193
Location
GDL/Sweden
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Centrist
why czechs dont speak german, how soon Will Belarusian do the same with mongol juchi language (Muscovite ) . yes, i know that situation with Belarus language in Belarus is much better than czechs have had 100 years ago. but still how soon Will Belarusian do the same with mongol juchi language (Muscovite )

"The act of building puppets has long been a form of protest for the Czech people. Seventeenth-Century wood-carvers, who were more versed in sculpting Baroque seats for churches than human facsimiles, started making puppets for the actors of Bohemia soon after Ferdinand II came to power, as puppets were the only remaining entities that had the right to speak Czech in public places. While the rest of the country and its people adhered to the newly imposed German language, wandering actors and puppet-masters spoke through the puppets in their native Slavic tongue.

It might seem unlikely that a few hundred puppets and puppet-masters could safeguard a language, especially through a loophole, but the people’s last remaining legacy to their past was tied to the puppet’s strings." BBC - Travel - Why Czechs don?t speak German
 
why czechs dont speak german, how soon Will Belarusian do the same with mongol juchi language (Muscovite ) . yes, i know that situation with Belarus language in Belarus is much better than czechs have had 100 years ago. but still how soon Will Belarusian do the same with mongol juchi language (Muscovite )

Many Native American languages have all but disappeared due to the influence of English, but who really cares? A language is just a language.
 
Many Native American languages have all but disappeared due to the influence of English, but who really cares? A language is just a language.

No, that was because we killed them in large numbers then drove the rest from their land onto reservations of our choosing. This wasn't some natural progression of English just being influential, it was forced on the continent with bloodshed.

As usual, you are completely and totally incapable of commenting on the actual topic of the thread instead of inserting unrelated dumbass comments.
 
Many Native American languages have all but disappeared due to the influence of English, but who really cares? A language is just a language.

Language is culture and history. Just ask the Quebecois.
 
No, that was because we killed them in large numbers then drove the rest from their land onto reservations of our choosing. This wasn't some natural progression of English just being influential, it was forced on the continent with bloodshed.

We still have many, many Native Americans, and the young ones aren't learning the old languages.

That's called social progress.

The Czech retained their language, except the ones who moved here -- and they, too have lost it.

Language doesn't mean much anyway.
 
why czechs dont speak german, how soon Will Belarusian do the same with mongol juchi language (Muscovite ) . yes, i know that situation with Belarus language in Belarus is much better than czechs have had 100 years ago. but still how soon Will Belarusian do the same with mongol juchi language (Muscovite )

"The act of building puppets has long been a form of protest for the Czech people. Seventeenth-Century wood-carvers, who were more versed in sculpting Baroque seats for churches than human facsimiles, started making puppets for the actors of Bohemia soon after Ferdinand II came to power, as puppets were the only remaining entities that had the right to speak Czech in public places. While the rest of the country and its people adhered to the newly imposed German language, wandering actors and puppet-masters spoke through the puppets in their native Slavic tongue.

It might seem unlikely that a few hundred puppets and puppet-masters could safeguard a language, especially through a loophole, but the people’s last remaining legacy to their past was tied to the puppet’s strings." BBC - Travel - Why Czechs don?t speak German

Why safeguard a language? Belarus ukraine etc all use languages similar to the russsian language, all those languages derived from kyevin rus in ukraine and their language differences are results of different dialects of the same language, or in ukraines case western ukraine had been subject to polish and lithuanian rule in the past, both those languages having an effect on their own language.

Most those languages in the eastern block either originate from ukraine or from the urals, and their written language derives from cryptic greek which was a more modern form of ancient greek, cyrulic was actually a written form made so that greek could be transformed for the masses and especially slavic nations.


Either way you are calling for nations to abandon tradition going back a 1000 years, I doubt that will happen, though some people are so opposed to anything russia they would cut off their nose to spite their face.
 
Many Native American languages have all but disappeared due to the influence of English, but who really cares? A language is just a language.

how can you compere the language of democracy and progress with language (Muscovite version of old Bulgarian ) of prostitutes, fascists, pogromists, criminals , losers, terrorists the worst tyrants out there ?
 
We still have many, many Native Americans, and the young ones aren't learning the old languages.

That's called social progress.

