- Joined
- Dec 9, 2009
- Messages
- 134,496
- Reaction score
- 14,621
- Location
- Houston, TX
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Conservative
The first fallacy in this post is "People keeping more of what they earn". The wealthy don't "earn" their money. They have workers who earn their money for them. The Waltons don't even work for Walmart. The most they've ever done is simply sit on the Board of Directors. These people have never worked a day in their lives. They sit back and let the profits of other people's work make them richer and richer, while their workers are dependent on food stamps, MedicAid, and other taxpayer funded income supports.
Only in America do you have "earned income credits" wherein taxpayers are required to supplement the incomes of the employees of the most profitable corporations in America. While the Waltons' fortune now exeeds that of Jeff Bezos and Bill Gates, two men who actually built companies, and created their own wealth, their employees, the people who actually "earn" the money the shareholders are receiving, are still struggling. Conservatives oppose giving workers more money, but cheer tax cuts for the wealthy.
Taxes are your share of the costs of living in a first world country. And the wealthy use more government resources than any other group. They need educated workers - taxes pay for education. Infrastructure - roads, railways, airports and waterways to move goods to market. Intellectual property protections, and courts to enforce property rights. Security and safety to keep you from being robbed or exploited and to protect property rights. Product testing and approval for product safety. And last but certainly not least, a social safety net to protect the poorest and most vulnerable from inevitable periods of contraction in a capitalist economy.
When Ronald Reagan was elected and America became a conservative country, the USA was a world leader in health care, manufacturing, infrastructure, and innovation, and poverty was at its lowest level in history. The working class owned a small percentage of the wealth of the nation, and the middle class a larger share. 40 years of Republican tax policies (three massive tax cuts, 18 years of war and deficit spending, one increase in the minimum wage), and the working class are now dependent on government assistance and the top 10% have seen their income rise by 270%.
This is fiscal insanity. If you aren't paid enough to provide basic living expenses for yourself, you're basically a wage slave. You can't save money, or do anything but watch the profits of your work go to those at the top who are sitting on their asses at home waiting for their dividend cheques.
Not sure what country you live in but you certainly don't understand this one. People don't earn an income because they are rich?? OMG, that one is priceless and totally ignorant of reality.
I gave you a list of the items and what tax funds them, you totally ignored it as you usually do as you are incapable of admitting when wrong. Fiscal insanity is throwing more federal dollars at personal responsibility issues with no accountability. Profit seems to be a dirty word for you so why do you live in this country?
No understanding of risk taking, investment, hard work as apparently all money belongs to the gov't. Still no answer to how people keeping more of what they earn is a gift from the gov't as you don't seem to grasp reality, IT ISN'T the GOVERNMENTS MONEY FIRST. Then there is the wealth argument totally ignoring that wealth continues to grow but I can see from your posts why you aren't participating.
Keep buying what the left tells you and keep letting them make a fool out of you. Waiting for you to explain how 1.66 trillion in Federal Income tax revenue and 160 billion in corporate income tax revenue didn't fund the 1.2 trillion dollar discretionary budget for 2018 and how you can claim revenue is declining?