• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

6 months in, GOP tax bill an utter flop

Rogue Valley

Lead or get out of the way
DP Veteran
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
94,313
Reaction score
82,690
Location
Barsoom
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
6 months in, GOP tax bill an utter flop

90


6/22/18
Six months after President Trump and Republicans in Congress jammed through massive tax cuts mostly for corporations and the wealthy, it has become clear that working families are suffering while billionaire GOP campaign contributors luxuriate in a tax windfall. While stumping for his tax plan, President Trump claimed cutting taxes for big corporations would result in an average pay raise of $4,000 for working families. Well, the tax bill slashed the corporate tax rate by more than 40 percent and handed multinational corporations a $400 billion tax discount on their accumulated offshore profits, but what was the result? Working people are still waiting for their $4,000 raise. Average hourly wages have actually gone down slightly, after adjusting for inflation, since the tax bill passed. So where did all the money go? Corporations are not reinvesting their tax windfall; they are paying that money out in the form of stock buybacks and dividends. Stock buybacks boost stock prices and CEO pay in the short term, making the rich even richer, but most financial analysts say that money could be put to better use investing in the long-term success of the company.

The total cost of the GOP tax boondoggle is $1.9 trillion to $2.3 trillion. Right on cue, Republicans are now trying to push through drastic cuts in Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security and public education to make up for the lost tax revenue. Finally, by weakening a central part of ObamaCare to pay for tax cuts for the rich, the Republican tax law will raise health insurance premiums for working families and cause 3 million people to lose health coverage in the next year. Finally, by weakening a central part of ObamaCare to pay for tax cuts for the rich, the Republican tax law will raise health insurance premiums for working families and cause 3 million people to lose health coverage in the next year. Congress should use the money saved from fixing this terrible tax law to invest in America. The U.S. needs to invest trillions of dollars in our infrastructure to be competitive in the 21st century. Senate Democrats have proposed a good start on what we need to do — $1 trillion for rebuilding and improving our country’s roads, bridges, schools, waterworks, rail systems, electrical grid and more, creating millions of good-paying jobs all along the way. All this could be paid for by repealing the GOP's huge, pointless, job-killing tax breaks for corporations and the wealthy.

The blue above. No citizen either approaching retirement or already there should even consider casting a vote for GOP Senators and/or Representatives come November 6.

These Republicans are looking to castrate/eviscerate you. Remember, they don't care about you, they're all millionaires who will enjoy a generous government pension and high-paying positions with lobbyist firms.

Related: The Top Ten Fallacies About the New Trump-GOP Tax Act
 
People seem to see through it.

The Republican tax law is becoming less popular, not more
It’s been six months since President Donald Trump signed into law the Republican tax cuts. During that time, the measure appears to have become less popular — not more. The GOP’s big 2018 midterms sales pitch isn’t working out exactly how party leaders thought it would.

According to a Monmouth University poll released this week, just 34 percent of Americans said they approve of the Republican tax reform package, compared to 41 percent who disapprove. That’s down from April, when 40 percent of Americans said they approved of the law and 44 percent did not. In January, respondents were evenly split, with 44 percent saying they approved and another 44 percent voicing disapproval of the plan.

Public opinion on the tax law has “never been positive,” said Patrick Murray, director of the Monmouth University Polling Institute, in a statement accompanying the results, “but potentially growing uncertainty about how American taxpayers will be affected does not seem to be helping the GOP’s prospects in November.”

Broadly, most polling shows the tax law is more disliked than liked by Americans. A recent Quinnipiac poll found 39 percent of respondents approve of the legislation and 46 percent disapprove of it. An Economist/YouGov poll found a smaller but still negative margin, with 38 percent approving and 40 percent not.

A RealClearPolitics average of tax law polling indicates that about 36.1 percent of Americans are on board with the tax measure and 43 percent are not, a nearly 7 percentage point difference.
 
6 months in, GOP tax bill an utter flop

90




The blue above. No citizen either approaching retirement or already there should even consider casting a vote for GOP Senators and/or Representatives come November 6.

These Republicans are looking to castrate/eviscerate you. Remember, they don't care about you, they're all millionaires who will enjoy a generous government pension and high-paying positions with lobbyist firms.

Related: The Top Ten Fallacies About the New Trump-GOP Tax Act

Not to mention that inflation thanks to Trump's moronic tariffs is eating more out of people's paychecks than the measly pittance the tax cut gave them.
 
6 months in, GOP tax bill an utter flop

90




The blue above. No citizen either approaching retirement or already there should even consider casting a vote for GOP Senators and/or Representatives come November 6.

These Republicans are looking to castrate/eviscerate you. Remember, they don't care about you, they're all millionaires who will enjoy a generous government pension and high-paying positions with lobbyist firms.

Related: The Top Ten Fallacies About the New Trump-GOP Tax Act

And how does this differentiate them from Democrats? I understand the criticism and I make the same point, but do you think that Democrats don't do the exact same thing?
 
Thanks for the AFL-CIO op-ed. No surprise here whatsoever. Big Labor remains as opposed as ever to people getting more money and cutting out the middle man.
 
And how does this differentiate them from Democrats? I understand the criticism and I make the same point, but do you think that Democrats don't do the exact same thing?

Oh, well, that changes everything. Except that it doesn't.

Democrats, are no angels, however, they would never have passed THAT tax bill. No Democrat president would have approved a 700 billion dollar defense budget. A Democrat president would not have purposely pulled a trade war out of his ass.

And, no, I am not a Democrat.
 
Oh, well, that changes everything. Except that it doesn't.

Democrats, are no angels, however, they would never have passed THAT tax bill. No Democrat president would have approved a 700 billion dollar defense budget.