The Czech retained their language, except the ones who moved here -- and they, too have lost it.

Language doesn't mean much anyway.

Native american language in this thread is comparing apples to oranges, it is a far cry from english, while russia belarus and ukraine can mostly understand each others native languages, as they are seperate dialects of the original slavic used in ukraine during christianization of the east. A belarus speaker a russian speaker and a ukrainian speaker would not be much different from a british speaker, a northern us speak, a southern us speaker and an austrailian talking in the same room, they all use the same base language with different dialects, and for the most part can undertsand eachother, while native american languages for the most part can be understood among other native speakers of different tribes due to similarity, is miles off from english.
 
Why safeguard a language? Belarus ukraine etc all use languages similar to the russsian language, all those languages derived from kyevin rus in ukraine and their language differences are results of different dialects of the same language, or in ukraines case western ukraine had been subject to polish and lithuanian rule in the past, both those languages having an effect on their own language.

Most those languages in the eastern block either originate from ukraine or from the urals, and their written language derives from cryptic greek which was a more modern form of ancient greek, cyrulic was actually a written form made so that greek could be transformed for the masses and especially slavic nations.


Either way you are calling for nations to abandon tradition going back a 1000 years, I doubt that will happen, though some people are so opposed to anything russia they would cut off their nose to spite their face.
you putlerist are 100% wrong as usual , Belarusian langue was language not just GDL but diplomacy in region , meanwhile Muscovite got their language only in 19c. before that they have used different forms of old Bulgarian. in eastern Europe Muscovite langue is language of war, occupation, degradation and prostitution . here is some information for you

"Russification (Russian: Русификация), or Russianization, is a form of cultural assimilation process during which non-Russian communities, voluntarily or not, give up their culture and language in favor of the Russian one.

In a historical sense, the term refers to both official and unofficial policies of Imperial Russia and the Soviet Union with respect to their national constituents and to national minorities in Russia, aimed at Russian domination.

The major areas of Russification are politics and culture. In politics, an element of Russification is assigning Russian nationals to leading administrative positions in national institutions. In culture, Russification primarily amounts to domination of the Russian language in official business and strong influence of the Russian language on national idioms. The shifts in demographics in favour of the ethnic Russian population are sometimes considered as a form of Russification as well.

Analytically, it is helpful to distinguish Russification, as a process of changing one's ethnic self-label or identity from a non-Russian ethnonym to Russian, from Russianization, the spread of the Russian language, culture, and people into non-Russian cultures and regions, distinct also from Sovietization or the imposition of institutional forms established by the Communist Party of the Soviet Union throughout the territory ruled by that party.[2] In this sense, although Russification is usually conflated across Russification, Russianization, and Russian-led Sovietization, each can be considered a distinct process. Russianization and Sovietization, for example, did not automatically lead to Russification – change in language or self-identity of non-Russian peoples to being Russian. Thus, despite long exposure to the Russian language and culture, as well as to Sovietization, at the end of the Soviet era non-Russians were on the verge of becoming a majority of the population in the Soviet Union.[3]
....
 
In 19th century the Russian Empire strove to replace[citation needed] the Ukrainian, Polish, Lithuanian, and Belarusian languages and dialects by Russian in those areas, which were annexed by the Russian Empire after the Partitions of Poland (1772–1795) and the Congress of Vienna (1815). Imperial Russia faced a crucial critical cultural situation by 1815:
....
there more literate Poles than Russians, more people within it could read and write Polish than Russian. The third largest city, Wilno, was entirely Polish in character and its university was the best in the Empire.[11]

Russification in Congress Poland intensified after the November Uprising of 1831, and in particular after the January Uprising of 1863.[12] In 1864 the Polish and Belarusian languages were banned in public places; in the 1880s Polish was banned in schools, on school grounds and in the offices of Congress Poland. Research and teaching of the Polish language, of Polish history or of Catholicism were forbidden. Illiteracy rose as Poles refused to learn Russian. Students were beaten for resisting Russification.[13] ...
Starting in the 1840s Russia considered introducing Cyrillic script for spelling the Polish language, with the first school books printed in the 1860s; these attempts failed.[15

....

