• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Governor, my father’s death is on your hands

Rogue Valley

Lead or get out of the way
DP Veteran
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
94,313
Reaction score
82,703
Location
Barsoom
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
Governor, my father’s death is on your hands

dbd21c8a-b354-40f3-bb31-8a53425a9ca0.jpg

By Kristin Urquiza

‘If you don’t have an underlying health condition, it’s safe out there,” Gov. Doug Ducey told Arizonans in late May, hoping to stimulate the economy. Those words were also a death sentence for Dad, a healthy and exuberant 65-year-young man named Mark Anthony Urquiza. He, like so many others, would not have died if American leaders — President Trump and governors like Ducey — hadn’t been so cavalier about pushing consumers to spend money. They have blood on their hands. When a shelter-in-place order took effect in March, both my parents believed in mask-wearing and social distancing. We watched in horror as New York brought in refrigerated trucks and dug mass graves. But by the time Arizona started to reopen on May 15, I couldn’t compete with the message coming out of the White House, projected across cable news and reinforced by Ducey. Dad was a Republican. He watched Fox News, and he had voted for Ducey and Trump. When they told him not to live in fear, that very few people would catch the disease, that its effects weren’t serious, he believed them. “The governor said it was safe,” Dad told me as, for the first time in months, he prepared to go out and meet up with his friends at their favorite karaoke bar. “Why would he say that if it wasn’t?”

A few weeks later, as he was fighting to breathe and terrified that he might die, he told me he felt betrayed. It was one of our final conversations. The next day, he was put on a ventilator. He died five days later, without family, as an ICU nurse held his hand. My father didn’t deserve that ending, and neither did the 152,000 people and counting, that we’ve lost. We got to this crisis because our leaders decided not to lead. The pandemic has surged across the country because politicians refused to acknowledge the severity of the disease, to increase testing and contact tracing, to give people desperately needed economic relief so they could stay home. Even as the case counts skyrocket, their response has been no response at all: They forge ahead with reopening businesses, public spaces and schools as if nothing is happening. As if people aren’t dying unnecessary, difficult, lonely deaths. At every stage of this slow-motion catastrophe — downplaying the virus, disregarding the advice of scientists, encouraging people to “liberate” themselves from health restrictions, pushing states to reopen too fast, without a plan — the Trump administration and its allies have made one thing abundantly clear: People like my dad are expendable, no matter how they vote. I refuse to let our government officials wash their hands of our suffering.

There are probably tens of thousands of stories just like that of Mark Anthony Urquiza. Americans that usually voted Republican, tuned in to watch Hannity, and believed it when Donald Trump and the GOP governors told them that masks were a Liberal plot to take away individual liberty and that 'the cure can't be worse than the problem'. I wonder when, and even if, the enormity of the destruction they have wrought will sink in.
 
Governor, my father’s death is on your hands

dbd21c8a-b354-40f3-bb31-8a53425a9ca0.jpg



There are probably tens of thousands of stories just like that of Mark Anthony Urquiza. Americans that usually voted Republican, tuned in to watch Hannity, and believed it when Donald Trump and the GOP governors told them that masks were a Liberal plot to take away individual liberty and that 'the cure can't be worse than the problem'. I wonder when, and even if, the enormity of the destruction they have wrought will sink in.

If only Kristin Urquiza's father had lived in a state run by a Democratic governor who had taken it seriously and ordered mandatory mask-wearing and business closure. Had that been the case, it is a 100% certainty that he would be alive today. Sadly, as the science has proven, this virus can only infect and only kill people who live in states run by Republican governors.
 
Governor, my father’s death is on your hands

dbd21c8a-b354-40f3-bb31-8a53425a9ca0.jpg



There are probably tens of thousands of stories just like that of Mark Anthony Urquiza. Americans that usually voted Republican, tuned in to watch Hannity, and believed it when Donald Trump and the GOP governors told them that masks were a Liberal plot to take away individual liberty and that 'the cure can't be worse than the problem'. I wonder when, and even if, the enormity of the destruction they have wrought will sink in.
November 3rd.

I'm originally from Missouri. There's an old saying there, "to get a mule's attention sometimes requires a 2x4." It applies to elephants, too. While I'd prefer prosecutions for criminal recklessness, we'll have to content ourselves with voting.
 
Last edited:
Governor, my father’s death is on your hands

dbd21c8a-b354-40f3-bb31-8a53425a9ca0.jpg



There are probably tens of thousands of stories just like that of Mark Anthony Urquiza. Americans that usually voted Republican, tuned in to watch Hannity, and believed it when Donald Trump and the GOP governors told them that masks were a Liberal plot to take away individual liberty and that 'the cure can't be worse than the problem'. I wonder when, and even if, the enormity of the destruction they have wrought will sink in.

Ducey said that in May? How stupid is he?
 
If only Kristin Urquiza's father had lived in a state run by a Democratic governor who had taken it seriously and ordered mandatory mask-wearing and business closure. Had that been the case, it is a 100% certainty that he would be alive today. Sadly, as the science has proven, this virus can only infect and only kill people who live in states run by Republican governors.
While obviously fallacious, and intended to be cynically sarcastic, it is far too close to the truth.
 