I really don't see much of a difference. We spent on a ton on defense with Obama.

DoD_Budget_Authority_2015.jpg


It did go down, yes, but let's not act as if Obama was some paragon of fiscal restraint. And again, I'm not even necessarily defending Trump here. That budget was a disaster. I just don't see why this should convince me to vote for Democrats. I still would rather vote for non-establishment conservatives.

A Democrat president would not have purposely pulled a trade war out of his ass.

And, no, I am not a Democrat.

Actually, and I was surprised by this, Schumer is on Trump's side when it comes to going after China.
 
I really don't see much of a difference. We spent on a ton on defense with Obama.

DoD_Budget_Authority_2015.jpg


It did go down, yes, but let's not act as if Obama was some paragon of fiscal restraint. And again, I'm not even necessarily defending Trump here. That budget was a disaster. I just don't see why this should convince me to vote for Democrats. I still would rather vote for non-establishment conservatives.



Actually, and I was surprised by this, Schumer is on Trump's side when it comes to going after China.

Tony I am not a binary political thinker. I'm certainly not selling Obama to you or anyone. I didn't vote for him. I am not a Democrat. I think both parties are anti-American. It is my firm belief that we MUST revamp election financing and greatly shorten the campaign season among other things or this nation will never see democracy again - and it can be argued that we don't have one now.

Schumer is one of my least favorite people in Washington. Trump and apparently Schumer are in-****ing-sane if they want to tackle trade imbalance with China while starting a trade war as well with our allies, while saddling Americans with a godawful, shameful tax cut for the wealthy and while not solving healthcare issue (yes that weren't solved under Obama). Americans are soon to be buried in debt with no way out. Which, by the way, I believe is Washington's intent. It is not my intent and I don't believe it is your intent.
 
Tony I am not a binary political thinker. I'm certainly not selling Obama to you or anyone. I didn't vote for him. I am not a Democrat. I think both parties are anti-American. It is my firm belief that we MUST revamp election financing and greatly shorten the campaign season among other things or this nation will never see democracy again - and it can be argued that we don't have one now.

Schumer is one of my least favorite people in Washington. Trump and apparently Schumer are in-****ing-sane if they want to tackle trade imbalance with China while starting a trade war as well with our allies, while saddling Americans with a godawful, shameful tax cut for the wealthy and while not solving healthcare issue (yes that weren't solved under Obama). Americans are soon to be buried in debt with no way out. Which, by the way, I believe is Washington's intent. It is not my intent and I don't believe it is your intent.
I'm all about strengthening Americans by increasing their wages, dropping their cost of living, and letting them get out of their incredible debts.

Sent from my HTC6545LVW using Tapatalk
 
Not to mention that inflation thanks to Trump's moronic tariffs is eating more out of people's paychecks than the measly pittance the tax cut gave them.

Inflation doesn't work the way you think it does.
 
And how does this differentiate them from Democrats? I understand the criticism and I make the same point, but do you think that Democrats don't do the exact same thing?

No,I don't
 
Thanks for the AFL-CIO op-ed. No surprise here whatsoever. Big Labor remains as opposed as ever to people getting more money and cutting out the middle man.

How much are you getting?
 
Oh, well, that changes everything. Except that it doesn't.

Democrats, are no angels, however, they would never have passed THAT tax bill. No Democrat president would have approved a 700 billion dollar defense budget. A Democrat president would not have purposely pulled a trade war out of his ass.

And, no, I am not a Democrat.

Great post!
 
I really don't see much of a difference. We spent on a ton on defense with Obama.

DoD_Budget_Authority_2015.jpg


It did go down, yes, but let's not act as if Obama was some paragon of fiscal restraint. And again, I'm not even necessarily defending Trump here. That budget was a disaster. I just don't see why this should convince me to vote for Democrats. I still would rather vote for non-establishment conservatives.



Actually, and I was surprised by this, Schumer is on Trump's side when it comes to going after China.

The famous deflect to Obama,to cover Trump 's fat behind!
 
That's why they passed it!
Why be a Billionaire when you could be a Trillionaire!

You mean individuals with the largest tax burden will naturally get the largest tax break?

You don't say...
 
6 months in, GOP tax bill an utter flop

90




The blue above. No citizen either approaching retirement or already there should even consider casting a vote for GOP Senators and/or Representatives come November 6.

These Republicans are looking to castrate/eviscerate you. Remember, they don't care about you, they're all millionaires who will enjoy a generous government pension and high-paying positions with lobbyist firms.

Related: The Top Ten Fallacies About the New Trump-GOP Tax Act

Okay, so am I to believe that the tax bill is considered a flop because the national debt will increase by $1.9 trillion - $2.3 trillion?

Fair, but what if I told you that it doesn't actually matter that the national debt increased because of this? Will you keep the same narrative or will you come up with a different argument?
 
Republican manifesto

So if it's written there and not in my post, why would you attribute those words to my statements??

It's almost as if you don't understand how to make coherent arguments, or something...
 
That's why they passed it!
Why be a Billionaire when you could be a Trillionaire!

that's a lot of money, and i can't wait until it trickles down.
 
6 months in, GOP tax bill an utter flop

90




The blue above. No citizen either approaching retirement or already there should even consider casting a vote for GOP Senators and/or Representatives come November 6.

These Republicans are looking to castrate/eviscerate you. Remember, they don't care about you, they're all millionaires who will enjoy a generous government pension and high-paying positions with lobbyist firms.

Related: The Top Ten Fallacies About the New Trump-GOP Tax Act

But it achieved their true goal, whether or not we figure out we got taken really matters not to them at this point .
 
Back
Top Bottom