A similar development took place in Lithuania.[12] Its Governor General, Mikhail Muravyov (in office 1863-1865), prohibited the public use of spoken Polish and Lithuanian and closed Polish and Lithuanian schools; teachers from other parts of Russia who did not speak these languages were moved in to teach pupils. Muravyov also banned the use of Latin and Gothic scripts in publishing. He was reported as saying, "What the Russian bayonet didn't accomplish, the Russian school will." ("Что не додѣлалъ русскій штыкъ – додѣлаетъ русская школа.") This ban, lifted only in 1904, was disregarded by the Knygnešiai, the Lithuanian book smugglers, who brought Lithuanian publications printed in the Latin alphabet, the historic orthography of the Lithuanian language, from Lithuania Minor (part of East Prussia) and from the United States into the Lithuanian-speaking areas of Imperial Russia. The knygnešiai came to symbolise the resistance of Lithuanians against Russification.

The Russification campaign also promoted the Russian Orthodox faith over Catholicism. The measures used included closing down Catholic monasteries, officially banning the building of new churches and giving many of the old ones to the Russian Orthodox church, banning Catholic schools and establishing state schools which taught only the Orthodox religion, requiring Catholic priests to preach only officially approved sermons, requiring that Catholics who married members of the Orthodox church convert, requiring Catholic nobles to pay an additional tax in the amount of 10% of their profits, limiting the amount of land a Catholic peasant could own, and switching from the Gregorian calendar (used by Catholics) to the Julian one (used by members of the Orthodox church).

Most of the Orthodox Church property in the 19th century Congress Poland was acquired at the expense of the Catholic Church of both rites (Roman and Greek Catholic).[16]

After the uprising,[which?] many manors and great chunks of land were confiscated from nobles of Polish and Lithuanian descent who were accused of helping the uprising; these properties were later given or sold to Russian nobles. Villages where supporters of the uprising lived were repopulated by ethnic Russians. Vilnius University, where the language of instruction had been Polish rather than Russian, closed in 1832. Lithuanians and Poles were banned from holding any public jobs (including professional positions, such as teachers and doctors) in Lithuania; this forced educated Lithuanians to move to other parts of the Russian Empire. The old legal code was dismantled and a new one based on the Russian code and written in the Russian language was enacted; Russian became the only administrative and juridical language in the area. Most of these actions ended at the beginning of the Russo-Japanese War of 1904-1905, but others took longer to be reversed; Vilnius University re-opened only after Russia had lost control of the city in 1919.
Ukraine

Russian and Soviet authorities conducted policies of Russification of Ukraine from 1709 to 1991, interrupted by the Korenizatsiya policy in the 1920s. Since then, the Ukrainian government has implemented policies in order to decrease the use of Russian and favour Ukrainian, a process labelled Ukrainization.

A number of Ukrainian activists committed suicide in protest against Russification, among whom are Oleksa Hirnyk and Vasyl Makukh.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russification
 
you putlerist are 100% wrong as usual , Belarusian langue was language not just GDL but diplomacy in region , meanwhile Muscovite got their language only in 19c. before that they have used different forms of old Bulgarian. in eastern Europe Muscovite langue is language of war, occupation, degradation and prostitution . here is some information for you

"Russification (Russian: Русификация), or Russianization, is a form of cultural assimilation process during which non-Russian communities, voluntarily or not, give up their culture and language in favor of the Russian one.

In a historical sense, the term refers to both official and unofficial policies of Imperial Russia and the Soviet Union with respect to their national constituents and to national minorities in Russia, aimed at Russian domination.

The major areas of Russification are politics and culture. In politics, an element of Russification is assigning Russian nationals to leading administrative positions in national institutions. In culture, Russification primarily amounts to domination of the Russian language in official business and strong influence of the Russian language on national idioms. The shifts in demographics in favour of the ethnic Russian population are sometimes considered as a form of Russification as well.

Analytically, it is helpful to distinguish Russification, as a process of changing one's ethnic self-label or identity from a non-Russian ethnonym to Russian, from Russianization, the spread of the Russian language, culture, and people into non-Russian cultures and regions, distinct also from Sovietization or the imposition of institutional forms established by the Communist Party of the Soviet Union throughout the territory ruled by that party.[2] In this sense, although Russification is usually conflated across Russification, Russianization, and Russian-led Sovietization, each can be considered a distinct process. Russianization and Sovietization, for example, did not automatically lead to Russification – change in language or self-identity of non-Russian peoples to being Russian. Thus, despite long exposure to the Russian language and culture, as well as to Sovietization, at the end of the Soviet era non-Russians were on the verge of becoming a majority of the population in the Soviet Union.[3]
....