If only Kristin Urquiza's father had lived in a state run by a Democratic governor who had taken it seriously and ordered mandatory mask-wearing and business closure. Had that been the case, it is a 100% certainty that he would be alive today. Sadly, as the science has proven, this virus can only infect and only kill people who live in states run by Republican governors.

Yeah, we should all live in the state of NY... Now there's a mayor who got it right.
 
Was this the same time in May that Trump was needling governors to open their states?

Or in the same May when Eric Trump was calling COVID a Democratic hoax?
 
While obviously fallacious, and intended to be cynically sarcastic, it is far too close to the truth.

Are you pointing us to the truth shown to us by NY's Democratic governor, Mario Cuomo?
 
Ducey is such a punk.
 
He is really, really stupid. Like licking the windows level stupid.

How could he say that in May when it was clear that the virus was bad?

Because Trump told him to? Because he was following the lead of Trump's stupid son? Irresponsible, especially in a state with a very large population of seniors.
 
Governor, my father’s death is on your hands



There are probably tens of thousands of stories just like that of Mark Anthony Urquiza. Americans that usually voted Republican, tuned in to watch Hannity, and believed it when Donald Trump and the GOP governors told them that masks were a Liberal plot to take away individual liberty and that 'the cure can't be worse than the problem'. I wonder when, and even if, the enormity of the destruction they have wrought will sink in.

Interesting.

I'm not familiar with Mr. Urquiza's case. Was he, for some reason, unable to isolate himself from everyone else? Did people without masks come sneaking into his home to breathe on him? If his daughter really loved him wouldn't she have restrained her father as she wishes the government restrained all the rest of us? Why is it that the daughter was unwilling to do that which she expected government to do for him?
 
Governor, my father’s death is on your hands

dbd21c8a-b354-40f3-bb31-8a53425a9ca0.jpg



There are probably tens of thousands of stories just like that of Mark Anthony Urquiza. Americans that usually voted Republican, tuned in to watch Hannity, and believed it when Donald Trump and the GOP governors told them that masks were a Liberal plot to take away individual liberty and that 'the cure can't be worse than the problem'. I wonder when, and even if, the enormity of the destruction they have wrought will sink in.

Politicizing a virus actually has human consequences. Who could have known?
 
If only Kristin Urquiza's father had lived in a state run by a Democratic governor who had taken it seriously and ordered mandatory mask-wearing and business closure. Had that been the case, it is a 100% certainty that he would be alive today. Sadly, as the science has proven, this virus can only infect and only kill people who live in states run by Republican governors.

While obviously fallacious, and intended to be cynically sarcastic, it is far too close to the truth.

Yeah, we should all live in the state of NY... Now there's a mayor who got it right.

Sure, Cuomo and Belasio got it wrong at first too. They were behind CA by whole 2 days when they shut down the state and the city. And yes, virus had spread there much more than it did in CA by then, but of course noone knew at the time thanks to crap testing (thanks Trump)

Then, however, they got it right and had the right messaging.

Trump and some (not all) GOP governors had the wrong messaging most of the way through.

There are plenty of people, Dems and Reps in all states. Heck, California has more Republicans than any other state of the Union. So, when people hear different messages, enough of them do NOT comply.

As a result, we got worst virus response across the civilized world.

So yes, it's on Trump, Ducey, Kemp, DeSantis, and the rest of them.

If his daughter really loved him wouldn't she have restrained her father as she wishes the government restrained all the rest of us? Why is it that the daughter was unwilling to do that which she expected government to do for him?

I see. The right wingers expect children to restrain their healthy and vibrant 65-year-old parents when it suits them. Good one.
 
Last edited:
Politicizing a virus actually has human consequences. Who could have known?
I'm actually serious about a criminal charge: ARS §13-1201 provides:
Endangerment; classification

A. A person commits endangerment by recklessly endangering another person with a substantial risk of imminent death or physical injury.

B. Endangerment involving a substantial risk of imminent death is a class 6 felony. In all other cases, it is a class 1 misdemeanor.
This is a textbook case - "Reckless conduct" occurs when a person exhibits extreme indifference to human life or the risk of serious injury. In May it was well established that COVID was frequently fatal. Ducey (and Trump) was extremely indifferent to that reality, and, essentially, condemned a quantity of Arizonans to death with his behavior.

Now, I am fully aware that the Governor can't/won't be prosecuted for his conduct, but it should be phrased in that manner to elucidate just how reckless and callous his behavior was and remains.
 
9dda893ef5e54f4f93cff87050d26f6e.png


Those tweets pushed the southern red state governors to open their states up all the way.

We are still seeing the results of those Trump tweets today in those record setting COVID states.
 
Here's another one....from NE Texas....Louie Gohmert's neck of the woods...


EeeX9KkXkAIdrrr



"....and may Karma find you all!"
 
Last edited:
Politicizing a virus actually has human consequences. Who could have known?

It is almost as if reality does not respond to the earnest wishes of Trump and his fans.
 
Here's another one....from NE Texas....Louie Gohmert's neck of the woods...


EeeX9KkXkAIdrrr



"....and may Karma find you all!"

Man, they are pissed. I would be, too. I already am.
 
Was this the same time in May that Trump was needling governors to open their states?

Or in the same May when Eric Trump was calling COVID a Democratic hoax?

It was the same time in May when Gov Cuomo was still saying there was nothing wrong with sending COVID patients to live in nursing homes...
 
Back
Top Bottom