• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Open Carry: How do you feel about it?

blackjack50

Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
Sep 14, 2011
Messages
26,629
Reaction score
6,661
Location
Florida
Gender
Undisclosed
Political Leaning
Conservative
This is something I'm not too sure about. I know many people favor this. In fact...historically speaking the carrying of arms openly was seen as a sign of being above board, and carrying concealed was for criminals. But now? I think the views have changed. So what restrictions on open carry would you put in place? If at all? Do you prefer open carry? Do you open carry? That kind of thing.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
This is something I'm not too sure about. I know many people favor this. In fact...historically speaking the carrying of arms openly was seen as a sign of being above board, and carrying concealed was for criminals. But now? I think the views have changed. So what restrictions on open carry would you put in place? If at all? Do you prefer open carry? Do you open carry? That kind of thing.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Not a fan of long arm open carry. I live in Colorado and I've actually never seen anyone openly carrying a long arm. I do understand that the folks in Texas were doing so as a matter of protest against laws prohibiting open carry of handguns, and I can see their point.

I've only seen open carry of handguns three times in 17 years here outside of hunting. I don't open carry, obviously, but it doesn't bother me. It's legal here outside of Denver and a few liberal enclaves.
 
Its a bad idea IMO compared to carrying concealed.

Some people are put off by the sight of a gun.
In a bad situation people will look to you to be the hero.
In a bad situation criminals will target you first.
"When cops are looking for a guy with a gun, don't be one." - Massad Ayoob.
 
I don't care for it unless you are out in the boonies. It's just someone trying to make a statement.

The main reason is non gun people get nervous, so give them a break. Concealed carry may be just a citizen or an undercover cop. Either way competence and purpose is implied.
 
Its a bad idea IMO compared to carrying concealed.

Some people are put off by the sight of a gun.
In a bad situation people will look to you to be the hero.
In a bad situation criminals will target you first.
"When cops are looking for a guy with a gun, don't be one." - Massad Ayoob.

Well said. I'm always concerned about others being stupid, thus I would never really want to open carry.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I don't care for it unless you are out in the boonies. It's just someone trying to make a statement.

The main reason is non gun people get nervous, so give them a break. Concealed carry may be just a citizen or an undercover cop. Either way competence and purpose is implied.

I agree with this. Open carry in populated areas makes people, including those who are otherwise sympathetic to firearms owners, nervous. Concealed carry is the way to go.
 
Not a fan of long arm open carry. I live in Colorado and I've actually never seen anyone openly carrying a long arm. I do understand that the folks in Texas were doing so as a matter of protest against laws prohibiting open carry of handguns, and I can see their point.

I've only seen open carry of handguns three times in 17 years here outside of hunting. I don't open carry, obviously, but it doesn't bother me. It's legal here outside of Denver and a few liberal enclaves.

See way out in the boondocks or in a small town? It makes sense to have open carry of handguns or even long arms. It depends on the work you are doing, then you consider the animal problems. I wish I could open carry here while hiking. Pigs are actually a real concern. My cousin just had to kill one the other day when it attacked his dog (well dog lost his **** barking at it and cousin put the hog down with his 9mm after it turned on the dog).


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I don't care for it unless you are out in the boonies. It's just someone trying to make a statement.

The main reason is non gun people get nervous, so give them a break. Concealed carry may be just a citizen or an undercover cop. Either way competence and purpose is implied.

You mean for concealed carry?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
This is something I'm not too sure about. I know many people favor this. In fact...historically speaking the carrying of arms openly was seen as a sign of being above board, and carrying concealed was for criminals. But now? I think the views have changed. So what restrictions on open carry would you put in place? If at all? Do you prefer open carry? Do you open carry? That kind of thing.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I believe that both open and concealed carry should be considered standard and require no permit.
 
See way out in the boondocks or in a small town? It makes sense to have open carry of handguns or even long arms. It depends on the work you are doing, then you consider the animal problems. I wish I could open carry here while hiking. Pigs are actually a real concern. My cousin just had to kill one the other day when it attacked his dog (well dog lost his **** barking at it and cousin put the hog down with his 9mm after it turned on the dog).


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

There's a holster on my hunting pack for my SP-101, but for hiking locally I carry it concealed. Even in small towns I haven't seen open carry outside of hunting season.
 