So from reading your post, you are either completely ignorant of history of that region, so ingrained in anti russia propoganda you will refuse anything that defies your logic, or finally you are upset the polinization and lithuization of belarus was not permanent and that belarus retained it's slavic nature from long before lithuania ruled over it.


Oh heck let me put it simply, you are angry lithuania does not have control over wester ukraine and belarus like they did centuries ago, and could not erase the slavic history there like you wished.


Oh wait let me predict your response, you will post an image of nigeria in snow that has been for too long debunked.
 
Belarusian is the second most melodic langue in the world,



 
No, that was because we killed them in large numbers then drove the rest from their land onto reservations of our choosing. This wasn't some natural progression of English just being influential, it was forced on the continent with bloodshed.

As usual, you are completely and totally incapable of commenting on the actual topic of the thread instead of inserting unrelated dumbass comments.

Stone Age people get the short end of the stick. We having said that we created a country out of an underutilized resource.

Do you wish you and America didn’t exist?
 
So from reading your post, you are either completely ignorant of history of that region, so ingrained in anti russia propoganda you will refuse anything that defies your logic, or finally you are upset the polinization and lithuization of belarus was not permanent and that belarus retained it's slavic nature from long before lithuania ruled over it.


Oh heck let me put it simply, you are angry lithuania does not have control over wester ukraine and belarus like they did centuries ago, and could not erase the slavic history there like you wished.


Oh wait let me predict your response, you will post an image of nigeria in snow that has been for too long debunked.

Urban Dictionary: Putlerist
https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Putlerist

Apr 2, 2015 - Putlerist: A term used to describe followers of Putin, who is comparable to Hiterisim. Putlerisim denotes Russia's radical climb to fascism with ...

ps and no, you Muscovy is not Nigeria in snow, its Somalia in snow already . in the hands on warlords , oligarchs, criminal organizations , a good example - Chechnya...
 
Urban Dictionary: Putlerist
https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Putlerist

Apr 2, 2015 - Putlerist: A term used to describe followers of Putin, who is comparable to Hiterisim. Putlerisim denotes Russia's radical climb to fascism with ...

ps and no, you Muscovy is not Nigeria in snow, its Somalia in snow already . in the hands on warlords , oligarchs, criminal organizations , a good example - Chechnya...

So moscow is somalia in snow, care to back that up because your nigeria in snow has long been debunked, you seem to be doubling down on failure at this point hoping your readers have the iq of a potato and could not ever use google.


How cute also the putlerist meme, because god forbid you actually back up any of the crap you spew and instead go straight for ad hominems, I know that entire region of the world is not stupid, however you do seem to feed the stereotype by posting memes and running away from backing up your own words.
 
how can you compere the language of democracy and progress with language (Muscovite version of old Bulgarian ) of prostitutes, fascists, pogromists, criminals , losers, terrorists the worst tyrants out there ?

The "language of democracy and progress?" What world do you live in? Those Native American children were forcefully taken away from their parents and forced to learn English -- as our forebears tried to breed the "savage" out of them.
 
The "language of democracy and progress?" What world do you live in? Those Native American children were forcefully taken away from their parents and forced to learn English -- as our forebears tried to breed the "savage" out of them.

Can you spell out what your are trying to say here?
 
Can you spell out what your are trying to say here?

I'm saying that forcing the Native American children to learn our ways and our language is no different from the Germans nearly forcing the Czechs to learn their language.
 
The "language of democracy and progress?" What world do you live in? Those Native American children were forcefully taken away from their parents and forced to learn English -- as our forebears tried to breed the "savage" out of them.

stone age people have had 0 chance in 19c, dont you think so? new try compere life of Native American children with life of Native children in Muscovy ...

dscn0133-460x345.jpg


yakutiya_01.jpg


but dont worry soon they will be free from mongol juchi occupation

1493303119151488947.jpg


https://pikabu.ru/story/tanets_yakutskikh_voinov_5011578
 
Back
Top Bottom