ChrisABrown
Active member
- Joined
- Oct 23, 2017
- Messages
- 254
- Reaction score
- 19
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Other
Re: How the 1st AMD. & the 2nd AMD are related and the 1st needed to defend the 2nd
No, that's the question you want to answer, which was the basis for the question I need answered because it defends the constitution. The question I need to ask frames the constitutional intent properly for the 9th because it upholds and defends the constitution. Or, the constitution, enables us to defend itself IF we use it properly.
The question was did the Ninth Amendment protect individual unenumerated rights or was it a centric protection of state's rights and powers as a rule of construction limiting the broad interpretation of Article 1, Section 8 congressional powers via the necessary and proper clause.
No, that's the question you want to answer, which was the basis for the question I need answered because it defends the constitution. The question I need to ask frames the constitutional intent properly for the 9th because it upholds and defends the constitution. Or, the constitution, enables us to defend itself IF we use it properly.
If the framers intended for the people to alter or abolish government destructive to unalienable rights, what did they intend serve the purpose of enabling the unity in the people required to actually alter or abolish a government powerful enough to be destructive to unalienable rights?