The 2A states that the right of the people to keep (have?) and bear (carry?) arms shall not be infringed. Pretending that means laws requiring taking classes, passing tests and paying fees in order to carry a hand gun (in any manner) are just peachy if done at the state level is unconstitutional.

Concealed carry has some advantages but also limits the type of gun and clothing required to do so. I am pro-choice on the manner of carry that one chooses.
 
Its a bad idea IMO compared to carrying concealed.

Some people are put off by the sight of a gun.
In a bad situation people will look to you to be the hero.
In a bad situation criminals will target you first.
"When cops are looking for a guy with a gun, don't be one." - Massad Ayoob.

Yup. Why open carry when you can get one of these? :lol:

 
Last edited:
I think open carry should be legal everywhere concealed carry is. That said, if you open carry you look like a douche. The only places I would ever consider open carrying is on my property or perhaps out in the woods hiking. Never in the city around people I don't know. Douchiness aside, it makes you stand out as a target. It is like counting your cash in public. "Hey, if you want to steal something of value I am the guy you want to ambush".
 
Keep them guessing. I don't want to open carry because I don't see the need to intimidate, but I like the option of having a little something when I need it.
 
There's a holster on my hunting pack for my SP-101, but for hiking locally I carry it concealed. Even in small towns I haven't seen open carry outside of hunting season.

Well Florida doesn't have it, but I have seen open carry in some other states. And only in small towns then.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
The 2A states that the right of the people to keep (have?) and bear (carry?) arms shall not be infringed. Pretending that means laws requiring taking classes, passing tests and paying fees in order to carry a hand gun (in any manner) are just peachy if done at the state level is unconstitutional.

Concealed carry has some advantages but also limits the type of gun and clothing required to do so. I am pro-choice on the manner of carry that one chooses.


If you find concealed carry limiting as far as fashion...you don't have the right belt and holster ;)

I carry in shorts and a tshirt.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
No problem with open carry, as long as the applicable restrictions are observed.
 
This is something I'm not too sure about. I know many people favor this. In fact...historically speaking the carrying of arms openly was seen as a sign of being above board, and carrying concealed was for criminals. But now? I think the views have changed. So what restrictions on open carry would you put in place? If at all? Do you prefer open carry? Do you open carry? That kind of thing.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I prefer concealed carry over open carry.
 
This is something I'm not too sure about. I know many people favor this. In fact...historically speaking the carrying of arms openly was seen as a sign of being above board, and carrying concealed was for criminals. But now? I think the views have changed. So what restrictions on open carry would you put in place? If at all? Do you prefer open carry? Do you open carry? That kind of thing.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Have no problem with it, have done it many times, even in downtown Seattle I'm yet to be hassled for it.

There are some places I must open carry because my WA CPL isn't valid, like Nebraska, Oregon, Wyoming etc I also visit a handful of rural areas in Northern California where open carry is legal and I do open carry in those places
Of course there is a difference between wearing a holstered pistol and taking an AR-15 in a tactical rig to the mall or an elementary school just to stir the pot
 
Last edited:
Have no problem with it, have done it many times, even in downtown Seattle I'm yet to be hassled for it.

Of course there is a difference between wearing a holstered pistol and taking an AR-15 in a tactical rig to the mall or an elementary school just to stir the pot

That is my big protest with open carriers. Not your audience. Don't cause a fuss. If you want to show us as the good guys...open carry a handgun in a holster. People will stare, but they won't lose their ****.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
That is my big protest with open carriers. Not your audience. Don't cause a fuss. If you want to show us as the good guys...open carry a handgun in a holster. People will stare, but they won't lose their ****.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I'm just waiting for one of the black rifle open carriers to go to mall for a protest and get shot by a CCW holder or an off duty cop who mistakes them for an active shooter
 
I'm just waiting for one of the black rifle open carriers to go to mall for a protest and get shot by a CCW holder or an off duty cop who mistakes them for an active shooter

Yep. A real concern now.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
This is something I'm not too sure about. I know many people favor this. In fact...historically speaking the carrying of arms openly was seen as a sign of being above board, and carrying concealed was for criminals. But now? I think the views have changed. So what restrictions on open carry would you put in place? If at all? Do you prefer open carry? Do you open carry? That kind of thing.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk



I'm not against it, but I don't think society is most states is ready to cope with it comfortably. Also, I personally prefer to carry concealed for both tactical advantages and social reasons.


Ideally, I'd prefer that it were legal. However, I think it is one thing to walk down a country road carrying a rifle or shotgun, and quite a different thing to walk into Starbucks or Wal-mart with an AR on a single point sling in tactical low-ready position.

For the most part, I think the latter is showboating and probably does more harm than good to the cause.


I've seen people open-carry in my home state, even though strictly speaking its legality is dubious at best. A holstered sidearm on someone's belt in the Piggly-Wiggly doesn't bother me... odds are very strong if they were planning to make trouble it would either be in-hand or concealed.

A guy walking down a country road with a shotgun or hunting rifle is not an issue to me.

But the guy who totes his AR or AK to go shopping or get coffee.... that's kind of an oddity. Even to me, and I'm as comfortable with guns around as most people are about cell phones. Long guns are not exactly convenient to tote around, for one. I wouldn't normally be carrying one on my person unless I expected to use it for something.

They're conspicuous and draw attention.... not something I want to do either.

If slung in a non-threatening manner they're not so easy to get quickly into action and are typically less useful in close quarters, which describes most self-defense situations.


Personally I don't see much point in toting one around, unless there's some kind of escalated threat situation going on.


Not real keen on wearing a handgun openly visible on the belt either. I did so when I was a cop and on duty... and wore it in a retention holster, and tended to keep my forearm over it when in a crowd, constantly aware of the risk of someone trying to snatch it (retention holsters are far from foolproof as we learned in instructional videos).

I much prefer concealed. It avoids social awkwardness among people who are made uncomfortable by firearms, but more importantly it gives you tactical advantages if something actually happens, as your status as an armed citizen is not immediately obvious (if you're doing it right).


Open carry probably is a deterrent, but it is also a "shoot me first" sign for bad guys who aren't going to be easily deterred.



EVEN SO, yes I do support legal open carry.



I just don't plan to practice it myself much, and would wish those who do would exercise some basic discretion about where, when and how they do so.
 
I'm not against it, but I don't think society is most states is ready to cope with it comfortably. Also, I personally prefer to carry concealed for both tactical advantages and social reasons.


Ideally, I'd prefer that it were legal. However, I think it is one thing to walk down a country road carrying a rifle or shotgun, and quite a different thing to walk into Starbucks or Wal-mart with an AR on a single point sling in tactical low-ready position.

For the most part, I think the latter is showboating and probably does more harm than good to the cause.


I've seen people open-carry in my home state, even though strictly speaking its legality is dubious at best. A holstered sidearm on someone's belt in the Piggly-Wiggly doesn't bother me... odds are very strong if they were planning to make trouble it would either be in-hand or concealed.

A guy walking down a country road with a shotgun or hunting rifle is not an issue to me.

But the guy who totes his AR or AK to go shopping or get coffee.... that's kind of an oddity. Even to me, and I'm as comfortable with guns around as most people are about cell phones. Long guns are not exactly convenient to tote around, for one. I wouldn't normally be carrying one on my person unless I expected to use it for something.

They're conspicuous and draw attention.... not something I want to do either.

If slung in a non-threatening manner they're not so easy to get quickly into action and are typically less useful in close quarters, which describes most self-defense situations.


Personally I don't see much point in toting one around, unless there's some kind of escalated threat situation going on.


Not real keen on wearing a handgun openly visible on the belt either. I did so when I was a cop and on duty... and wore it in a retention holster, and tended to keep my forearm over it when in a crowd, constantly aware of the risk of someone trying to snatch it (retention holsters are far from foolproof as we learned in instructional videos).

I much prefer concealed. It avoids social awkwardness among people who are made uncomfortable by firearms, but more importantly it gives you tactical advantages if something actually happens, as your status as an armed citizen is not immediately obvious (if you're doing it right).


Open carry probably is a deterrent, but it is also a "shoot me first" sign for bad guys who aren't going to be easily deterred.



EVEN SO, yes I do support legal open carry.



I just don't plan to practice it myself much, and would wish those who do would exercise some basic discretion about where, when and how they do so.

Well well said.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I carry but I have no desire to intimidate or upset anyone.

I would prefer that people view me as a polite harmless old man with a bad limp.

I do realize the limp will make a predator view me as a weak member of the herd. That's why I carry. I hope and pray I never have to use my weapon to defend myself but if I am threatened by a person who wishes to put me in a hospital for an extended stay or six feet under and has the capacity to do so — then I plan to do my best to stop his attack.
 
Back
Top Bottom